Mafia 104 - Dawg the Bounty Hunter - The Play

[Ballyhoo]

I vote to lynch Pir for being a Will lacking in nobility.

 

[Kashta]

I'm glad to be back. And yeah, like I said, I will be much more able to be consistently participate than in earlier games.
Thanks >.<
Clarifying was probably a bad word. I was more looking for him to explain it a little bit more, and what he answered was what I thought he meant, I was just wondering.
I thought that maybe, possibly, if you reallly wanted to stretch it that complications in the game could cause some chaos for scum to hide behind. His answer was the one I expected, and was a perfectly acceptable explanation, but if he would have tripped over himself or given a strange explanation, he would have been much more suspicious.

Have you never seen a player use sarcasm? But yeah, it was just a joke.

"What he answered was what I thought he meant, I was just wondering."

Pir, your answer "sounds good" but I don't believe you.

I think you were either trying to make Neph seem suspicious to us or maybe prod him into a flustered response you or others might find suspicious... or possibly just asking a question you didn't really question just pretending to appear helpful.

If you honestly wondered what Neph meant or if Neph wanted to hide behind chaos, I think you would have asked him to clarify his original statement in the context he made it.

Here is Neph's original post.

At least I didn't show up 10 mins before the vote. Rock on guys.

My starting vote is for rbisbop.

That'll probably change. This is an interesting game. A lot to keep track of. I like complications.

The "that'll probably change" part referred to his vote.

The last 3 sentences were talking about this particular game. And I think when we read all 3 statements together, Neph's meaning was clear.

The thing is, when you asked Neph to clarify, you didn't include the full content in your quote.

Why did you prune Neph's remarks from this:

"This is an interesting game. A lot to keep track of. I like complications."

To just this:

"I like complications."

Maybe it's just me, but that doesn't look like an innocent question, even though that's what you say it was.

 

[Kashta]

I won't be here for nightfall so I'll have to vote somewhere.

I vote to lynch Lab Rat.

That is not a real vote, just a placeholder for now so I don't UD in case I can't get back on.

I should be on and off for short times until early afternoon-ish so I hope to check Pir's response if there is one and see what else may develop.

 

[jpappy789]

Kind of a stretch, especially before the first nightfall.

I retract my vote to lynch rb and vote to lynch zaffy

I can't find anything vote worthy,

I vote to lynch Zaffy

for saying "darn tootin"

Interesting how two votes on Zaffy were placed right after each other. Of the two, Neph's strikes me as more suspicious.

Neph, what exactly is your vote for? All you said was "kind of a stretch" about Zaf's post. I'm used to more analysis from you by now.

As for Wiz's vote...the first player to place a second vote (albeit, a joke vote apparently) and it follows the first.

I won't be here for nightfall so I'll have to vote somewhere.

I vote to lynch Lab Rat.

That is not a real vote, just a placeholder for now so I don't UD in case I can't get back on.

I should be on and off for short times until early afternoon-ish so I hope to check Pir's response if there is one and see what else may develop.

After a prototypical Kash "digging" post against Pir you throw a placeholder vote on Lab. Huh? If it's a placeholder, why not just vote Pir now?

 

[Dangerdoll]

for lack of anyone better to go on than to be random, I am gonna place my vote where he had assumed everyone would. I vote to lynch FF. Welcome back to the game, bud.... where are you??

 

[Kashta]

After a prototypical Kash "digging" post against Pir you throw a placeholder vote on Lab. Huh? If it's a placeholder, why not just vote Pir now?

I might vote him, I just wanted to think about it. There isn't much chance his reply is going to resolve anything either so it's where I'm inclined to vote if nothing else comes up.

My only reluctance is tending to look harder at vets in a team building format. For Pir to be scum, Dawg would have had to let the balance of this game rest on him in a critical role or someone would have to have chosen Pir as their first turn. I find both cases unlikely... but still possible I guess.

 

[Kashta]

So many random votes so soon. What happened to discussing pizza toppings? Instead it is about getting crabs? Makes me itch just thinking about it.

Stay safe Labby hate to see you UD before I can vote to lynch you. :dance2:

In case you get a chance to check in during the day.... Wizard, why did you vote Zaffy for tootin' instead of Labby? You do vote Lab sometimes on Day 1 when it's all still random/lighthearted.... and we already know Lab didn't get swept away from Isaac.

 

[jpappy789]

I might vote him, I just wanted to think about it. There isn't much chance his reply is going to resolve anything either so it's where I'm inclined to vote if nothing else comes up.

My only reluctance is tending to look harder at vets in a team building format. For Pir to be scum, Dawg would have had to let the balance of this game rest on him in a critical role or someone would have to have chosen Pir as their first turn. I find both cases unlikely... but still possible I guess.

If his reply doesn't seem to have any chance of clearing things up, that makes it even more interesting as to why you didn't just place your vote their in the first place.

Dawg stated in the rules that his roles were random.

 

[Kashta]

If his reply doesn't seem to have any chance of clearing things up, that makes it even more interesting as to why you didn't just place your vote their in the first place.

Dawg stated in the rules that his roles were random.

I know Pappy. I did start typing up a vote on him too. And random is supposed to be random... and I believe they usually are. I just know as a game mod, I'd be hard pressed not to randomize the assignments a second time if the first run put a player in that role who UDs so often.

You are right though...

I retract my vote on Lab and vote to lynch Pir.

I don't believe what he said is true in response to my question. And I don't have anything more suspicious to go on. I also may not get back again before night. So this vote is unlikely to change.

 

[Chill]

Well it vote changing time as I may not get back before nightfall.
I retract my vote to lynch Jpap.