Mafia #12

[Dangerdoll]

Innocents in blue. This is back when DD was a popular suspect. I know this is from early on, but it seems a bit suspicious to me since she hasn't voted yet today.

JM- Did you list all innocents or did you throw a teammate that looked like she was going to be voted off onto the list to make yourself credible if she was lynched?

I retract my vote to ynch Charlie and vote to lynch Judgemax.

Eureka!!!! I think HN has found a winner!!!! I believe DD is innocent, which means this is a list of innocents!!! Nice try JM!!! Judge you guaranteed if LadyG was innocent some people better duck and cover??? Which people??? What have you done to fulfill your promise to Lady???

Going to dinner, I will probably not be back till after dinner. That's a pretty damning post against JM, I'd like to see DD comment on it since she is the remaining unknown on that list. But I also think the evidence is strong against ewurm. I will leave my vote where it is but if Tonight goes well for us and I see tomorrow I would not be against voting JM. Of course if she doesn't vote in the next 2.5 hours we won't have to worry about it.

Well well well. Now, reflecting back to when I was mafia, I never even wanted to hint at any of my people in my suspect list for the town to become confused with, but some folks did. My thoughts are perhaps the seasoned players are more apt to putting their own team mates in their lists because they are more sure of being able to change the towns thought after doing so just in case someone does hook onto one of their teammates. I never really had the confidence that I would have the time to sit and defend who ever slyly enough to where it didn't look like I was protecting them. Gah, I hope I am making sense. Bottom line, if Judge is choosing to make a list, it may be full of innocents also, due to this lack of confidence because she hasn't played in quite some time. Then, we look at her not voting. Gosh that makes it look on the bad side too when you are pointed out the whole voting issue, explained why it would be best to vote now and then still not vote. We don't even know who she's is leaning towards the most. We only have seveal guesses from her... meaning it's would be this one or that one.... never a solid solid suspect. Hmmm... that leads back to the whole confidence thing....

 

[Dangerdoll]

well folks, I am off for a bit. I will again try to make it back before nite in case there is something I need to ddo in order to save the twon .... meaning a tie vote or something or if anyone is going to swicth or even find new evidence.... I will be back as soon as I can.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Well well well. Now, reflecting back to when I was mafia, I never even wanted to hint at any of my people in my suspect list for the town to become confused with, but some folks did. My thoughts are perhaps the seasoned players are more apt to putting their own team mates in their lists because they are more sure of being able to change the towns thought after doing so just in case someone does hook onto one of their teammates. I never really had the confidence that I would have the time to sit and defend who ever slyly enough to where it didn't look like I was protecting them. Gah, I hope I am making sense. Bottom line, if Judge is choosing to make a list, it may be full of innocents also, due to this lack of confidence because she hasn't played in quite some time. Then, we look at her not voting. Gosh that makes it look on the bad side too when you are pointed out the whole voting issue, explained why it would be best to vote now and then still not vote. We don't even know who she's is leaning towards the most. We only have seveal guesses from her... meaning it's would be this one or that one.... never a solid solid suspect. Hmmm... that leads back to the whole confidence thing....

Or guilt.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

where are all the missing players???

 

[judgemax]

First off, let me say, I am sorry that I haven't voted recently, I got called to deliver puppies, unfortunately, they called to late, and lost 4, very sad evening for me. I then had to leave and and coach cheerleading.

I retract my vote for Charlie.

I think we may be shooting ourselves in the foot here folks. Ogre said in the sign up thread that roles this game would be chosen at random, I will take that at face value and assume a random number generator was used. Now look at who was killed on Day 1. Ice. They chose Ice, and we lynched Lady G. King quit, and DP died a mysterious death. No power roles were lost. Ice wasn't hammering down suspects like normal, I actually had him on my list leaning Mafia. Why would an experienced Mafia hit someone the Town suspects? Sure, it could be reverse play, but I am beginning to think we have a very inexperienced team of Mafioso's this round that are just planning to take out the most experienced players. The resulting vacuum makes us all go at each other over the littlest details. Who knows maybe Mee-Mee is the Don, it might explain her lack of posting. But should we lynch her if she is going to die mysteriously tonight? I am waiting on her to show up, she has to vote if she wants to live.

JM, plant, I understand what you are trying to do by holding your vote, but it also looks like you are waiting on the rest of the town to make a choice before you join in, that way you can share the glory or divide then blame without commiting early yourself.

I see your point and why you think that way, I guess I am just trying to play more like the game is supposed to be a thinking game.

