Mafia 105: Finding Bigfoot The Game!

Well... Ice, I am seeing the point of your arguments. Definitely not clearing you, but I want to see your input for at least another day. I retract my vote from Ice and vote to lynch AAF.
 
allaboutfish said:
Ice that makes a lot of sense since i voted blob last night, and he was tied to be lynched. Good try though.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
Click to expand...


To many variables to go through but if Blob had the double vote it didn't matter if you voted him or not as he could move to anyone that had 2 votes at the time not to mention a couple of votes hadn't been made yet. It would be a great way to hide your alliance by being able to say what you did. Especially if he is the tree hugger since you lost the ability to hit he becomes expendable.
 
IceH2O said:
Sorry football will always take precedence...Try to fit this in between games..




The JB theory was something I was thinking about. I just posted my thought,never said it was fact. But you shoot it down and then say the same thing as I did about why someone wouldn't just vote there? Also why would JB tell the Hunter to shoot Neph unless he knows he is Bigfoot? Why waste a shot on a hippy when you only have 2? Be easier to watch them and see who they call out and deduce from there then take them out when a case is possible. The dirty hippie will invest as Bigfoot so you can't just shoot willy nilly.
Click to expand...

I breifly forgot about the dirty hippy being a false-invest, so maybe using a shot on Neph (unless he showed as said hippy) wouldn't be the BEST plan, but I still don't see how JB voting Neph would tip off bigfoot even if Neph was hippy. The person who is bigfoot wouldn't necessarily know that JB was going after one of their protectors.

I don't want to make a big deal out of this because I don't think it's a theory with all that much importance, per se, given how much of the orderal surrounding the double vote/invest is hidden from the town. I'm aware that you aren't 100% with your own theory, but I still wanted to make sure I added my input (I didn't "shoot it down" or at least that wasn't my intention). Lab has proven to be a bigger threat given Neph's inexperience with the game so JB could have focused more on finding bigfoot if he thought that was more important.

Personally, I don't see much coming out of this discussion anyways...perhaps I shouldn't have brought it back up in the first place.


allaboutfish said:
No maybe a vet would do that but i definently wouldnt be able to.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
Click to expand...

Look up what a WIFOM (wine in front of me) sitaution is...you've pretty much defended yourself with a textbook example of one.
 
blobdabob said:
Did you ask?


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
Click to expand...

If you're so sure of who the remaining hippies and bigfoot are, then you shouldn't have to be asked.

Really, people shouldn't have to pry any helpful information from you at all.

I keep wanting to give you the benefit of the doubt, but we're at a point in the game where your inexperience just becomes a convinient excuse for your anti-town gameplay.
 
jpappy789 said:
Here's a summary of my thoughts...






Chem- while also new, it's been bugging me that they have latched on to so many of my ideas. I could easily see the scum team telling a new player to basically follow vet players Lab, JB, myself or Ice (if he's innocent) and Chem's certainly done that in regard to my posts. While the piggy-backing bothered me, it also is weird that they then turned around and accused me of being too unemotional with my posts.
Click to expand...
this is really getting on my nerves, yes its my first game. but im not allowed to do good my first game? i love how people assume i have to be coached to develop such a strategy. everything you said the first two nights made sense jpap. so agreeing with you was easy to do. however after the fact that following you resulted in two innocents dying i had to question: why is jpap so mechanical in his thinking. it just seemed odd to me that you showed little emotion. i never said i was overly suspicious but now im questioning your motives jpap. unfortunately it looks like aaf is going to die. so my vote really doesnt matter at this point it seems. i was trying to wait as long as i could to make the best choice from all the info that has been discussed. i mean aaf seems a bit suspicious to me, but really jpap is at the top of my list. but i have no feeling in my gut telling me aaf is up to anything. his behavior seems pretty normal for him from what ive seen in the regular forums.
 
and after reading more blob is really starting to make me think he has something to hide. and ice is definately on my radar. so maybe i should just make a list.
jpap- live ive already said, very mechanical, very logical, but almost too much so. i just have a gut feeling that something is up with him.
blob- non responsive, and seems very short with replies, possibly hiding something, possibly not.
ice- im still kinda out on this one,i have an inkling of scummy but not top choice. still watching.
pir- mr orangatan is still on my radar. but lately has been overshadowed by alot
neph- still unsure about him. he i had a feeling about him but maybe i was persuaded too much by jpap. he seems like hes legitimately just trying to survive. cant tell if its because he really is innocent or just wanting it to come off that way.
chill- hasant said much, but did try to correct my grammar. that didnt sit well with me as i had a horrible english professor that was an old hippy. makes me wonder.
aaf- seems somewhat scummy but also just seems like aaf.
so as of now my top 3 are
blob
jpap
ice
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom