Mafia #18 The Santa Game

[Hooked Newbie]

There's a good case HN, it's people who haven't done anything evil who might be scum..... BTW, why is Grins on you list of those who haven't made any/many mistakes? I believe Grins was on your most recent suspect list, so she had to have made some mistakes, right? Why you voting JPap instead of Grins?

Because she may have been led along and I don't think she's the Grinch.

Nice apology to Niko....you didn't kill him, though. You hopped on after he was already dead.


How would your vote have been 'wasted' had you stayed on Chas? Niko would still be dead, right? Regarding my vote, would me moving to Niko have been a better thing to do?

I've stated my reasons for that twice already and my original thoughts were posted as well. Do I need to state it again for you?

I might say the same about you....you say that I haven't made any mistakes, yet you tried to link me to both Andi and Plantling's hits. Strange, I haven't heard much from you until I asked about your vote on Niko....

I "linked" you to Andi's hit? I think I need to look back, was your vote on her too? Did you put your vote on BOTH innocents that got hit? Gonna vote me too?

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Ice & Mad- good job! I fully expect to be the leading vote getter by the time I get up, but I need to get to bed. Hopefully the townies will look back to your cherry picked quotes and look at the true context. If not, I guess I'll start watching for the signup thread.

 

[IceH2O]

I didn't want to vote this early but lets see what comes of it.

If anything maybe if HN is innocent and just having a run of bad luck it might tip us to the actual evils.

I vote to lynch Hooked Newbie

 

[IceH2O]

Ice & Mad- good job! I fully expect to be the leading vote getter by the time I get up, but I need to get to bed. Hopefully the townies will look back to your cherry picked quotes and look at the true context. If not, I guess I'll start watching for the signup thread.

Good job?

I didn't write your posts. I didn't make your lists. I didn't place your votes.

You did all that on your own.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I find your explanation for the email lacking and as for where my suspicions are I've already stated that and been clear about it when I've posted since the start. How about reading those instead of alluding to relationships that don't exist?

LOL good one, Grins. Using the dirty card you just threw is only going to make it show you are more closer to the chat room than anything else. How about you state just what those suspicions on me were from the start. I would prefer post numbers too.

Still think he is a good candidate.

Your late jump to Niko at night fall is the reason you stick out.As does Charlie.

You both have continually voted one another. Then switch to innocents, you to LG and then Niko and Charlie to LG and Niko. Look how you two follow each other. Only reason I said you over Charlie is because DD is saying Charlie needs to be voted and I'm not trusting DD. Charlie might be evil and the sacrifice to make her look good.

I'm not voting anyone yet. We have several suspects and I'm not going to blindly follow anyone.

Ice, I will explain this again. I voted Niko on night one because he seemed most guilty to me and I thought that it was clear from his wordy screw up that he had been busted and was trying to squirm out of it. I was wrong. It was day 1, that's not unheard of.

As time went on, it dawned on me the peculiar way Charlie was portraying himself. No role play, no mention of me. I know I am not the be all for Charlie to talk about, but it is strange that role play wasn't a big part of the posts for Charlie.

Um DD, by your own twisted logic YOU look guilty for mentioning this again. For all I know this is a plan by you and Charlie to take out innocents by looking like you're on opposite teams.

uh-huh.... mention #4. Now I can see the panic. I just hope people take note of it later on in the game. You are clearly being coached.

We came up with 2 or 3 suspects and split votes among them to see who went where. I don't believe at that time we were down to a possible last night fall.

Theres no room for error, we need to find the best suspect and lynch them.

As for jumping off innocents. I mentioned it earlier too. You were on Niko, as soon as the ball got rolling on him you jumped to Charlie. What about Niko was so suspicious day 1 but not Day 2?

What about Charlie raised your suspicion level so much?

I was on Niko, day 1. As soon as the ball got rolling, what? You mean as soon as I started becoming suspicious of Charlie you mean? I never once voted for Niko on day 2. Yes, I still found him suspicious and was wrong but my concentration was on Charlie because I find him very suspicious. I explainrd to you why Niko was suspicious on day one and less on day two. I explained why Charlie raised my suspicion. How many times do you want to hear it, or are you not really looking that hard?

 

[Dangerdoll]

and actually, it wa game 15 and yes, we were in a better position. However, the plan was good and it worked for us.

 

[IceH2O]

So DD who do you think we should put up as suspects to vote on then?

So far it looks like HN Jpap and Beth already have votes. That work for you or would you rather see a different group?

 

[Madcrawdad]

I "linked" you to Andi's hit? I think I need to look back, was your vote on her too? Did you put your vote on BOTH innocents that got hit? Gonna vote me too?

Huh? I voted CL and Beth. You remember CL ... the guy that you slipped up and said was guilty to Charlie. Then you had to backtrack, because it kind of ruined your reason for hopping on Lady G...

 

[Madcrawdad]

Ice & Mad- good job! I fully expect to be the leading vote getter by the time I get up, but I need to get to bed. Hopefully the townies will look back to your cherry picked quotes and look at the true context. If not, I guess I'll start watching for the signup thread.

Last time I lynched you as scum you accused me of cherry picking, too....

HN, I see you.

 

[Dangerdoll]

So DD who do you think we should put up as suspects to vote on then?

So far it looks like HN Jpap and Beth already have votes. That work for you or would you rather see a different group?

If I had to list, I would say Charlie, Grins or you.

I have already stated reasons for both Charlie and Grins, and you becuase I have begun to notice a difference in your issues which you call importance. I feel usually, your findings are much more than what you have now and seem to support them with as much passion. I don't like what I see by your posts.