Mafia 104 - Dawg the Bounty Hunter - The Play

[Kashta]

What I find really interesting, is that Dun and JP have been at each other the entire game. Yet shortly after we lynch an innocent Zaffy, they both come out and vote JB. My case on JB hinged on Zaffy flipping scum.

Maybe we had a very elaborate case of distancing going on the entire game.

My suspicion of JB was linked to Zaffy as scum too at first. Now I'm starting to wonder if JB was just playing with us.

Zaffy was tied for the lynch twice before we finally just piled on him to ensure his lynch.

Maybe that's why JB pulled that stunt with the tied votes in the first place? It did motivate us to kill off another innocent townie and stopped us from looking around for something else that would actually have been worthwhile.

Not to mention the way he bounced around the thread all day cracking jokes and trying to provoke Rb.... that discouraged a few more serious posts too, I'm sure. I know it did for me when I checked in earlier in the day.

 

[Chill]

48

 

[rich311k]

Jb is playing oddly, that was the reason that Zaffy got voted off.

I am thinking that the scum are directing all of his. I am trying to rethink this whole thing we are no where close to getting anyone that I can see.

My vote is on the Wiz but I am very likely to switch somewhere else as that was a gut jerk reaction.

 

[dundadundun]

What I find really interesting, is that Dun and JP have been at each other the entire game. Yet shortly after we lynch an innocent Zaffy, they both come out and vote JB. My case on JB hinged on Zaffy flipping scum.

Maybe we had a very elaborate case of distancing going on the entire game.

W. O. W. !!!

seems to be anything can look suspicious and be misconstrued in this game. if you look back at the votes, i haven't been following the pack at all. i believe zaffy has been sincere the whole game... and definitely did so as of at least D3/D4. nobody else wanted to see it, though... so why waste my time... everyones minds were dead set it seemed. and with so little cooperation from so many pivotal players, who was there to convince?

i still don't trust pappy as far as i can throw him.

but it was one statement from JB that threw zaffy under the bus and made him look scummy to so many. the most obvious statement i've ever seen float by in my time in the mafia games. and now somebody... anybody... thinks there's reason enough not to vote JB?

Wiz... you're setting up to be my third suspect. Did you not see JB playing games and going around in circles for the last 48 hours? did you not see the voting fiasco prior to nightfall before last? did you ignore my warning about JB pulling something funny with that question to Zaffy prior to the vote?

yes... he voted me. i'm fine with that. BUT... he set up a 3 way tie... and 2 (now known) innocents lives hung in the balance due to that 3 way tie... and they're both now gone thanks to that move.

JB is scum... if we all voted right now, i'd be fine with that... i might want 48 hours for the next nightfall, though.

 

[dundadundun]

Jb is playing oddly, that was the reason that Zaffy got voted off.

I am thinking that the scum are directing all of his. I am trying to rethink this whole thing we are no where close to getting anyone that I can see.

My vote is on the Wiz but I am very likely to switch somewhere else as that was a gut jerk reaction.

i think JB's actions have been too obvious for him to think we'll catch on. knowing he's smarter than that gives him the benefit of the doubt. but his actions don't deserve it and i think he's playing us all for fools. i think a vote switch would be in the towns favor tonight. i'm not clearing wiz. i just think we need to go after the obvious distraction/confusion/scum and go from there with a clean slate and some clear heads.

 

[dundadundun]

What I find really interesting, is that Dun and JP have been at each other the entire game. Yet shortly after we lynch an innocent Zaffy, they both come out and vote JB. My case on JB hinged on Zaffy flipping scum.

Maybe we had a very elaborate case of distancing going on the entire game.

also... don't forget I was the only person on JB BEFORE nightfall.

I was the only person that pointed out that it was JBs suspicious activity that led the train on zaffy.​

 

[dundadundun]

What I find really interesting, is that Dun and JP have been at each other the entire game. Yet shortly after we lynch an innocent Zaffy, they both come out and vote JB. My case on JB hinged on Zaffy flipping scum.

Maybe we had a very elaborate case of distancing going on the entire game.

also... don't forget I was the only person on JB BEFORE nightfall.

I was the only person that pointed out that it was JBs suspicious activity that led the train on zaffy.

