yes....although I tend to disagree with your philosophy of leaving potential underling mafia in the game in order to concentrate on 'bigger fish'.
Mafia #14 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
yes....although I tend to disagree with your philosophy of leaving potential underling mafia in the game in order to concentrate on 'bigger fish'.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
Well only for now.. If nothing better comes along then I'll shoot.. But I don't think he could fish out one of our Power Roles if he tried... I mean come on when was the last time he posting anything constructive..
Besides there are already better players that I feel are mafia on my list right now.. And why go for the leaves when you can kill the tree at the roots.. ???
Dadgum this has been a busy night. I had dinner and played some WoW and it's taken me an hour to catch up with all the reading.
JM if you are not mafia, you sure are coming across as it. I see a lot of people saying JM is being defensive, but she started the thing with Blue, albeit Blue doesn't seem willing to drop it either. It seems both are just willing to duke it out at the expense of digging out clues on other people.
Charlie also, I haven't seen much of an effort to convince us he's not scum. Way too much fluff posts about being some silly water boy. Careful there Charlie or the crocs Momma warned ya about will get you =)
I have not seen anything out of the ordinary that really jumped out at me from anyone else at this point. I do notice that there are a few people with very little mention because they aren't all that active. DJ, Jens, Mad...not saying I suspect them or anything, just that it would be quite easy for them to slide by. At least Mad's appearing to be helpful.
I'm keeping my vote on DP for now. I don't have a stronger suspicion on anyone else. I'll hopefully have more time tomorrow in the daytime while my son's doing his assignments to go back through tonight's drama and double check it for anything that's naughty or nice.
I am surprised that with the high quantity of posts that went on tonight how little voting was actually done. Lots of people with no votes in as of yet.
JM if you are not mafia, you sure are coming across as it. I see a lot of people saying JM is being defensive, but she started the thing with Blue, albeit Blue doesn't seem willing to drop it either. It seems both are just willing to duke it out at the expense of digging out clues on other people.
Charlie also, I haven't seen much of an effort to convince us he's not scum. Way too much fluff posts about being some silly water boy. Careful there Charlie or the crocs Momma warned ya about will get you =)
I have not seen anything out of the ordinary that really jumped out at me from anyone else at this point. I do notice that there are a few people with very little mention because they aren't all that active. DJ, Jens, Mad...not saying I suspect them or anything, just that it would be quite easy for them to slide by. At least Mad's appearing to be helpful.
I'm keeping my vote on DP for now. I don't have a stronger suspicion on anyone else. I'll hopefully have more time tomorrow in the daytime while my son's doing his assignments to go back through tonight's drama and double check it for anything that's naughty or nice.
I am surprised that with the high quantity of posts that went on tonight how little voting was actually done. Lots of people with no votes in as of yet.
I multi-quote the posts that I want to use, and then cut and paste the one quote into the other. It's a little bit of a pain, so I don't do it that often, but sometimes it helps makes responses clearer.
Well guys its been fun.. I'll be back on in the morning before I have to go to the "big" town of Ellendale ND to upgrade a post office's access to their WAN and install a bunch of new hardware (see my pregame post).. I will try to get my list and thoughts together tonight and post in the am along with my vote.. as I might not be back in time.
nite all.. keep kickin' the bushes.
nite all.. keep kickin' the bushes.
FireDancer7905
I'm in love!
Alot has happened today! No more Heroes chit-chat on this thread! (don't say anything about tonight's epdisode, it's on in a few minutes here. (hurray!)
Anyway, back to the game:
JM: I am flattered to make your mafia list, but I'm not seeing it. I haven't played in so long, I might as well be a newbie.
But....You are all soooo caught up in how people have played in the past. Now, I'm not saying that it's not valid, but really. We're all pretty intelligent people. It makes sense that people will evolve in their game play and style. I have seen changes (if subtle) in the way a few people I played with a few months ago have done so. Social drama at its best (or worst!)
About DP: If mafia, and silent, very dangerous. It can be a great tactic to keep one player "goofy" (for lack of a better term) and below the radar.
About LadyG: The questions you choose to ask confuse me. I don't know why the avatars were important, or the bit about the thred being a sticky forever. These seem to be random points to put focus on minor inconsistencies that have nothing to do with the game.
Clown-lover: OMG! Another new hero!!! hehehehehe!!!!! I'll start a new thread in GCC to chat about the latest developments. No one else I know watches the show.
