Mafia 104 - Dawg the Bounty Hunter - The Play

rich311k said:
I also think that I would like to see a name from Dun. We should see what they were thinking or at least what they believe they were thinking. Of course if Dun is scum it will be a lie but that may help down the road.
Click to expand...
*he (Dan) ;)
 
Chill said:
I'm trying to process this Rich. Kash is your strongest suspect. You firmly believe she set Pir up to jump over the edge, but you join her in pushing Dun? I'm having a little trouble reconciling why you'd get behind her if you think she's scum. She's too good a player to push a question that would hurt her team. So if you believe she is likely scum wouldn't that make you suspect of her question as well?

Don't get me wrong I have no problem with Dun answering the question. As you can see I asked him one myself.
Click to expand...

i truly believe she's a good enough player to push a question that could hurt her team and still get away with it. just like i truly believe pappy could form alliances out in the open and still keep a distance from his allies when it comes to vote counts. to add to that, we have a lot of strong players in this particular game that all have their own in-game super powers. i'm thinking of making personalized capes we can all wear during game play. :naughty:

rich311k said:
Why? A good player would ask questions that work, otherwise you would stand out like AAF or a sore thumb. (On an aside why is a sore thumb something that people would pick as standing out?)

Asking Dun for a name and agreeing with Kash that it would be good to hear is not pushing anyone. I think that we have the right, since we all voted to get an idea what Dun was thinking.
Click to expand...

i don't see anything wrong with that. (on your aside... when my thumb is sore i sometimes hold it out and or put it in my mouth to soothe the pain, idk...)
 
I keep going through the thread to find something that sticks out. I think I finally did.

Day 1, Zaffy votes Rich with a reason that I originally took to be a joke in the spirit of most of the Day 1 voting.
Zaffy said:
You had posted a few times already today, what made you choose now to make your 'random*' vote?

I vote to lynch Rich311k




*that's not what random means.
Click to expand...

Zaffy said:
It's because he claimed it to be random, however it doesn't appear to be.
Click to expand...

Zaffy said:
Rich made 3 posts over 2 hours prior to and including his post. The order of posts went; Rich, Pir, Rich, Pir, Bally, Rich(vote) If he was just going to vote the last person who posted he skipped 2 chances to vote for Pir. Besides the fact that choosing to vote for the next poster is non-random anyway. It doesn't feel right to me.
Click to expand...
Then he actually goes on when questioned to defend this vote. No mention of it being a joke or half-joke. Zaffy seems to believe in this vote at this point. He really seems to have put some time and effort into his analysis of what happened.

Zaffy said:
I retract my vote to lynch Rich and vote to lynch Piranha

I choose to live.
Click to expand...
Zaffy changes his vote to survive.

Zaffy said:
No worries guys, I was not turned.
Click to expand...
Then we get this after nightfall.

Zaffy said:
I meant that rich stated his reason for voting Bally was that he voted for the last person who posted. But Piranha posted twice while rich was apparently active.
Click to expand...
More defending of his vote on Rich. Still no mention of it being a joke.

Zaffy said:
The truth is I don't think there's anything to it, but as far as day 1 goes it's better than most reasons.
Click to expand...
Now, after being pressed again about it... Zaffy doesn't think there's anything to it. Why, Zaffy, at no point earlier did you make reference to the fact that this really wasn't much to go on?

When I first read Zaffy's post after nightfall stating that he wasn't turned, I thought it was Zaffy being goofy. Now I tend to think that it's a private joke for the scum den to laugh at. If this is right, I tend to think he was telling the truth about not being turned... that's what would make it funny. So if I am right, Zaffy was scum from the start.

I know it's thin, but it's better than anything else I have atm. IDK how my time will turn out this afternoon/evening, but this is subject to change should something else come up and I have time to get back on.

I vote to lynch Zaffy.
 
Just because I want to make a reply to this, Rich, my sore thumb stands out because I hit it with a hammer (when nailing something or course) and promptly use some less then bland language loudly and aggressively, thus standing out :D

So no one else wants to post their current suspect list?
 
Chill said:
I thought that was clear. Everyone was voting randomly and Zaf made a big deal out of Rich voting randomly. Claiming it wasn't random at all. Zaffy's vote wasn't random it was for a reason. I got the feeling that Zaffy's reason was an attempt to make something out of nothing. Zaffy being Zaffy though it's hard to tell. I might have been wrong (of course we won't know that till we know Zaffy's alignment). At this point if I have to place a placeholder vote it will still be Zaffy till something better comes along.
Click to expand...

Yet you voted for JB...so what came along that was better than Zaffy? From what I can tell you haven't said anything in regards to JB...
 
Two things Chill, 1) You don't have any people you think are the evil guys out of everyone here? Really? 2) When did you start suspecting JB?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom