Mafia 100-The Witches Return-The Game

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Of course it had something to do with the fact that I was in the lead to get burned. I guess I felt that was a given. You have played mafia before I take it. What would have you done? Really, what would have you done if you were in my shoes with a little over an hour left? Would have you just get burned? Let's say I did nothing? Then what. Is that what you would have done? Nothing? It was day one. So where do you stand on Hammer stating that they are sure that Wiz is scum? Are you going to vote for Wiz? Hammer? Me? Do you have a better choice? Are you just going to wait and see if someone else brings a better suspect? Over 20 hours into day two, Hammer has a gut feeling and you think he just needs some Pepto Bismol? I don't think he is joking.

Please answer my direct question, what would have you done in my shoes?

First off, take a deep breath and settle down a bit.

Second, I never once said that I wouldn't do what you did. As an innocent (assuming you are innocent) it statistically makes the most sense to save yourself. I pretty much implied that TWICE when I told HH that given the votes it makes sense why you changed to tie it up. In case you missed that it was posts #210 and 216. The only hesitation I have is that it still doesn't mean you are, in fact, innocent and if not you helped kill a known innocent.

What I didn't understand is why you chose Driver. When you answered that you made no mention of saving yourself, so I asked. I would have thought that would have been the primary motivation.

As for the Pepto bismol joke, maybe you just need to lighten up. Right now you seem awfully jumpy. I don't have any great suspects although if I had to choose right now I probably would pick between you and HH, simply because hardly anyone else is even posting. The other that posting are have not seemed suspicious enough yet.

I still don't see the case on Wiz, especially from the standpoint of your vote yesterday. I could see a slim possibility of those that voted you trying to direct attention away from Wiz, but at the same time the way the situation played out I don't see that as likely. At least not to the extent that HH is suggesting.

 

[[AC] C-note]

Sorry about the sign in mix ups everyone!! I didn't actually write down who I sent what names too, and I deleted the PMs after I sent them so I wouldn't have names attached in my head to alias names. That made it pretty hard to send new PMs when I realized ones I had messed up on :wall:

Vote count so far....

Narwhal-(1)- Hammerhead
Chupa-(1)-Wizard
Rickets-(1)-Chupa
Wizard-(2)-Tree, Fire
Tree-(3)-Wingnut, C-note, Driver8
Mael-(1)-Gunslinger
Doomsday-(1)-HIIQ
Gun-(1)-Narwhal
Driver8-(1)-Star
Wingnut-(1)-BadHaggis
HIIQ-(1)-Dooms
C-note-(1)-Mael
Fire-(1)-Nem

I vote to burn tree hugger at the stake.

Didn't notice I had it wrong.

Is it strange to anyone else?

This correction came 3 1/2 hours after the offending post. Nobody in the thread called you out on it but you thought to go back and check your wording anyway? Any reason for that? It looks like LG counted it anyway.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

Okay somewhat caught up. I skimmed to get the jest of what is going on and will go back and get a better read later when the kids are in bed.

I noticed not many commented on the spell.



Sounds like Warlock spell number 3 to me. Spell #3 - forces a player to not vote at all and not have any consequences happen.

So we know that person can't UD. If a witch got this spell they could lay low or actually not even post at all knowing we don't vote UDs,so we need to keep this in mind.





My post was 4 minutes after Trees vote, do you really think I read and reacted? I wrote my vote and was trying to think of something clever to write after it. I didn't even know Tree had voted yet.

I don't know why Doom is protecting me, it always makes me uneasy when someone sticks up for me anytime in the game but on Day 2 it really makes me wonder. Doom is one I plan on looking more into. No one should be excusing anyone at this point and usually the ones excusing are the ones that need to be looked into the most.

Once again I'm not excusing you or trying to protect you from anything. All I am trying to say is that I don't think you stepped in on Wiz's behalf. When HH floated the idea out there that you and/or Cnote protected Wiz I saw something I disagreed with and questioned. That is all.

I'm not going to turn around and say that I think you are innocent either. That's simply not the case. I just do not agree with HH's current assessment of your role, based on the information given that is...

 

[[AC] wing nut]

Is it strange to anyone else?

This correction came 3 1/2 hours after the offending post. Nobody in the thread called you out on it but you thought to go back and check your wording anyway? Any reason for that? It looks like LG counted it anyway.

Besides that I posted at the same exact time stamp as the vote tally?

I was catching up and noticed everyone else had written it the other way so to make sure it counted I changed it to the correct wording.

Looks like you are reaching a little bit Cnote, nervous that you are being looked at and trying to deflect much?

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

I had the same initial thought as Tree when I read Wizard's vote post.

*I vote to burn Wizard at the stake.*

Fire, maybe you could explain why you agreed with Tree's vote on Wiz. It doesn't appear that many people did, based off who has actually voiced an opinion.

 

[[AC] narwhal]

Is it strange to anyone else?

This correction came 3 1/2 hours after the offending post. Nobody in the thread called you out on it but you thought to go back and check your wording anyway? Any reason for that? It looks like LG counted it anyway.

I did not notice, seems to me it means he did not pay all that much attention when he typed it, came back later and saw that it was incorrect and changed it. I generally go back to my last post when reading that way I do not miss anything.

 

[[AC] wing nut]

Once again I'm not excusing you or trying to protect you from anything. All I am trying to say is that I don't think you stepped in on Wiz's behalf. When HH floated the idea out there that you and/or Cnote protected Wiz I saw something I disagreed with and questioned. That is all.

I'm not going to turn around and say that I think you are innocent either. That's simply not the case. I just do not agree with HH's current assessment of your role, based on the information given that is...

I accept that for now, I still need to reread and absorb when its quieter in here to make a more accurate assessment.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

Given the vote count does it really seem all that difficult to see why they changed votes?

The only thing that escapes me is why Driver was the one chosen to switch to...

What switch would have made you feel more comfortable?

Doom, I will try this again. If you were in my shoes, what would have you done? Who would have you switched your vote to? Why?

 

[[AC] wing nut]

You sure do offer up explanations for players a lot. Are you a latcher?

 

[[AC] wing nut]

My last post was to Narwal