Mafia #19 50/50

[Lady G]

Night 2 votes

andi swyd 407 dc 410

jl66 beth 469 niko 503

plant blue 482

blue jdge 492 wes 493 andi 499 plnt 573 mal 597

niko lady 577

beth jl66 570 brains2


No vote from jpap...

Night 1 votes

to lynch...

DD (9) by jdge blue lady plnt jl66 swyd jpap niko wes

blue (1) by malbri

judge (3) by DD DC andi

13 of 14 have voted....

no vote from beth...

less than 1 1/2 hrs to nightfall....

Beth voted DD right after this post from RB.
From this, Beth and Andi are looking really good as a lynch candidate. We have Andi voting on innocents both nights, and Beth voting on DD last minute, even after DD had been outed.
Andi, to me is looking to be the best at this time, her quick in and out vote on Jmax..after the DD "outing", then her quick in and out vote on Blue...not thoughts of her own really on either.

 

[Lady G]

not sure what to say,but that stings. I was wrong about Blueiz even though I didn't vote for her, I still thought she was mafia.
Andi- could either be mafia or innocent, has done things to make me wonder how innocent she is.
JL-had you pegged as mafia, not sure I'll wait
Plantling-nothing screams mafia, but with you nothin ever does, perhaps your good at hiding
Brains2-you have a nasty attitude, and your mean classic mafia style, but I'll peg you as innocent, I mean with the attitude it would be to obvious.
DC-perhaps you are mafia, I will investigate.
Niko-you are so good at this game you could be either.have to investigate you further
Malbri-you just seem innocent,so perhaps you are mafia
Wes-too quiet for my liking, perhaps you are mafia
Those are my thoughts, I will pay more attention today. Lets get mafia this time shall we.

Just a few thoughts on Beth's list...
what did you mean by "not sure I'll wait" to JL?
To Plant you say she never screams mafia...am I wrong or have you only played one game w/her..one she was innocent in?
To Dc, you say you will investigate?? How did you get an investigation??
To Niko same thing??
Where are the investigations and thoughts to these investigations Beth??

 

[Lady G]

Well, it seems ACville is deserted once again...I'm not going to sit and discuss with myself, so I am off for a while.

Just want to say to John first. You mentioned the 2 ppl discussion, I am not really so convinced on Plant right now, yes I am wondering..but no where near a vote for her. Personally, I would pick...Beth, Andi, DC or Niko.

 

[plantling]

I believe Plant is moving up on my list. Yes, we have had many of the same thoughts..that is why I was leaning her more innocent, but I am wondering was she trying to attach herself to me, maybe as a "lone" mafia, either thinking me innocent and wanting to look innocent if I was lynched/hit...or thinking I am Mafia and not wanting me to go after her.


Blue was pretty on Plant there, yes she also named me, as possibly connected to Plant...I am not, others may feel this way also all I can do is tell you I am not, this is why I am wondering did we really have the same thoughts or is she trying to connect to me for a reason?? Also if we were "communicating" mafia...we would not "chatter" between each other on the thread, that is something I hope to be obvious to others.

No, LG. I'm not trying to attach myself to you. We have agreed on certain things but it wasn't just me always agreeing w/you, you agreed w/me at times also. And yes, as I've already stated that looking back at the posts I was harsh on Blue, but she was quite harsh w/me, too, especially after my very first question to her. I wish I had just dropped it but then she started trying to link me w/you and Niko. Something that an evil has tried to do to me in a past game.

These are some of the conversations that we had:

This is true, also...but then they could be counting on us thinking that. Really I do not think the three can communicate. I am leaning more DD or Blue evil, not sure on Niko at this point, possible one of the two along with Niko?? All I know is HALF the town is evil so there are many out there, the likely hood of us getting a Mafia on night one are higher in this set up then others. I'm pretty sure at least ONE of Niko, DD and Blue are mafia, just trying to decide which.

You were commenting on what I said about the Blue/DD/Niko thing.

