Mafia 101 - Blarney Castle: Return of the Leprechauns - Game Thread

[[AC] Old3Toes]

before i even looked at the thread i knew i was going to pick the person in front of me.

Just so I can get the timeline straight...

You decide to vote the person before you without looking at the thread

You then read the thread

You vote Dawg because you see his post last

Correct?

Hang on.. just saw this.



Well...... okay, AAF. That is one way to pick someone randomly. But let me give you a little advice for future games. Don't decide a random vote that way ever again!

Let's say for the moment that this is true and you are a townie. Voting out someone like Dawg is a very bad choice. If Dawg is innocent, he is extremely valuable to the town. Definitely someone you don't want to help get lynched on Day 1!!! He's very smart at this game and we need him to help us nail scum. Heck, I'd much rather trade 2 or 3 other townies for just one player like Dawg.

Really Kashta? In a numbers game you would trade TWO OR THREE townies for ONE player?

Don't get me wrong, I think Dawg is a solid mafia player. But that is an awfully troubling statement to me. Maybe it would make more sense if Dawg was say a super important PR, but to say that just based on his game play abilities seems like a huge stretch to me.

 

[[AC] Old3Toes]

HUH? Was this clarified somewhere? I was just wondering whether Chill was a communicator or not and I couldn't find it in the thread. The nightfall post just says "Evil Leprechaun".

You're right, my mistake. For some reason in my head I thought Lab said that Chill was the non communicator but he could have been with the team.

That does lower LG on my list then.

 

[allaboutfish]

Just so I can get the timeline straight...

You decide to vote the person before you without looking at the thread

You then read the thread

You vote Dawg because you see his post last

Correct?



Really Kashta? In a numbers game you would trade TWO OR THREE townies for ONE player?

Don't get me wrong, I think Dawg is a solid mafia player. But that is an awfully troubling statement to me. Maybe it would make more sense if Dawg was say a super important PR, but to say that just based on his game play abilities seems like a huge stretch to me.

yup

 

[dirtydawg10]

Dawg -- When you retracted your Fozzy vote to vote Red, thus creating a tie between AAF and Red.... Chill was the only one who had not voted yet. You said you wanted to see if someone might switch or find out which way Chill would vote. At that time, what did you think was most likely from Chill.... that he would break the tie.... or that he would vote someone other than AAF or Red?

I figured Chill would definitely vote and that he would break the tie. If for nothing else I was hoping it would at least cause some discussion. Apparently my vote didn't even do that.

I wondered that too when I re-read her posts but came to a completely different conclusion. To me, it's more of a wash.

Lady G and Chill are good friends who quite often vote each other right off the bat in a lot of games. Kind of an "unless I've got somewhere to vote for real, I'll default to Lady G/Chill" kind of a thing.

Pappy tends to do the same thing defaulting his Day 1 vote to Dangerdoll just the same way.

That being the case, doesn't that make Lady G's vote on Chill inconsequential?

Not sure about her but based on what I see I'll lean her innocent for now. Just because there is not much else to go on right now. Don't get me wrong there aren't any blinders going on for LG either.

I would say that LG's vote doesn't do anything to make me learn her one way or the other at this point. No one except Chill knew he was scum.

I think we just found one I vote to lynch O3T

 

[dirtydawg10]

You're right, my mistake. For some reason in my head I thought Lab said that Chill was the non communicator but he could have been with the team.

That does lower LG on my list then.

It was a mistake and I think you slipped up. Only a scum would think (know) from what Lab wrote that Chill was on his own.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Wizard -- You voted O3T because dinosaurs died out long ago. Was that a random vote or a joke vote?

:rofl: I love this question

 

[Fozzybear]

Okay, I have watched you guys play this for some time now, and have been waiting for the chance to jump in for a whirl. It been very fun so far.


My vote on AAF was mostly random day 1 playing/being dickish. I completely understood that he cold have been completely innocent and reliable with his explaination of his voting. That being said I couldn't decide on somebody else to randomly vote on...AAF it was

 

[jbradt]

It was a mistake and I think you slipped up. Only a scum would think (know) from what Lab wrote that Chill was on his own.

I tend to agree with this. I vote to lynch O3T.

 

[Fozzybear]

hmn...the plot thickens.*Fozzy can't stop looking at Dawg*

 

[jbradt]

hmn...the plot thickens.*Fozzy can't stop looking at Dawg*

So what are your thoughts on the statement in question? Care to elaborate on what in particular you're looking at? Are you implying Dawg is scummy?