Mafia #18 The Santa Game

Madcrawdad said:
Grins....why didn't you open the present we sent you?

Also, in order for there to be any chance for tomorrow for the town, Blitzen NEEDS to kill me tonight....
Click to expand...
Mad this works only IF you are a communicating innocent and only IF the evils hit you tonight.

For all we know you may be trying to guarantee that blitzen sends the lump of coal to an evil to seal the deal for you guys.
 
jpappy789 said:
Mad this works only IF you are a communicating innocent and only IF the evils hit you tonight.

For all we know you may be trying to guarantee that blitzen sends the lump of coal to an evil to seal the deal for you guys.
Click to expand...

It's almost an unwinnable situation for the town, period. Scum wouldn't need to go through all this trouble for the win....
 
about one hour to go...
 
50 minutes....

:grinyes:
 
Madcrawdad said:
It's almost an unwinnable situation for the town, period. Scum wouldn't need to go through all this trouble for the win....
Click to expand...
But all the evils have to do now is hit another person and with you gone they win, the odds are that they hit an innocent. No offense mad but you arent really anything special right now. IF you are a communicating innocent the only thing you can do is name another innocent...basically you are another number so they do not NEED to hit you. Unless the are trying to play it safe and just get an innocent for sure.

And true the evils dont need to do all this to win but there is nothing stoping them from an almost clean sweep. They could easily end it now, if you are evil and they coal is sent to you.
 
*sigh* my replies are in red. First I want to start off by saying, sheesh Ice, you really are becoming obvious. No, you and your team are not going without us lynching at least one of you. Seems to me that someone is panicking.... I'm surprise really that Charlie isn;'t more vocal and he's letting you do all the work.
IceH2O said:
Beth thats the only list I had and was from days ago. Yes I've been wrong a couple of times as has most of the town. You think DD is innocent but you forget she was the one that jumped onto Niko the very 1st day. Then the copy and pasted email. I think she wanted to make a post but wanted to make sure everyone on her team was okay with what she was going to say. Once she got the okay she accidentally copied to much and pasted it.
Click to expand...
IceH2O said:
Ice, I jumped on Niko on the first day, just like others jumped on other people. Everybody knows that day 1 is a crapshoot and Niko looked like the most suspicious with his posting and then trying to weasle out of what he said. I've explained this time and time again. As far as the post and email thing, I admitted my error, explained and am targetted by the Grinch and elves as fiercely because it's all you have because you know I am innocent. I believe you and your team investigated me at one point and found that I am no elf and can't take that I am on to you.

Same thing as I just posted to Beth that you need to look at about the email Jpap. We all know DD doesn't need coaching but a lot of the time the evils go in with a plan. This game they have controlled us from the start. I think she wanted to clear the post with the others.
As was mentioned, I never have needed "clearing up" when I was evil in past games, what in your right mind would think if I was evil this game that I would need to "clear my post"??


I agree being all over the place doesn't help us at all.

We only have 6 innocents vs 5 evils.
Charlie makes 4 evils, I am goign to venture on some more of your list as being you, Mad, and possibly Grins. Last, not quite sure. Blue, maybe

If they lynch innocent and hit innocent its game over.
I am teling you all, Charlie is innocent. I guarantee it, I am now knowing that I am probably going to be hit tonight. If Charlie is not Evil, I take full repsonsibility for the entire game.

What is even worse is that Blitzen happens tonight.

We need to lynch an evil (6-4) and hope that Blitzen hits an innocent which would make it (5-4) and hope they hit one of their own 5-3. If they hit an innocent then its 4-4.

If we lynch an evil(6-4) and Blitzen hits an evil (5-5) and they hit an innocent its (5-4 evils) .

Beths posts are all over the place. Her suspicions are only on those who have called her out. She followed a player she thought was evil onto another player. I don't think she is the grinch though.

Here, Ice is completely trying to break this 3-3 tie between Charlie and Beth. I have a feeling Beth is innocent from this.

I still feel that DD is our best bet at Grinch.

how very wrong, especially knowing exactly who the Grinch is.

Her post that she knows HN is innocent is more disturbing knowing that Mad claims to be one of the communicating innocent left. So she was communicating with evils.
I never said I know HN is innocent, I was merely saying that I'll bet he is or I have a feeling he is. Fact is, I don't know but by your posting, you're not helping make him seem guilty.

Also did anyone notice that DD wasn't on me till HN mentioned me? And how she has been trying to twist my posts?

I'm not as sure that HN is evil as I am of DD. HN has had his moments that made me think he was but I also think that DD could be taking advantage of his aggressiveness.
I wasn't on you until you came at me head on as I began my suspicions and guarantee's that charlie was evil. You made me come at you all by yourself. Imagine that, huh

Click to expand...


I feel as I am already out. Ice, this is the most *gah* move you have made in all Mafia's. Just why would you even push for the Santa to come out. Yes, I am Santa. The reason I am saying it tonight is because I feel as if you and your team have already investigated me and I now have a green cross on my head. The reason I didn't come out any sooner is because as I've seen in past games, I tried to keep it together and go as far as I could especially with Rudolph being taken out so soon... it looks like I am left with no choice.
IceH2O said:
I really thought that DD would try to pull the Santa card, all evils try as a last gasp try to confuse the town especially when being looked at and want to lynch their suspect.
Click to expand...
IceH2O said:
So I was thinking about it and decided to play what if...


Lets go with that DD is Santa.

She was all over Niko Day 1. Day 2 she changed her mind and made Charlie her number 1 suspect while keeping the suspicion on Niko. Does that mean even though Niko was her highest suspect that she decided instead to investigate Charlie based on him not role playing with her? Wouldn't you investigate your top suspect? I don't believe she made any investigations at all.
I was all over Niko the first night. I had nothing to go on. I was looking for Rudolph the first night, I investigated Charlie (of course)... he was confirmed evil.

Night 2 she decides to jump on me AFTER HN names me in a post. Then claims HN is innocent. Did she investigate HN? Even if HN is innocent what about that makes me evil? Why jump me except I'm also a very vocal player. HN also named other players but DD wouldn't have the posts on them to pull up a case. She still hasn't pulled up a case on me either though.
I never jumped on you the second night til you jumped on me. The second night I investigated Plant... an innocent

I believe DD is Grinch, she knew Niko wasn't on her team and went to lynch him, once the ball got rolling and others took over she switched to another innocent. I believe she investigated me last night, to make sure i wasn't a disconnected elf, and found me innocent and coupled with HNs aggressive nature is using that as a springboard all the while staying on Charlie to not look like she is jumping to another innocent,since she has already been called on doing it.

Remember the Grinch has only gotten 1 investigation so far, nights 2 3 and 4 according to the rules.
what's messed up is I should have stuck with investigating you but last minute decided on plant, I didn't think rb would set me and you together
Click to expand...


right, one more night. You guys must be flipping. People, I urge you to switch your votes to keep this game alive and please please please look at my suspicions and those on me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom