I saw that it was Thanksgiving weekend for him but I still do want more from him and will wait for his reaction when he sees a few votes parked on him.
Mafia #12
- Thread starter OgreMkV
- Start date
So we give a pass to anyone that doesn't supply enough posts to go on? In that case, low post count wins. Everyone, quit posting and we won't question you... bad strategy IMO.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
Ok, well who do you think is mafia? There are 4 or 5 and that puts them at about 1/3 of the town at this point. In the interest of posting our thoughts, I really thought you were looking innocent, but this apparent defense of Charlie has me scratching my head. Also you said something to the effect of "if it's what the town thinks, I'll vote along with you". That really does raise alarm bells for me.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
I already posted my thoughts on who I thought was guilty, you mean to tell me you haven't read them?
The list was
Pappy, still
Sov, still
perhaps mee-mee
The more I think about it, my points on Pappy and Sov were reiterated in one of the very posts you even quoted from me, HN. You scratching your head? You have me scratching mine at this point.
The list was
Pappy, still
Sov, still
perhaps mee-mee
The more I think about it, my points on Pappy and Sov were reiterated in one of the very posts you even quoted from me, HN. You scratching your head? You have me scratching mine at this point.
I have read everything. You name two and a "perhaps" without very specific reasons. Sov may be guilty, but I'd really like to hear what your reasons are for suspecting her over Charlie since neither has really contributed.
OK everyone - back after a long Sunday of horse shows (yes - some of us do do things on a sunny Sunday). I do apologise for my lack of posting as referenced several times. As I previously explained, difficulties getting on the computer make me neither innocent or guilty, just busy on a holiday weekend with both kids at home. However, please feel free to investigate me if you feel the need to.
As to my helping the town - despite the temptation last night, I did not jump on the band wagon for Lady G. I was and am convinced of DD's guilt, and stuck by my vote.
I understand people vacillating between who they perceive to be guilty. Right now, everyone reminds me of a tennis match, with heads swivelling one way and then another. I think we would all be better off listening to our gut instincts and maintaining our votes until absolutly convinced otherwise. Constant changing is muddying the waters, and IMO playing right into the mafia's hands. Obviously we need consensus at night's end, but I would rather listen and process than chop and change.
I myself am strongly leaning to the following suspects, listed in order of certitude:
DD
Plantling
Chas
Cases for Plant and Chas have been made by several people. Plant seems to be very defensive when called on, and yet have nothing substantial to say when asked for her reasons. It almost seems like a "let me get a name out there" play. Chas and DD do seem to be in collusion, though less so now after having been called on it. I can almost see the "outside" mafia chat now!
For now, unless proved completely wrong, my gut feeling still rules, and I vote to lynch DangerDoll
As to my helping the town - despite the temptation last night, I did not jump on the band wagon for Lady G. I was and am convinced of DD's guilt, and stuck by my vote.
I understand people vacillating between who they perceive to be guilty. Right now, everyone reminds me of a tennis match, with heads swivelling one way and then another. I think we would all be better off listening to our gut instincts and maintaining our votes until absolutly convinced otherwise. Constant changing is muddying the waters, and IMO playing right into the mafia's hands. Obviously we need consensus at night's end, but I would rather listen and process than chop and change.
I myself am strongly leaning to the following suspects, listed in order of certitude:
DD
Plantling
Chas
Cases for Plant and Chas have been made by several people. Plant seems to be very defensive when called on, and yet have nothing substantial to say when asked for her reasons. It almost seems like a "let me get a name out there" play. Chas and DD do seem to be in collusion, though less so now after having been called on it. I can almost see the "outside" mafia chat now!
For now, unless proved completely wrong, my gut feeling still rules, and I vote to lynch DangerDoll
man oh man. its been a very long day. i still havent had time to read thoroughly but i have skimmed enough to see whats happening. I will read more after everyone is in bed tonight. I am sorry if i haven't been much help so far, I'm hoping tonight i can find a scumbag, build a solid case, and prove my innocence.
It is interesting to me that Mee Mee hasn't responded to my vote for her. (Unless she did and i missed it.) Maybe she's trying not to be defensive. I agree with JL that enough votes on her will make her crack. She seems like a fine suspect to me. It is alarming that more people aren't discussing her vote for noone, especially after a long first day. Are you telling me she saw nothing suspicious???
It is interesting to me that Mee Mee hasn't responded to my vote for her. (Unless she did and i missed it.) Maybe she's trying not to be defensive. I agree with JL that enough votes on her will make her crack. She seems like a fine suspect to me. It is alarming that more people aren't discussing her vote for noone, especially after a long first day. Are you telling me she saw nothing suspicious???
Oh Charlie... you could have come back with something sooo much better than this. Mee-mee being quiet is a bit odd, but I tend to think that it's because you (and team) told her to quit posting. When has she played differntly? Agreeing with JL is interesting too since both of you have seemingly switched play styles. So, what time does everyone go to bed? I'd like to be here to see your thoughts after you read through.