Mad, Ogre, JL, Hooked, Charlie and the rest of the old vets: Do grudges really live this long? Do suspicions never die? I love watching the haggling, it's almost better than watchng Cheechoo take a swing at a stinking RedWing!
Almost. 
So right now, I'm stck between an OMGUS for JM, just for putting me on the list, and LadyG, for just striking the wrong chord with me. I will decide by bedtime tonight.
~brandy
Anyway, back to the game:
JM: I am flattered to make your mafia list, but I'm not seeing it. I haven't played in so long, I might as well be a newbie.
But....You are all soooo caught up in how people have played in the past. Now, I'm not saying that it's not valid, but really. We're all pretty intelligent people. It makes sense that people will evolve in their game play and style. I have seen changes (if subtle) in the way a few people I played with a few months ago have done so. Social drama at its best (or worst!)
About DP: If mafia, and silent, very dangerous. It can be a great tactic to keep one player "goofy" (for lack of a better term) and below the radar.
About LadyG: The questions you choose to ask confuse me. I don't know why the avatars were important, or the bit about the thred being a sticky forever. These seem to be random points to put focus on minor inconsistencies that have nothing to do with the game.
Clown-lover: OMG! Another new hero!!! hehehehehe!!!!! I'll start a new thread in GCC to chat about the latest developments. No one else I know watches the show.
Mad, Ogre, JL, Hooked, Charlie and the rest of the old vets: Do grudges really live this long? Do suspicions never die? I love watching the haggling, it's almost better than watchng Cheechoo take a swing at a stinking RedWing!
Almost. So right now, I'm stck between an OMGUS for JM, just for putting me on the list, and LadyG, for just striking the wrong chord with me. I will decide by bedtime tonight.
~brandy
Honestly John, it was your post where you said "they" need a better reason for not posting sooner. I'm sorry, but it seemed to be to try and "confuse" the town into thinking we all had sorry excuses. Believe me you are very low on my radar at this point. Really I mainly threw your name on there for a reaction. I'm not sure I believe that was a "mistake" when you typed that and it tweaked me pretty good.
Alot has happened today! No more Heroes chit-chat on this thread! (don't say anything about tonight's epdisode, it's on in a few minutes here. (hurray!)
Anyway, back to the game:
JM: I am flattered to make your mafia list, but I'm not seeing it. I haven't played in so long, I might as well be a newbie.
But....You are all soooo caught up in how people have played in the past. Now, I'm not saying that it's not valid, but really. We're all pretty intelligent people. It makes sense that people will evolve in their game play and style. I have seen changes (if subtle) in the way a few people I played with a few months ago have done so. Social drama at its best (or worst!)
About DP: If mafia, and silent, very dangerous. It can be a great tactic to keep one player "goofy" (for lack of a better term) and below the radar.
About LadyG: The questions you choose to ask confuse me. I don't know why the avatars were important, or the bit about the thred being a sticky forever. These seem to be random points to put focus on minor inconsistencies that have nothing to do with the game.
They weren't important just like the talk about heroes wasn't important. Just something to talk about at the time I suppose. When someone mentions (in your case) my avatar is Peter pan and it's not, yeah it's something worth mentioning in a day one scenario, not anything to vote someone on, but worth at least a mention imo.
And asking DD about the tread being in a sticky well if she was saying that it had always been in there...that would of worried me some with her, that is why I asked her she responded it ended.
What I don't get is of everything posted so far you pick these to go with as suspicious? Oh well to each their own. Hope this clarified some for you.
Clown-lover: OMG! Another new hero!!! hehehehehe!!!!! I'll start a new thread in GCC to chat about the latest developments. No one else I know watches the show.
Mad, Ogre, JL, Hooked, Charlie and the rest of the old vets: Do grudges really live this long? Do suspicions never die? I love watching the haggling, it's almost better than watchng Cheechoo take a swing at a stinking RedWing!
So right now, I'm stck between an OMGUS for JM, just for putting me on the list, and LadyG, for just striking the wrong chord with me. I will decide by bedtime tonight.
~brandy
Yeah it seems to work out nice, that is why I wondered, I like it..does sound like a pain but it looks and works nicely IMO.
With out Z around our vote tally isn't around as much either, I went back to see who was on who and this is what I have so far...any mistakes please make note of it, so others and myself will see it too.
Charlie (3) JL, HN, Ogre
DP (2) CS, Swayde
Blue (1) Jmax
Jmax (1) LG
Charlie (3) JL, HN, Ogre
DP (2) CS, Swayde
Blue (1) Jmax
Jmax (1) LG
