Here it's 8:52 AM. Beth has a list
Here Beth suspects the Coler/CL argument could have been a plan.
Here it's 4:19 PM and Beth votes herself. All of a sudden she's not sure of anyone but herself.
Mafia #18 The Santa Game
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Ok, I didn't mean to hit the reply button yet. My point is that Beth's posts are illogical. She votes herself citing she is only sure of herself, but if she is innocent, then isn't it better to vote someone she's a little bit suspicious of than herself.
Then she lists Coler, Mad, and I as suspects. When Mad questions her on it she backs off real quick and eventually takes him off her list.
Then she lists Coler, Mad, and I as suspects. When Mad questions her on it she backs off real quick and eventually takes him off her list.
Well, if Beth is evil she isn't being well coached. However, it's possible she is disconnected from the group.
You haven't done anything and thats the point.
You voted for yourself. After making a list of suspects. I understand not feeling strongly on anyone the 1st night but none of us can say we do. You have to take chances and voting yourself is just as safe a vote as voting for someone not in the running to be lynched. You also could have broken the tie. Whats you're thoughts on Clowns status of evil or not?
You haven't drawn out any evils or even built cases, you're just floating along making posts that make no sense really.
You weren't that high on my list just someone to watch but..
How can you say you don't see anything on Niko? I think the evidence is pretty damning. Are you trying to protect Niko?
You've actually made yourself more a suspect in my eyes and I thank you for your response.
After rereading the posts DD also has my attention. The post in which she quotes Mad but goes on a tangent against HN was very strange.
So if anyones keeping notes my suspects are in no order
Niko
Charlie
Coler
Beth
DD
Beth, you are really all over the place. How about reading the posts and going from there. I dont think this is newbieness. In some posts yuo come off like you know what youre doing, with confidence, in other posts you seemingly dont know what to say or do.. Can you post some thoughts that actually make sense?
oe of the reasons fo rmy thoughts on Niko is that he was one of the few who thought that my choice to vote for myself was not evil, but because I really didn't want to throw out some random vote. And he defended me, if he was evil he really would eith have jumped on the train with everyone else to keep focus on me, not him. Or he was innocent and was told that I was innocent.
I realize that I have probably walked into great debate.
And Grins what makes you think I am suspicous?
I realize that I have probably walked into great debate.
And Grins what makes you think I am suspicous?
Here Beth says she thinks it's better she votes herself rather than someone she has no proof on. Well, is there really ever any proof in these games?
If she's read a lot, then why did she miss when nightfall is?
Due to Beth's illogical posts, I think it's because she has something to hide, perhaps evil pointy ears?
I vote to lynch Beth.
Of course he didn't point it out. He also placed a safe vote. To point it out would have made him a hypocrite.
I think you and Niko are teammates and thats why the protection.
You use one instance to claim his innocence when there are many more posts leading to his evilness.
so to reiterate my suspects are:
HN- because he doesn't like poutine
Niko- because I don't think he likes it either
HN- because he doesn't like poutine
Niko- because I don't think he likes it either