I'm not sold on all 3 being Mafia or all 3 being innocent, either. And I agree 50% chance of lynching a Mafia is pretty good. I'd like to go for one of the communicating Mafia, but will be satisfied w/one of the 4 non-communicating ones. This game is a lot about numbers. We lose if after the 4th day the Mafia outnumber us.

I answered.

Right now, before I go to bed I have to say...Andi and Beth stand out to me more than anyone else at this time.

I will post more thoughts tomorrow, after some sleep. We did a great job tonight, lots of thanks to Jmax!!:grinyes:

You found Andi and Beth suspicious.

Well, just a quick thought or two before starting out the day:

Yep, I too, found Beth's hedging before nightfall suspicious. It could have been genuine Newbie confusion, but then the situation wasn't that hard to understand, so I'm wondering if it was more like hesitation to vote out one of her own.

Because for some reason I get hit on night two these days , I will go ahead and put up a list and will try to update it if necessary before next nightfall. Any comments on the pple on my list is welcome.


MY LIST:
Assumed Innocents:
JMax
LG

Mafia Suspects:
Andi
JL
Blue
Beth
DC

Like I said, any comments are welcome. I don't have any investigative powers or special powers or roles, so it's all speculation on my part. I very well may be wrong about a few. The more discussion before nightfall, the better.

I agreed I also found Beth suspicious. (We weren't alone in that). Then I made my list.

Hmmm, I just noticed this. There are 4 votes on Andi and most of the voters are on my list of suspects. IMO, Andi may be Mafia, but she's prolly not part of the communicating team. I think at least one of those voting for Andi are on that team. It could even be 3.

Blue and JL were on Niko for that joke he made to LG. DC seems to be going w/the flow a bit this game.

I stated I was concerned about the pple voting for Andi who were also on my list.

You know, Plant that is a little interesting there. They did all three just jump right on that one didn't they (the vote for Andi).

I do agree Andi, looks mafia the way she posts and the things she says makes her seem that way. My only reservation on her is, her first game. She played the exact same way...didn't post much, when she did it was always really off, then posted that she has been playing RP games for years this of coarse made everyone jump on her, because we all said we had been thinking her a confused newb, then she posted she had been playing these type of games for so long, everyone figured she was "playing" us, so she was lynched and found innocent.

Now, of coarse this does NOT really make me think she IS innocent just because of that, but it does make me pause..before jumping on the Andi train.

We need to take out the mafia, and it doesn't matter which communicating or non, but others are looking pretty scummy right now too, and I'm not sure about the whole lets take her out thing, especially after realizing who is all voting her from the start.

You agreed w/me about the pple voting for her.

Really I'm not sure where my vote is going to land, looking back the whole Blue, DD, Niko thing came back to mind. Obviously we found DD to be mafia..now I wonder were Blue and DD "tag teaming" Niko?? Was Niko and DD distancing??

Then JL, and DC just seem very off to me. JL, with his vote for me, when talking about Niko in his post...saying I was defending Niko. Blue and DD also seemed to think that, was he going on there lead?? I was very surprised when JL replied with the Niko "slip" he is one I for sure would of realized it was just a joke, and for him to try and build a case around that just threw me off. His posts with his "thoughts" were very disoriented also, so not like JL.

You stated your suspicions about JL.

Yep, that's why my vote is on JL. I'm most suspicious of him atm. Not sure if I wanna vote Andi w/so many pple I don't trust on her. I am also willing to vote for DC or Blue atm.

I told you that's why I voted him.

We had similar thoughts about a few things. I was not following you nor did I think you were following me.

 

[plantling]

lol, I work, I go to school, I do homework, I do chores
I dont have much time to really analyze the thread really hard like some of you
I have told you my thoughts, on multiple people
I am actually going to be a loner here, but I really dont like this brains guy.
He expects everyone to be on at every second posting every little thing that pops into their mind(not really, its an exgageration, but still)
Also, he came after a mafia was killed, do you think rbish would make him a mafia to even it back out(cause he is evil like that)
Anyways, im placing a vote now, because I have to work tomarrow, and im not sure what time I will get home
I vote to lynch brains

Wow, Mal. I don't think you're expected to post your every thought every second, but a few thoughtful posts everyday would be nice. Also, I suppose RB was referring to you being in chat but not taking the time to come and read the entire thread before posting a vote on Blue. I know you retracted and voted for I think Niko, but still we would like to hear more about your suspicions than just a quick vote.

