Mafia 100-The Witches Return-The Game

[[AC] RICKETS]

If that's the best consideration I'm going to get at this point, I'll take it.

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

You have lots and lots of time to show me Star's posts through the game that illustrate them being a witch. Lots of time.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

Yes, but I can't stay here playing mafia all day. I need to go. That's why I put a tentative vote in before leaving.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

I should be back in a couple of hours.

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

Rickets, can you also tell me why, yesterday, you were all over Fire, me and eventually scoop. You had no thought of star being a witch. That should be an easy question to answer.

Again though - show me your case on star.

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

Yes, but I can't stay here playing mafia all day. I need to go. That's why I put a tentative vote in before leaving.

You've been plenty active to go about your efforts to uncover a witch but you havn't done it.

I will come back on thread in an hour and a half. I won't be around for longer than a half hour. At this point in time you should assume you're getting my vote.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

You've been plenty active to go about your efforts to uncover a witch but you havn't done it.

I will come back on thread in an hour and a half. I won't be around for longer than a half hour. At this point in time you should assume you're getting my vote.

Wow. That was harsh Nemesis. And unnecessary.

You have no idea what my schedule is yet you feel I deserve to get barked at and given a fixed ultimatum just because I can't stay here without interruption. I just shuffled things around so I could come back to the thread. I don't see anyone else bothering to even try anymore but do you hassle them or suspect them for remaining quiet? Apparently not.

Forget it, Nemesis. Figure out who the last witch is all by yourself.

Your mind is made up anyway. Vote me and be done with it.

------------

To everyone else:

I am comfortable with my vote where it is on Star.

My 2 top suspects for last remaining witch are Star and Fire.

Based on what I've reviewed last night and today, I am convinced that Cnote is innocent... Nemesis is innocent... and Wingnut is innocent in appearance only.

This is important: Do not kill Wingnut. They count on the town side in terms of number so we need them alive. At the same time we should not trust them or believe what they tell us. They are loyal to the witch team only and not the town. Given any opportunity to do so, Wingnut (as an innocent) will betray the town. I have no doubt about that.

I have other things I put off that still need to get done so I'll go. And I'll return as soon as I can.

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

Big slip up by Rickets :-

My question :-

Rickets. Are you saying you think Star was a witch since the start of the game.

Ricket's answer :-

No, I've trusted Star through most of the game. Well, actually I have gone back and forth a few times but I trusted her for the most part.

^ Rickets is definitive, and says No, they're not saying star was a witch from the start.

Rickets realises the problem.

Oh wait. I misread the question. Sorry. Just a sec. Be right back.

I respond.

OK...waiting for your next post.

Rickets readjusts. They think it is simply 'very possible' star has been a witch all along.

I think it's very possible Star has been a witch all along. She has just been very active the whole game so it's hard to go through all of her posts in the time we have before night.

My thoughts :-

1. Rickets was all over fire yesterday, then me. There are votes on star but not either of me or Fire. Vote on Star is opportunistic, objectively.

2. Rickets makes no effort to build a case against star. Its eh...too hard...

3. The big mistake. For Rickets to be innocent, Star can't have been a turn, because for Rickets to be innocent, the random event was their scum turn spell, not a turn of townie to witch. They answered the question I asked above too quickly and slipped up big time.

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

Oh yeah and by the way I was not harsh or barking at you - I was completely fair. I told you when I'd be back, and exactly where you stood - total transparency.

And your reaction 'figure out who the last witch is all by yourself' is completely unhelpful to the town.

I get a sense that you can't be bothered to try and show a case against star because you know it isn't there and that your race is just about down - so you don't want to put in any effort. You're giving up.

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

sorry I said 'there are votes' on star in reality there's just c-notes vote. But the point is that star represents Rickets only chance of not being burnt so to start saying now that star is scum is opportunistic.