Mafia #14 -- The Play

[cooldude123]

from all of djs post i'm pretty sure that he is mafia
he's not making sence, then blod then random stuff,
this is what makes me think he is.
I vote to lynch DJ

 

[Lady G]

I really do not like who is voting with me on Blue. As I think they are more mafia than not. I also do not like the fact that DD and cool have not voted.

I do not think the roles this game are 100% random. I think there is a noob on each team.

I will not be here for nightfall and will not get to spend a whole lot of time in the next few hours on here.

I have to agree with you there JL, I do not think they are random at all. This may be completely off but this is they way I see Rb may of made the teams.

Old school
Orge
CL
Jensons
Swayde/Ice

New school
DD
Blue
DC/JL
DJ

Obviously this is just a "feeling"...yes I know ppl HATE feelings but really that is one of the things to this game...you get a feeling that is where it starts.
Feel free to move the names around however you see fit, but I bet these are our Mafia right there. Could be wrong on a couple but I bet I'm not far off.

 

[Lady G]

Oh and I forgot to address one part of CLs post about me...you know you say how I ask others their opinions...yes I do, because AGAIN that is part of the game (if you are innocent) you do want to know others opinions on things, because as a town we should come together..:silly:

 

[Lady G]

So if you are so sure about DJ why is your vote on Blue?? Revenge vote?? Simply because she knows that you are mafia like I do. You and your postings don't pass the smell tests. No but like I said you were all over the place and that in itself is suspicious enough.. And then you were so sure about DJ yesterday.. Why not today?

Why, because I believe there are many mafia on that vote...it is a "safe" vote at this time. If it looks he wont me lynched, yeah I will switch on to him. Me adding my name at this time does nothing he will be lynched, and yes I do believe he is mafia. THAT is why I voted him last nightfall, it wasn't a "safe" vote at that time, I was going to work and not going to be here for night fall..I really thought others were going to move over to him.

I really do not like who is voting with me on Blue. As I think they are more mafia than not. I also do not like the fact that DD and cool have not voted.

John, all I can do is tell you I am NOT mafia and really I know that means nothing in this game...everyone say's that, but that is all I have.

 

[Lady G]

:topic:
Swayde, I tried that game...it's just a little to cartoony for me.

 

[Lady G]

Wow OK I have finally caught up with todays postings and went over HN posts from yesterday and today.. If he was hit because he was onto something then this is what I saw..

HN(RIP Innocent Townie Friend) really was on Charlie (RIP Innocent Townie Friend) and the Judge.. Those were the two who he really was applying the screw gun to... so to speak. He did question Lady G on her "questionable" postings and had a few exchanges with Blue questioning her on some of her posts. But by and large he concentrated his efforts of the first two people. Today he wasn't real pressing as I feel he was convinced (as we all were) that his vote was in the right place. In fact I think he even stated that once or twice.

So if we follow this train of thought that DJMajor was a diversion could it necessarily be assumed that he was a diversion for the Day 1 vote (which we now know had to be false because we lost two townies) but can we theorize that it might be a diversion for the Day 2 vote because he was close?

Some of you have posted that you thought that HN's list consisted of the following and I think I have listed them in the order of his concern. If you really look at his messages and who he was pressing to get their mafia vibe this is it. Or am I completely off base here?

Charlie
JM
DP
DJ

While I have been in two games realistically I only have IRL about 4 days worth of play under my belt so I really am technically a newbie at this myself. With my vote and suspicions cast for Charlie yesterday I am going to take more of a questioning role over the next game day because while I thought I knew how to play I'm starting to feel like a horses rear.

What I would like to know CL...is where did you get he was going after Judge? The only other person I saw when I went back was Blue? Yes, he made reference to a couple others and then Dj at the end....but Blue is the only other I saw him to really question a few times.
So....are you trying to take attention away from Blue, with leaving her out of this post and then coming after me for voting her?

 

[clown-lover]

I have to agree with you there JL, I do not think they are random at all. This may be completely off but this is they way I see Rb may of made the teams.

Old school
Orge
CL
Jensons
Swayde/Ice

New school
DD
Blue
DC/JL
DJ

Obviously this is just a "feeling"...yes I know ppl HATE feelings but really that is one of the things to this game...you get a feeling that is where it starts.
Feel free to move the names around however you see fit, but I bet these are our Mafia right there. Could be wrong on a couple but I bet I'm not far off.

I got the time to run home for lunch as I forgot some of my tools that were needed in the garage.. Decide to run through the posts real quick and I see this..

Does anyone else notice that this list is comprised mostly of people who have called her to the carpet or whom others are sniffing out as mafia. I just find this amusing and you have yet to make a case for ANYONE on that list.

Just like I called JM and ICE to task for putting out lists without rational I'm going to do the same to you.. If you think anyone on that list is mafia - prove it. At this point there is enough posts going on for you to make a case so **** or get off the pot.

 

[clown-lover]

What I would like to know CL...is where did you get he was going after Judge? The only other person I saw when I went back was Blue? Yes, he made reference to a couple others and then Dj at the end....but Blue is the only other I saw him to really question a few times.
So....are you trying to take attention away from Blue, with leaving her out of this post and then coming after me for voting her?

Ok so here is your answer.. Post 1

Early vote simply because Blue is smart & new. You expect her to be mafia?



You think she's a scumbag based on what really? That the role assignments may be "tweaked"? Or that it was the first "case" available to jump on?



I would have liked this post had it not come immediately (15 minutes) behind Charlie's.



Same comment as above except you only waited 10 minutes to agree with Mad.



Not sure exactly where this all gets me, but I would suspect strongly (as far as Day 1 goes) that either...

A. JM & Charlie are on the same team (Mafia).
B. JM & Charlie are on different Mafia teams.
C. JM is innocent and Charlie is Mafia.

Plus

X. Mad & CL are on the same team (Mafia).
Y. Mad & CL are on different Mafia teams.
Z. Mad is innocent and CL is Mafia.

So given that the Mafia frequently try to agree with innocents, Charlie & CL would be my top candidates. The fact that there are two teams throws some added variability into this since they could be agreeing with someone on the opposing scumbag team, but it's the only thing I have to go on so...

I Vote to lynch Charlie.


Others I'm watching are the usual suspects... DD, Ice, Ogre, Lady G, JL, etc.

Post 2 where he digs into her for not answering his concerns

Thanks for the advice. I was posting at the same time, but I've read them since and your response to Ice doesn't address all of my concerns.
Seriously? We'll be down a townie? I guess we should all just take that tidbit as gospel and assume you're telling the truth huh? Any suspects besides those that you expect? C'mon, since you think so much like Rb, you should be able to name them right?

Post 3 where he questions her logic on her list

So, you have 6 out of 8 listed? Wow, that would be a day 1 record easy! If I'm to believe or place weight on this list, I know the two Dons.

Post 5 actually because post 4 was just thanking her for her list
Here he talks more about her list etc..

I actually wasn't being sarcastic there... lol

Ice did make a good point about the total numbers, but I was just saying it'd be a record this early. Of course, I trust nobody so you have to know that I'll take everything with a grain of salt. If you are innocent, there's probably a good bit of insight in it. If you're mafia, we should be able to identify most of your team by elimination. Either way, thanks for posting. The more info we have, the better.

As of this point he didn't post really any more tree kicking for the day.. The next day he was all but concentrated on Charlie.. He didn't kick any more at her tree but for the people he was grilling to get a response Charlie and the Judge were on that list..

 

[clown-lover]

What I would like to know CL...is where did you get he was going after Judge? The only other person I saw when I went back was Blue? Yes, he made reference to a couple others and then Dj at the end....but Blue is the only other I saw him to really question a few times.
So....are you trying to take attention away from Blue, with leaving her out of this post and then coming after me for voting her?

Now to answer the rest of your question.. - I really could care less what blue does to tell you honestly.. If you look at my postings she was on my mafia list and still is.. You however have sailed into the lead.. She will have her time under the spotlight but you need to go first.

 

[clown-lover]

Well I have to run.. I need to finish the fiber I'm working on so I can be back here this evening.

But you know LadyG I think you safe today anyway simply because everyone is singling out on DJ who is probably Mafia.. I just don't want any of them to forget about you.. You can bet the first post I make on day 3 is going to be my vote to lynch you. I just find it curious that if you are such a concerned townie why aren't you digging up the dirt?

And you still have yet to answer my questions.. Your doing the same thing you did yesterday.. People calling you to the carpet but you deflect or try and make them look guilty.. Or they end up on "your list" You are so transparent your cellophane.