just so confused on fish choice

salty420

this fish was coming on to me
Mar 8, 2007
1,931
0
0
47
Sugar Grove, IL
i have gone back and forth on what fish to stock in my 75g. i have come up with my final stock list about 10 times now. i just can't seem to make up my mind on my focal/main fish or whatever you call it. i need advice, pros/cons...

for those who don't know here's my current stock list
2 bk/wt clowns
1 pj cardinal
1 royal gramma
1 blue neon goby
1 orange-back fairy wrasse

i plan on adding
1 midas blenny
1 green (yes green now) clown goby

and here's where the dilema comes in. all along i planned on adding 2 dwarf angels, a potters and an african flameback. then i decided no on the potters after doing some reading on how delicate they are and no on the flameback because i don't want any more yellow in the tank. so then i decided to go with a coral beauty. then i decided why am i going to risk an angel at all in my reef am i dumb..? so after talking to my lfs they said get a tang... my husband wants a
regal tang - i am VERY leary of this! i think they are #1 too big, #2 too prone to disease (expecially in a smaller tank). one of my lfs has a beautiful small regal that we were looking at today and we really liked it. the owner of the store was telling us that his tanks are all basically QT tanks (copper treated water), we could take the fish home and put him in our display and he could pretty much guarentee it would break out in ick. then we watched this perfect healthy looking fish rub on the rocks. - which is why i'd prefer a tang at least a little hardier like a -
kole tang or a
purple tang
or go back to the angel idea and go with something like a swallowtail. BUT i would really like a bright colored, swimming around a lot kinda fish so i don't know that the swallowtail would fit the bill (not so colorful..?)
what do you all think? do you have any suggestions for me.. PLEASE :wall:
 
Well, if you can find a healthy C. potteri, I think you may be happiest with it. I have had mine for a few years--the trick is to find one that readily eats and acts normally otherwise. The other trick is to supply LOTS of algae. I purposely leave the glass dirty to accomodate this.
 
I have experience with a purple tang in a 75G and it did not work out well. Lasted just a few months longer than a yellow tang, about 18 months. It was the only tang in the tank, purple replaced yellow when it died. Just from watching it you could tell a 75G was way to small for it. I will admit, the tank has never been what I would consider "well maintained" though and I am sure that had quite a bit to due to its death. I have no experience with a kole tang though.
 
sorry to be off topic, lfs use copper so their fish dont get disease right? and when they come to us, they get it cause we dont use copper?

i dont know if you like wrasses, i like them and be getting more soon later on.
 
lets see

lemarki angel
japanese swallowtail angel
singapore angel
purple tang
firefish
bangaiis
mandarin-6 months or more
midas blenny possible
sixline wrasse- i love mine he dosent pick on anyone in my tank
clwon gobies- i have 2 green if you want them:) and im not kidding
starry blenny
lawnmower blenny
chromis
dartfish
watchman goby
kole tang
yellow tang
flame angel
and im all out
hope you like some of them those are all some of my favorite fish
 
yes, many lfs treat their tanks with copper so they are basically QT tanks - but not all. and i do like wrasses but don't really want a tank full of them, i think i'm just going to stick with the 1 fairy wrasse...
as far as the potters goes... i really really like this fish and can get one a healthy specimen locally. but i don't want to have a bunch of algae on my glass amphiprion!
 
How about 200g tank, get them all? No? Well, I think you could do the Kole in there but it probably comes down to which you want more and which risk you're willing to take. The Kole possibly needing an upgrade or the Angel possibly having an appetite for coral.
 
lemarki angel not out of the question just wish it was a little more brightly colored
japanese swallowtail angel same as above
singapore angel hmm that's a possiblity hadn't seen that one before
purple tang
firefish can't have these - last one was harrased to death by royal gramma
bangaiis already have a pj looking for swimmers
mandarin-6 months or more
midas blenny possible this one is a FOR SURE
sixline wrasse- i love mine he dosent pick on anyone in my tank NO
clwon gobies- i have 2 green if you want them:) and im not kidding send one my way :)
starry blenny and
lawnmower blenny im
chromis out
dartfish of
watchman goby room for more fish im afraid
kole tang
yellow tang too much yellow tho if i wasn't getting the blenny i'd get this guy
flame angel
and im all out
hope you like some of them those are all some of my favorite fish
thanks aj
 
AquariaCentral.com