Are most filters providing serious overkill when it comes to biological media?

So, seriously, does anyone really need a half a canister full of Substrat Pro on an Aquarium? Is that just overkill?

Like said above, "need it"? Probably not. Depending on your setup, a half canister full of a few dollars worth of plastic pot scrubbers or pennies worth of pea gravel will provide the same service as expensive store bought bio medias.

To me, the biggest advantage to having 'more' than you need is to have the ability to setup a new tank instantly.

Another thought is, is there a point of having an amount of bio media so large, that your mechanical media can't keep it clean of solid debris? On an oscar board I frequent, there's folks there that remove and replace a portion of their bio media, every time they service their canister filters. The claim is the pores in the bio media become clogged with dead bacteria and debris over time and thus reduce it's surface area for BB to colonize.

They basically boil the old stuff and put it back into rotation. I do not have the ambition to join that movement at the moment.
 
Can a tank have to many plants? Oh wait wrong topic though I suppose it could be related. Only in this case the bio media isn't in the filter but in the tank. Lots of surface area, at times the older parts are discarded. I don't think boiling the old stuff would help anything, unless you are trying to make a soup.

Perhaps could have kept out of this since I don't really have anything to add, but the mixture of the ideas of function of plants and mechanical bio media was amusing to me.
 
AquariaCentral.com