Mafia 100-The Witches Return-The Game

[[AC] C-note]

How in Bala's name could they be teammates? You think there are 2 left? Pardon my acronym, but wtfudge? And Star? *smh*

You see, they are not literally team mates in the sense that they are both witches. But since wing is still very much playing for the witches to win they are in effect playing for the same team. wtfcudgesmfhgs hhaks

 

[[AC] C-note]

There is one person here who knows for sure if Wing was identified 100% as scum. If Wing wasn't 100% identified by HH, then there is a chance that wing was a townie who was turned to scum. Is it possible that Wing was a townie and wanted to draw the turn spell onto themselves so they could be a scum player. That would make wing the last scum player.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

There is one person here who knows for sure if Wing was identified 100% as scum. If Wing wasn't 100% identified by HH, then there is a chance that wing was a townie who was turned to scum. Is it possible that Wing was a townie and wanted to draw the turn spell onto themselves so they could be a scum player. That would make wing the last scum player.

That is a very interesting possibility, Cnote. I know of a player who did that in a previous team-building format game. They weren't happy being "just another innocent townie" so they behaved a certain way hoping the scum team would turn them. And, that's exactly what the scum team did.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

The only problem with that idea, though. I don't doubt Hammer. I don't see why they would've made us believe they had an invest result if they didn't really get one.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

I do have the idea for an approach I can take to come up with a suspect list. That involves pulling a few more posts, though, and I don't have time to do that right now.

Will post more about that when I get back.

 

[[AC] C-note]

The only problem with that idea, though. I don't doubt Hammer. I don't see why they would've made us believe they had an invest result if they didn't really get one.

That's my sticking point as well.

 

[[AC] C-note]

I don't doubt that Tree used the turn on Wing. I don't see any reason why he wouldn't have.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

So, let's say Wingnut was bored with the game as an innocent townie. They wanted the Warlock to turn them to a witch instead. So they acted scummy enough on purpose to make us want to burn them... but before we did that, they threw out the idea that we ask the Warlock to turn them instead... along with an implied promise that the turn would help the town, of course.

The Warlock saw how that would benefit us. A true win-win proposition that also eliminates the risk of turning a townie to witch. I can see why the Warlock would go for it. Plus, not only would the witches be down one but the town would gain one as well.

Tree suggested it to Hammer who talked it over with the other. And just about everyone agreed right away. Anyone who opposed that idea would be suspected. (No wonder so many people wanted to burn me up when I wasn't thrilled about it.)

So Wingnut was turned and has been hostile toward us ever since. In fact, Wingnut commented just yesterday how boring this game was and they wanted it to end. Poor thing, Wingnut must not be having a good time. The activity level in the scumden must have dropped off a lot. And we're not entertaining enough for them.

The problem I have with this theory is I'm still convinced Hammer had a real invest result on Wingnut before the witches hit them.

I'd like to ask everyone what their thoughts are on this idea. Do you think it's possible, likely, or doubtful?

That includes you too, Wingnut. (Unless you'd rather just concede and get this over with.)

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

I'll check in again at lunch.

 

[[AC] xx_Nemesis_xx]

Quoting this post for reference. My comments in blue - I have limited time and this is easier than breaking up the quote :

So, let's say Wingnut was bored with the game as an innocent townie. They wanted the Warlock to turn them to a witch instead. So they acted scummy enough on purpose to make us want to burn them... but before we did that, they threw out the idea that we ask the Warlock to turn them instead... along with an implied promise that the turn would help the town, of course. My comment - this is quite mad if you believe that Hammerhead had an investigation result on Wing to work with.

The Warlock saw how that would benefit us. A true win-win proposition that also eliminates the risk of turning a townie to witch. I can see why the Warlock would go for it. Plus, not only would the witches be down one but the town would gain one as well.

Tree suggested it to Hammer who talked it over with the other. And just about everyone agreed right away. Anyone who opposed that idea would be suspected. (No wonder so many people wanted to burn me up when I wasn't thrilled about it.) My comment - I am just noting here that Tree and Hammer came up with the idea to work the turn spell and these are of course confirmed townies. It was not in other words a witch plan.

So Wingnut was turned and has been hostile toward us ever since. In fact, Wingnut commented just yesterday how boring this game was and they wanted it to end. Poor thing, Wingnut must not be having a good time. The activity level in the scumden must have dropped off a lot. And we're not entertaining enough for them.

The problem I have with this theory is I'm still convinced Hammer had a real invest result on Wingnut before the witches hit them. My comment - yes, it would be astonishing to think that Hammerhead would have claimed an investigation result if they did not.

I'd like to ask everyone what their thoughts are on this idea. Do you think it's possible, likely, or doubtful? Your idea as much as I understand it is that Wing nut was townie turned scum. This ignores the investigation result by Hammerhead. My thoughts on your idea are that it is quite mad.

That includes you too, Wingnut. (Unless you'd rather just concede and get this over with.)