 

[plantling]

Revised List: (I'm willing to vote for any of these)

Andi-as per previous posts

Beth-as per previous posts

DC-as per previous posts

Mal-Her hit and run posts and votes don't offer a whole lot of information about her or her suspicions.

JL-I'm putting him back on my list not as an OMGUS thing but I think pple need to remember that until lately his thoughts on the game were very scarce. He only started posting a lot when his game life became threatened. I fear he's trying to pull the wool over our eyes. I've also wondered why he is coming after me now. I agree I prolly look suspicious for my vote on Blue, but JL has either got blinders on or he's got an agenda if I'm his best suspect.

 

[Lady G]

No, LG. I'm not trying to attach myself to you. We have agreed on certain things but it wasn't just me always agreeing w/you, you agreed w/me at times also. And yes, as I've already stated that looking back at the posts I was harsh on Blue, but she was quite harsh w/me, too, especially after my very first question to her. I wish I had just dropped it but then she started trying to link me w/you and Niko. Something that an evil has tried to do to me in a past game.

These are some of the conversations that we had:


You were commenting on what I said about the Blue/DD/Niko thing.


I answered.


You found Andi and Beth suspicious.


I agreed I also found Beth suspicious. (We weren't alone in that). Then I made my list.


I stated I was concerned about the pple voting for Andi who were also on my list.


You agreed w/me about the pple voting for her.


You stated your suspicions about JL.


I told you that's why I voted him.

We had similar thoughts about a few things. I was not following you nor did I think you were following me.

You know Plant, I have to agree. I think we have just had many of the same thoughts, and being about the only ones posting our thoughts and opinions at that time..it just ended up looking that way.

I still am not sure of your innocence, but I do feel we just saw the same things.

I am sorry to say but Blue did make herself look mafia in my eyes also. The bicker between her and Niko, then Jmax...yes, her thought was one that needed to be thought about, because it was possible, but she just didn't want to drop it. Then her trying to connect us, I honestly have to say had I not seen Andi's vote on her and had Niko answered me differently my vote very well may of ended up on her. Although I was really going between Niko and Beth at that time.

 

[Reefscape]

Just a few thoughts on Beth's list...
what did you mean by "not sure I'll wait" to JL?
To Plant you say she never screams mafia...am I wrong or have you only played one game w/her..one she was innocent in?
To Dc, you say you will investigate?? How did you get an investigation??
To Niko same thing??
Where are the investigations and thoughts to these investigations Beth??

I can only presume your refering to an investigation with this comment towards me??...

Investigate, meaning goin back over the thread and looking at peoples posts, look for things..

 

[Lady G]

I can only presume your refering to an investigation with this comment towards me??...

Investigate, meaning goin back over the thread and looking at peoples posts, look for things..

Ahhh, Niko!!!!

Yes, I was talking about her saying she was going to investigate you.

 

[Reefscape]

Read the post again LadyG.. What I said is that you are NOT all over the place which is the norm for you.. This game you seem... assured, confident, non wishy-washy.. Which ISN'T your play style.

Depends on if what they are talking about is worth responding to or not.

I also agree with what brians2 said regarding this...if its something pityfull, then i am not going to just jump on to the thread and start blasting out statements..Questions you asked got answered, you dont like the answers you were given, so be it, thats for you to decide. I have done zero to make me look scummy and your basis of a case against me is nothing. We should be working together to root out the scum who are coasting through this game, not picking up and pushing tiny little remarks or comments...things like that are going to be this towns downfall if we are not carefull. We cannot afford to loose anymore innocents...