I want a Jack Dempsey...

I had 4 Jack Dempsey's originally, but 3 were female and 1 is a male. They were originally all in a 37G tank from the start, but eventually the male picked one female as his mate and they beat up the other 2 females. I took those two and put them in a 10G tank, but the smaller of the two died about a week later because the larger of the two decided that it wanted all of the tank to itself. The second female died only about a week ago, after living in that tank for over 4 years on its own. The breeding pair are still alive and seemingly well, although the male still beats on his female partner sometimes.
The breeding pair did breed, many times in fact. The heater was recently turned down on their tank so they would no longer breed, because all they would do was consume their offspring. Jack Dempsey's can be very interesting fish, but mine didn't seem to get along. Proceed with caution if keeping multiple ones in a single tank.
 
I had 4 Jack Dempsey's originally, but 3 were female and 1 is a male. They were originally all in a 37G tank from the start, but eventually the male picked one female as his mate and they beat up the other 2 females. I took those two and put them in a 10G tank, but the smaller of the two died about a week later because the larger of the two decided that it wanted all of the tank to itself. The second female died only about a week ago, after living in that tank for over 4 years on its own. The breeding pair are still alive and seemingly well, although the male still beats on his female partner sometimes.
The breeding pair did breed, many times in fact. The heater was recently turned down on their tank so they would no longer breed, because all they would do was consume their offspring. Jack Dempsey's can be very interesting fish, but mine didn't seem to get along. Proceed with caution if keeping multiple ones in a single tank.


Do ya think 2 JD's in a 10G tank had ANYTHING to do with it?
 
What if I introduced a baby Jack Dempsey after Gourami and Killifish were moved?

that would leave the JD with:

a huge redtail shark, about 6 inches, mean, too fast to be caught anyways

a school of madagascar raindows, also super fast

a black ghost knife....most fish don't mess with them and they get really big

the pictus cat.. which aadvark had sucess with

gold nugget pleco
 
a huge redtail shark, about 6 inches, mean, too fast to be caught anyways
Should be ok

a school of madagascar raindows, also super fast
not sure, but Id say they would be food once the JD got bigger

a black ghost knife....most fish don't mess with them and they get really big
Definatly not compatable. Even though the BGK can get big, it is territorial, and Blindness will not allow it to tell the difference between food and a threat. In any case, even a 72 gallon is too small for this fish. Even a 120 gallon will barley hive it room to turn arround when full grown.
the pictus cat.. which aadvark had sucess with

gold nugget pleco

Should be fine.
 
AquariaCentral.com