 

[dundadundun]

I can assure you that Dun and I have not been distancing and I feel like an idiot for getting wrapped up with the Zaffy vote and holding off on voting Dun again. As for Dun following me, I have no clue what he is up to. Maybe he felt like it was an opportune moment to jump on JB before it looked scummy?

But at this point they're still both my top suspects, it's just that Jb's behavior since he was called out for his D3 vote has been so unlike him that I can't see him as an innocent. He's abandoned any motivation to dig and help the town at all. His vote on Kash was icing on the cake.

Even without Zaffy flipping scum, do you really not suspect Jb at all?

don't get too full of yourself, there JP. you're 48 hours late to the party if i'm following you. :screwy:

you're not off my radar that easy, either.

 

[dundadundun]

this should make things a little more convenient...

i feel we're far enough into the game that these may be helpful for someone.

Final Votes Day 1:

0 - JPap - Chill (4)
0 - RB - Pir (46), Neph (66)
0 - JB - Lab (48)
5 - Pir - FF (53), Bally (101), Kash (109), Lab (140), Zaffy (165)
1 - Bally - Rich (78)
0 - Rich - Zaffy (82)
4 - Zaffy - Neph (98), Wiz (99), Chill (112), Pir (164)
2 - Neph - JB (100), JPap (120)
0 - Lab - Kash (103)
2 - FF - Doll (105), RB (119)
0 - Kash - Pir (114)
1 - Doll - AAF (124)

No votes from: Dun (Dun's non-vote has doubled the vote of the opposite team. Only the person's vote that was doubled will know)

Final Votes for Day Two:

1 - FF - Dun (234), RB (354)
1 - Rich - FF (248)
1 - Dun - Zaffy (253), JPap (357)
3 - Neph - Lab (311), Wiz (327), AAF (385)
2 - Zaffy - JB (333), Kash (346)
1 - JB - Chill (337)
2 - Kash - Rich (353), Doll (384)
2 - Doll - Zaffy (389), RB (422)
1 - AAF - Neph (395)

No votes from: Bally

Final Day 3 Votes:

1 - Rich - FF (504), FF (561)
3 - Zaffy - Rich (506), Chill (566), Kash (568)
1 - JPap - Dun (518)
3 - Dun - FF (539), JPap (560), Lab (588), JB (600)
3 - FF - RB (559), AAF (567), Zaffy (597)
1 - Lab - Wiz (580)

No votes from: Bally

Day 4 Votes:

5 - Zaffy - Wiz (636), Kash (644), JPap (680), Chill (712), Rich (717)
1 - JB - Dun (650)
0 - RB - JB (718)
1 - Wiz - RB (721)
2 - Kash - AAF (751), JB (755)

No votes: Zaffy

List of players:

AAF
JPap
JB
Chill
RB
Wiz
Kash
Dun
Rich

Game On!!

Next nightfall is up for debate. 24hrs or 48hrs...majority rules.

 

[jbradt]

this should make things a little more convenient...

i feel we're far enough into the game that these may be helpful for someone.

These will be helpful to someone. But only someone with the right information, who throws out the first two days voting.


I'm only going to say a couple of things here, and then I'm going to largely be gone for the majority of the day.

First, anyone who says my actions led to Zaffy's lynch is overlooking the fact that there was a whole day cycle in which a bunch of you voted Zaffy. Look at the effect of my actions N3... you all had 2 (now known) innocents up for the lynch... and yet you're agitated that I introduced a third player into the mix? Be real folks. I didn't believe either FF or Zaffy were scum, so I put a third choice in there. I wanted to at least have a chance of lynching scum. I know Zaffy and FF well enough that there was no way I was falling for that. Anyone who tells you otherwise is likely to be talking about my BEHAVIOR and overlooking the effects of that behavior. Most of you guys know me well enough that you know I don't do much without reason. Even when that doesn't seem to be the case.

My vote on Kash... what can I say, I like voting for scum.


Last comment: Wiz... reread your first two posts after nightfall again. See if you can't put together a workable theory involving turns, dropped cases, and strange voting patterns.

Good luck townies... we're going to need it.

I vote to lynch Kash. This vote won't change.