Mafia #12

[plantling]

I vote to lynch Charlie

He is way too quiet. Probably just threw a vote in today to have a vote. Also he didn't react at all when people started talking about him...very unlike innocent Charlie...

I agree w/you that it's very unlike him not to respond to people's accusations. Of course now he will prolly come full force at me for voting for Lady G as others have, but have at it. I think though if the Mafia want me they may not want to start the train so as not to be left holding a string if I'm lynched. Of course they could always vote and then jump off when the train is taking off.

Anyway I will probably vote Charlie later unless someone more suspicious comes to light.

 

[Rbishop]

You obviously didn't find any substance in my posts, but if you or others go back and really read them you would see I was asking pple questions trying to get answers. I prefer the subtle method as opposed to the in your face questions that get people's heckles raised more than answers.

It appears you are a tad bit protective of Sovran. Is there a reason?[/quote]

Nope, not protective of anyone except myself. It is just a comparison of post counts and what I feel is substantive in them, plant.

Content in a post is up to each one's descretion, but calling someone out solely on quantity is up to criticism. Sovran could just as easily be distracted with personal issues personal issues as you allude to. Thats all.

 

[Rbishop]

For right now, I will set a vote, that is highly likely to change, until we hear more.

With this being a football excuse day like last week, it doesn't appear there is going to be a lot of activity. Especially with nightfall just at 9 PM cst tomorrow. Everything will happen quickly around the football scedule which normally includes a Monday night game. Could be lots of late voting with little foundation. The sooner we vote, the more chance for discussion.

I vote to lynch Charlie_stubbs...

 

[plantling]

Nope, not protective of anyone except myself. It is just a comparison of post counts and what I feel is substantive in them, plant.

Content in a post is up to each one's descretion, but calling someone out solely on quantity is up to criticism. Sovran could just as easily be distracted with personal issues personal issues as you allude to. Thats all.

I didn't call her out solely for the quantity of her posts. This is from my list:

My list:
Sovran-Very little posting and as I've stated before was much more helpful in Game 4 when she was an innocent

If you went over her posts, as you did mine, most of them are just jokes and such. In Game 4 she actually had suspect lists. It doesn't take that long to make up a suspect list. Though you think little of my posts, I asked questions to those I felt were suspicious and I got my answers. I got something out of them enough to where I had DP leaning innocent as well as Jp now. And others may think I'm guilty for it but I think DD is innocent and Swayde also. You, I'm not so sure on. You don't seem to feel any regret for your Lady G vote.

 

[Rbishop]

Plant...don't turn this into an arguement between you and me. I regret the loss of any Townie, and I make my votes early, not jump on a train with 50 minutes left to go in the day and blame things on technical difficulties.

I did go over her and your posts, they were both just an accumalation of jokes with out any substance. You yourself never really gave a list...said you vote one of 3, voted for someone else then did a late switch...despite Sov's lack of your posts, they made a call and stuck beside it, without saying one thing and doing two others...

 

[Swayde]

Man what a slow day. I keep checking back in when I get a chance, but nothing really going on =(

 

[ewurm]

Okay. I am going to go with my hunch on Ewurm. Aside from just my feelings about him, I also do not like the fact that he voted for DP and never removed his vote and then was so "confused" about whether DP was mafia or not even after Ogre explained it.

I vote to lynch Ewurm.

The Miller - this is an unknown role. The Miller player will not know their role and will be told they are innocent. If investigated by the detective, some unseemly gambling debts will come to light and this person will be assumed to be mafia.

This is what had me confused. The miller is told they are innocent, but will assumed to be mafia. I get it now. I think that's a pretty weak reason to vote for me. I guess I'll take my lumps for misunderstanding.

 

[plantling]

Plant...don't turn this into an arguement between you and me. I regret the loss of any Townie, and I make my votes early, not jump on a train with 50 minutes left to go in the day and blame things on technical difficulties.

I did go over her and your posts, they were both just an accumalation of jokes with out any substance. You yourself never really gave a list...said you vote one of 3, voted for someone else then did a late switch...despite Sov's lack of your posts, they made a call and stuck beside it, without saying one thing and doing two others...

I really don't want to argue either, but I have to respond if you're trying to paint me in a bad light. I explained why I changed my vote already. I explained why I did't vote for JP. KotD withrew from the game. JL finally posted but his posts didn't seem as incriminating as Lady's. So if switching my vote to her makes me guilty in your eyes, then so be it.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Ooops. You are right rb, then he voted DD. Zs voted for me later I believe. But Chas actually followed DD, that's what I was trying to get at.

Here are my thoughts on the early voting and some other stuff from yesterday. I think Charlie followed DD to "blend" and possibly create some suspicion on DD. Then the drama between Ice & DD allowed him to fade away with out being called out. I think they hit Ice with the intention of everyone jumping onto DD first thing. This depends on whether they were confident that Jpappy wouldn't be close (if he is mafia) or that they didn't care which of the two went. This does depend on DD being innocent, but the more I think about it the more it plays. Just food for thought.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

The Miller - this is an unknown role. The Miller player will not know their role and will be told they are innocent. If investigated by the detective, some unseemly gambling debts will come to light and this person will be assumed to be mafia.

This is what had me confused. The miller is told they are innocent, but will assumed to be mafia. I get it now. I think that's a pretty weak reason to vote for me. I guess I'll take my lumps for misunderstanding.

Based on the description, I assume that DP was the Miller.