Mafia 103...the play

Nepherael said:
Hmm I don't remember you questioning either of us. Unless you consider asking AAF if he was so sure just to keep that dialogue going. And you asked JB a question. So you're saying asking a couple questions but never taking anything past square one is what a real innocent would be doing?

I'm sliding along with JB right? Well he's made some excellent points and really explained his reasoning well. I happen to agree with his reasoning though I can't say I've seen any in depth posts from you describing your thoughts on any important person or situation in particular so why wouldn't I latch onto what seems to be sound reasoning when there's none to be found elsewhere?

These replies are just digging your hole deeper to me
Click to expand...

I asked several questions. You guys where letting logic slide a bit.

Jb's post seem to be based on interpretations of past play, how would you know if he is right or wrong as this is your second game?
 
rich311k said:
I asked several questions. You guys where letting logic slide a bit.

Jb's post seem to be based on interpretations of past play, how would you know if he is right or wrong as this is your second game?
Click to expand...

Well here's where I covered that. What real investigating did you do again?


Nepherael said:
I see JB's reasoning and I applied that to what I've seen from pap in my first and only game (he was an innocent) and he isn't even in the same ballpark this time around. It lines up enough for me to trust my instincts on it.
Click to expand...
 
rich311k said:
That covers it?
Click to expand...

How doesn't it? I explained my reasoning, that I've seen his gameplay previously, and that while it was only once it's different enough this time around to notice a difference, not to mention the fact that there's someone else that noticed that difference also.

Anything else you wanted me to go over?
 
We're you going to elaborate on the actual investigating you did?
 
Nepherael said:
How doesn't it? I explained my reasoning, that I've seen his gameplay previously, and that while it was only once it's different enough this time around to notice a difference, not to mention the fact that there's someone else that noticed that difference also.

Anything else you wanted me to go over?
Click to expand...

Explains why you believe JB about Pap, thin but OK. No mention of me.
 
rich311k said:
I explained it several times to you. I asked questions where needed and read what was going on. I formed my own opinions. You?
Click to expand...

So there's no examples besides the 2 questions we've already discussed? I thought you said there were plenty?

No worries this isn't really going anywhere. I'm sure once the townies go over the points I made and my explanations for why I feel that way and come to their own conclusion. I trust them to make the right decision with all the new content that's been added =)
 
Nepherael said:
So there's no examples besides the 2 questions we've already discussed? I thought you said there were plenty?

No worries this isn't really going anywhere. I'm sure once the townies go over the points I made and my explanations for why I feel that way and come to their own conclusion. I trust them to make the right decision with all the new content that's been added =)
Click to expand...

Sounds like a fine plan. I will go look for the content.
 
rich311k said:
Explains why you believe JB about Pap, thin but OK. No mention of me.
Click to expand...

Oh I see. I'll mention again why I think I've nailed you down because it'll be faster to type than to go find my quotes. First off instead of actually really questioning anyone you just asked AAF if he was really sure about me to egg on our back and forth (and maybe a couple other fluff/shallow questions), then you voted for me with "turning and dodging" as your reason nothing beyond that (thin indeed) except for "it felt forced", followed by 2 votes for pap and you trying to get pap's back by suggesting it was possible for JB and pap to be in cahoots instead of offering much in the way of an opinion about either of their gameplay specifics so far.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom