Mafia #14 -- The Play

[IceH2O]

Ice, My group is as follows:

DD - lynch today
Jensons
blue
JMax

who do you have that I'm missing?

This is what I'm looking at

Mafia (no order)

DD
Ogre
Blue
Jensons
Clown

leaning mafia (no order)

JM
DC
Sway
Mad
DP

My top 3 would be the same as yours though

DD
Jensons
Blue

I probably should move you and clown down to leaning mafia, its just some posts really have me thinking you guys are mafia.

 

[Swayde]

Ok, so my drunken post is going to be neither entertainig or enlightening. Instead I'm going to say, jesus my head hurts and I wish I could be hanging with the girl right now. These cat fights are mildly amusing but are getting me nowhere more than when I get in a fight with a woman. I'm freaking confused and have no idea where to place my vote. I'd like to think that G is detective but i know I've wanted to play that card before. I'm so burnt out on work and such right now that I can't think straight but I thought I'd check in. I've also been trying to take btter care of myself lately due to a certain influence. I went drinking tonight to blow off some steam but will make a semi-rational choice in the morning before I go to the lady's place. I know I've been bad this game even by my standards but stuff came up all at once and things are suddenly making a difference in life. It's weird, if anyone wants to talk or say hi feel free...God, I feel like a total dork but whatever, I'm in a good place right now...Night everyone...

Why the confusion? DD is not denying she's mafia, in fact she's being quite bold about it and trying to implicate other people by saying they need to be in their chat room talking to her.

I am very surprised and pleased to see that there is still so much disucssion going on. I really thought the thread would die down quite a bit.

It seems someone else has already commented on all the strange things that stood out to me in people's posts since yesterday.

I am wondering though if there is a connection between DC and DP. They both voted for CS close together 403 & 417...then they both vote for DJ 652, 677 (they both did this very soon after the new day began)...now they both vote for DD 1356 & 1357. I'm not necessarly worried about who they voted for, since a lot of people, myself included, believed that DJ and CS were likely mafia, and am convinced that DD is, it's the timing of their posts and their votes that is raising flags with me. Plus I dont' think either one has been helpful at all.

 

[Lady G]

Please find my original statement where I said DD seemed helpful. I'm sure it was waaaaay before you came out. Remember that we all that charlie and DJ were mafia too.






With DP, I have everyone except brandy (Jensons) on DD. Why hold out? I would submit to add Jensons name to the possible mafia list for this reason and that some of the quotes above are just plain nutty.
[/COLOR]

Yeah, I believe it was after the DD, Blue inncident, so you still can't show me anything...just question me back?

 

[Swayde]

off topic...Lady G, I haven't tried out Luminary yet, between WoW, beta testing Pirates of the Burning Sea, Travian (a web based version of Civilzation type game) and Bejewelled 2 my gaming time is pretty much full. I'll eventually get around to trying it out though becasue it does look pretty neat.

 

[johnlarson66]

I have nothing new to post, but did not want to get accused of lurking.

I have thought about doing a scaled list, but I am going to wait until the next day. I have made most of my thoughts pretty much known.

If Lady G finds another mafia, then I will just follow her.

 

[IceH2O]

Why the confusion? DD is not denying she's mafia, in fact she's being quite bold about it and trying to implicate other people by saying they need to be in their chat room talking to her.

I am very surprised and pleased to see that there is still so much disucssion going on. I really thought the thread would die down quite a bit.

It seems someone else has already commented on all the strange things that stood out to me in people's posts since yesterday.

I am wondering though if there is a connection between DC and DP. They both voted for CS close together 403 & 417...then they both vote for DJ 652, 677 (they both did this very soon after the new day began)...now they both vote for DD 1356 & 1357. I'm not necessarly worried about who they voted for, since a lot of people, myself included, believed that DJ and CS were likely mafia, and am convinced that DD is, it's the timing of their posts and their votes that is raising flags with me. Plus I dont' think either one has been helpful at all.

I don't know that the timing is that important but the fact they they are late voters does stand out some. There were nearly 100 posts between CoolDudes vote and the DC DP votes.CL was also pretty hard to get a DD vote from also.

I don't think they thought DD would just come out and admit to being mafia. They were probably holding out votes hoping for DD to talk her way out of it so they could vote for someone else and get a train rolling.

Then last night when they got caught up they seen that DD admitted mafia and had no choice but jump on.

 

[OgreMkV]

Yeah, I believe it was after the DD, Blue inncident, so you still can't show me anything...just question me back?

LadyG, let me explain this very carefully. Tell me what post you are referring to.

If it's the post where I said that DD has been very helpful in convincing me that you are the detective... that's what I meant.

To help you out. Here is every post that I found (without reading every post I ever made in GCC, where I mention DD. Tell me which post you are referring to.

Ice, My group is as follows:

DD - lynch today
Jensons
blue
JMax

who do you have that I'm missing?

Please find my original statement where I said DD seemed helpful. I'm sure it was waaaaay before you came out. Remember that we all that charlie and DJ were mafia too.

With DP, I have everyone except brandy (Jensons) on DD. Why hold out? I would submit to add Jensons name to the possible mafia list for this reason and that some of the quotes above are just plain nutty.
[/color]

DD has been very helpful in convincing me that you are the detective and that she mafia.

You asked twice and I have been out since 2:00P CST. You could at least way until I make a post that doesn't answer your question before you go jumping on me for not answering your question.

I vote to lynch DD. For the record, I disagreed with LadyG's plan, but it's done and I believe her, especially after DDs lame attempts.

I think DD did more to help LadyG thatn LadyG could have.

Ice, I would encourage you not to place JMax and DP on the back burner.

Again to attempt to forestall the mad rush... in the interest of discussion and because a few of those posts were insanely mafia like I vote to lynch Blueiz.

I will probably switch later.

In the interest of full disclosure, this is driving me nuts. I read one post that says she's the det, and I think, "Yeah, I can see that." Then I read the next post that says something isn't right and I think, "Yeah, I can see that too."

So you investigated DD first and she's a Don.
You did not investigate blue, jensons, or clownlover, even though they are your top suspects?

You investigated people that are hard to read...

I can see that. I don't think I agree with it, but I can see the logic behind your plan. We have plenty of time, so let's work this out and decide, as a town, if we should follow LadyG.

To be honest, as I write this, I'm leaning more and more her way. I still think discussion is better than a lack of discussion, so I'll keep my vote where it is for now.

Can I just say, "What the frack is going on?" My thoughts

Whyand why should we believe you?
Me too...
Crazy.
Not the phrase I would use. Maybe, 'Oh ****!"
You ain't the only one.
I would hope so too...
So there!
Because?
I'm leaning this way myself at this point.
I'm not sure that makes sense. If you are the detective, then you're dead real soon. We could use a core of players to build around. With even two innocents known, we get better odds of lynching mafia.
Tell me why we're trusting you at this point.
I wouldn't say anything like that until this is all cleared the heck up.
I can understand that too.
I want to know why you trust her explicitly. I'm not saying her claim isn't possible, but it doesn't sound real good to me at this time.
Totally agree.
No kidding
Disagree. One group of mafia already knows, the other probably doesn't care. I think it's safe to say who was protected though. This is about the only thing that has me believing in LadyG at this point.
I can agree... to a point, but you're being VERY against it. The doctor save is pretty convincing.
huh?
This sounds weird. When I was ref, I'd send out the results before I posted the good morning post. I don't know how rb does it, and we know he posts the night posts SLOWLY! So maybe.
Agreed.
We need a live detective more than we need one mafia dead. We need ALL the mafia dead. As a group, we do have amazing powers to pick out mafia and maybe one lead is enough to go on, but...
Hell I don't know.

Concern List is still
JMax
DD
LadyG - detective?!
DJ - innocent sigh
blue? Does this mean that you really think blue is mafia or was she a convenient distraction?

That still bothers me too.

OK LadyG, my big question is "Why DD as your first night investigation?" I mean, I'm glad you picked out a mafia and all, but why her and why reveal now? OK, two questions.

I'm sure there's been lots of posts while I wrote this, so I'll catch up and go from there.

As usual, my thoughts in red.
A final comment, I agree with many of things LadyG says here, because a lot of it is the obvious and innocuous posting that doesn't really mean much.

I hope my comments have helped in some way.

I hope this helps. I'm missing something here.

 

[clown-lover]

I don't know that the timing is that important but the fact they they are late voters does stand out some. There were nearly 100 posts between CoolDudes vote and the DC DP votes.CL was also pretty hard to get a DD vote from also.

I don't think they thought DD would just come out and admit to being mafia. They were probably holding out votes hoping for DD to talk her way out of it so they could vote for someone else and get a train rolling.

Then last night when they got caught up they seen that DD admitted mafia and had no choice but jump on.

Just bopped in real quick to see what had been happening.. Will be studying the major portion of the day for my Level III test which is in two weeks.. But I just wanted to answer this real quick ICE.. If you look at the sign up thread I posted the following. I was gone until late in the day and was unable to read the happenings. If I had been around and able to surf during the day like yourself you would have seen my vote a lot sooner. I have bolded the section where I stated last sunday where I would be gone until late..

Exhibit A

So the GF and I have been talking about it.. I might have her convinced that I can play but I can't make promises as this is what I have for work this week..

Monday in town doing a security install shouldn't run late but then its a security system.
Tuesday out of town won't be back until late - upgrading a post office 3 hours a way.
Wednesday - Thursday complete a 92 strand fiber splicing job for the Department of Transportation and depending on weather I may be working late one or both of those nights to get the job done. Fiber splicing and humidity don't mix.
Friday - Driving 3 hours to do a 16 cable install for the ND school for the deaf. Its gonna take a lot time as the building is old and not made for infrastructure cabling. I probably won't get home until 10 pm.

So as soon as you guys ask - Where is Clown-Lover please refer yourself to this message

BTW Bob - I'm in

 

[cooldude123]

I don't know that the timing is that important but the fact they they are late voters does stand out some. There were nearly 100 posts between CoolDudes vote and the DC DP votes.CL was also pretty hard to get a DD vote from also.

I've not been on because i've been busy, as soon as i saw DD confess i voted 4 her.

 

[Rbishop]

Update...thru post 1369....

to lynch....

DD (12) by:

judge 1104 jpap 1122 lady 1128 swayde 1147 ice 1162 mad 1224

ogre 1255 jl66 1266 cool 1268 clown 1339 DC 1356 Dwarf 1357


lady g (1 ) by Danger 1107


13 of 15 have voted....

no votes from blueiz or jensons....


Nightfall at 8 PM EST, tonight, 10/27....


PMs or e-mails as required...