If I was going to pick a "slacker" Mafia team I would choose ewurm, Mee-Mee, Sovran, judgemax and rbishop?Please don't call me a slacker, I have contributed, as often as I can, I have forgiven most of you for your absences at "odd" times, All I ask is the same respect!

If I was going to pick a "powerhouse" Mafia team I would choose HN, Charlie, swayde, plantling, and johnlarson?

I personally feel the list is closer to the "slacker" scenario than the "powerhouse" but that list doesn't feel 100% correct. There may be one really experienced player, who may or may not be the Don, leading a team of 3 or 4 lesser experienced players. The two players other than myself I left off those lists are pappy and DD because I really haven't a clue how they fall.

No Votes from Mee-Mee or JudgeMax

I will be voting at the end of this.

Innocents in blue. This is back when DD was a popular suspect. I know this is from early on, but it seems a bit suspicious to me since she hasn't voted yet today. seriously?..do you know what your doing?, because you pulled my very first list, we haven't even made it through the first day, ..come on, I can;t help who i thought was guilty, the law of averages says that its almost impossible to choose mafia first day, and as I recall, you were after lady G before me.

JM- Did you list all innocents or did you throw a teammate that looked like she was going to be voted off onto the list to make yourself credible if she was lynched?sure, if thats what you want to think! :lol:

I retract my vote to ynch Charlie and vote to lynch Judgemax.

glad to see someone noticed me, i felt like no one cared i was here!

Eureka!!!! I think HN has found a winner!!!! I believe DD is innocent, which means this is a list of innocents!!! Nice try JM!!! Judge you guaranteed if LadyG was innocent some people better duck and cover??? Which people??? What have you done to fulfill your promise to Lady???

You know what, life got in my way, I am sorry, But I believe that comment was made for DD not lady G, read the posts, and since you weren't here, i assume you were skimming, and now your trying to switch suspicion of you and onto me, I Guess, some of you fell for it, I however am not! I vote to lynch charliewho thinks its so easy to throw stones, and you all watched where the stone went, instead of where it came from.



w

 

[Dangerdoll]

I was wondering where that post was from, HN..... why did you pick the 1st list Judge posted and not one of her later ones?

 

[charlie_stubbs]

last game I thought to myself, "I have a good suspect, but I'll vote later and see what develops first." Things came up that prevented me from returning to vote in time, and i was subsequently killed. Some even speculated that i was disinterested because i had no power role and that is why i did not vote. I learned a valuable lesson that day. Each day I am alive will begin with a vote. Accusations=responses=answers, as Ice would have so fondly put it. Votes can always be changed, and its a good way to get the "lurkers" posting. That being said, I am leaving my vote on MM until she dies an untimely death or until she posts. I hope the players without votes placed will arrive and will not die untimely deaths, unless they are mafia of course.

 

[judgemax]

last game I thought to myself, "I have a good suspect, but I'll vote later and see what develops first." Things came up that prevented me from returning to vote in time, and i was subsequently killed. Some even speculated that i was disinterested because i had no power role and that is why i did not vote. I learned a valuable lesson that day. Each day I am alive will begin with a vote. Accusations=responses=answers, as Ice would have so fondly put it. Votes can always be changed, and its a good way to get the "lurkers" posting. That being said, I am leaving my vote on MM until she dies an untimely death or until she posts. I hope the players without votes placed will arrive and will not die untimely deaths, unless they are mafia of course.

I have never been in that position, I am glad that you are now participating more, but don't downgrade me for playing my way, and don't say I was slacking , because when night fell last night, you were one of the ones who every one thought was a low poster...

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Innocents in blue. This is back when DD was a popular suspect. I know this is from early on, but it seems a bit suspicious to me since she hasn't voted yet today. seriously?..do you know what your doing?, because you pulled my very first list, we haven't even made it through the first day, ..come on, I can;t help who i thought was guilty, the law of averages says that its almost impossible to choose mafia first day, and as I recall, you were after lady G before me.

I know I pulled your first list. Who else would know the innocents on day one besides the mafia? You listed a good amount and one unknown. I found it curious. Wouldn't you? I did vote for Lady G before you. You think that makes you look more innocent?!

JM- Did you list all innocents or did you throw a teammate that looked like she was going to be voted off onto the list to make yourself credible if she was lynched?sure, if thats what you want to think! :lol: When in doubt throw a light hearted smilie in.

Sorry about the puppies

 

[Dangerdoll]

Charlie, do you mean you will look no where else if better evidence comes along? Seem pretty adamant... *sigh*