Mafia #19 50/50

[plantling]

/// game off
got a call from my kids teacher and so now I am home with a sick child.. will turn some attention to the game while he is sleeping
/// game on

Sorry all, I'm reading to catch up, Have spent a portion of the weekend at the med-stop my 2yr old has strep throat, he was running a 102.9 fever saturday night

Wow, Hope both your kids get better soon. Both my kids were sick the week before Thanksgiving, and I know it's no fun.


Andi, hope you get caught up soon and post your thoughts about the game. It looks like you're going to get voted off tonight so if you're innocent please give us reasons we should change our votes.

 

[plantling]

Speaking of post counts, this is the current tally:
Lady G 121
atnixon 80
plantling 79
judgemax 72
johnlarson66 64
bethkira2000 48
brains2 46
Dangerdoll 42
Blueiz 40
rbishop 31
Malbri 26
wesleydnunder 25
jpappy789 23
andi872 13
Swayde 12
DeputyChiefJR 8

 

[DeputyChiefJR]

Hey, long football day yesterday...Lemme go over the posts and write something up....

 

[Reefscape]

/// game off
got a call from my kids teacher and so now I am home with a sick child.. will turn some attention to the game while he is sleeping
/// game on

Hope everything is ok with the young one mate..

 

[andi872]

First off, Blue was not so on judgemax. She did not even vote for judgemax. She was just pointing out that we could not 100% trust judgemax being innocent just because of the dangerdoll lynch. Lady G had posted this before and anyone who has played before knows that this could have been an option and it was something good to talk about.

Judgemax's vote on Blue was suspicous and I think she was a little maniplated by making the post. People were making a bigger deal out of her saying it than others.

I think the town needs to get 2 solid names to put up and go from there. The mafia can control the votes at this stage, so if we stop them from spreading everyone out then we have a better chance of seeing where they line up.

My top chioces are:

Beth
Niko
Andi
Plantling

I also think DC and Marbri are not to be trusted.

Now that I have made six new friends, I will change my vote again and call it a night. I hope the town can make this day a two person race.

I retract my vote to lynch andi and vote to lynch Plantling.

I would like to see other peoples lists and my vote is up for change. What would be good if everyone put up a list of four and then voted for their top, then we can adjust as needed.

I do not see plant as guilty.

Well, I have quite a few things I have to get done today. I will be back on later to add more thoughts. Going to leave my list of suspects I have at the time.

Niko-He just isn't sitting well with me, he says he wasn't on when I know he was. That makes me very suspicious, as he could of just admitted to being there and gave a reason he didn't post.

Beth-Her hesitations, and her post are not setting well with me at all.
Me neather I do think Beth is Mafia

Andi-She just doesn't seem to add anything to the game as far as thoughts, I am wondering if she is a communicating mafia.
Not communication Mafia, for that matter not Mafia, just the bad luck of RL issues this game and i can see hoe they are making me look mafia, If i did not know better I would peg me too.

DC-Has done nothing at all to help the town, said he will play more after last night, guess we will have to wait and see what he does.
I have yet to see him help as you have pointed out he said he would, I hope he is not having RL issues, but I agreee he is looking Mafia

My comments are in purple feel free to ask me question I will answer to the best of my ability.

I vote to Lynch Beth

 

[brains2]

OK so Andi is next on the list... Again I must stress I don't expect people to live in the thread, I don't expect them to forgoe RL issues nothing. But the quality of the posting is severely lacking..

Day 1 - normal banter.. Again I pretty much blow off day 1 banter..

Yaay and it starts again

Are we making cards already...at this rate we will have our own deck

End of Day 1

Start of Day 2

NOOOOO not again

:rofl::y220e: Welcome to the club...I've been 29 a few times

Are we having vocabulary lessons too?

ok finally got through all the post

She read everything and had absolutely nothing but this to say.. I had more to say waiting in the wings being an observer of the game.
End of Day 2

Start of Day 3
Now again I don't question peoples RL stuff but look at this post and then look at the posting outside of the thread. This was all she could come up with for a post.

Sorry Yesterday was crazy with RL issues..I'm trying to catch up

Hi all

I'm having net connection problems here at work. I'm gona go ahead an vote so I dont UD

I vote to Lynch JM

She votes.. No rational no reasoning.. Just out of the dark bam.. Votes JM.

hopefuly this will work i get dumped each time i try to post... I have been geting on to read each time my connection has aloud

Again I'm not going to question connection issues but this is all she could post?? An excuse?
End of Day 3
Start Day 4

Ok, I’m typing this in another program to start, cause half the time that I tried to post yesterday it kept dumping me and I would loose every thing I said…

• I was not sure that DD was mafia or innocent, it just happened she was Mafia. BUT I wasn’t going to just follow the train I have been the assisted cause in innocent’s deaths in previous games that way.
• JM was a safe vote JM wasn’t going any where, I wasn’t trying to get a train going I was trying to not hurt the town even though I was not in a position to help the town.

I am still having internet problems here at WORK; I can get on and read but my ability to post with out being kicked off it hit or miss. And I knew due to my class last night I was not going to make it to my home computer till after nightfall, Saturday I will be able to do more.

Well at least we get some reasoning but its more of a fire fighter effort at this point because people are questioning her.. Can't seem to post anything else of substance until it came to this. Also I don't get how she could NOT think DD was mafia.. It was OOOO so evident that she was..

End Day 4

Start Day 5

I just caught up on post I have to run an errand before nap time I'll be back in about a hr

This is all she posted... Never posted here but did in other threads.

Originally Posted by judgemax
well, this has been slow, i am hoping that by tonight i will have plenty more time, to contribute my thoughts, honestly, this is a very busy weekend for me, ..

So, My suspect list is as follows:

Blue: I think blue knows more about contriving a plan, than she is letting on, I think NIKO gate, was planned, I think BLUE is mafia.

This, is a good point, I'm incline to agree with you here.

LADY G , I still find it suspect, that DD named you. In MO, I would have named a known mafia, simply because, so many are now trusting LG is innocent.

This too is a good point LG is too good at this game to assume she is not mafia

Andi, She has several games under her belt, and this has got to be teh worst play I have seen from her yet. I think, she is struggling, with being a non communicating mafia.

THis is the first game that I have run into techinical issues as well as RL during game time, if people want to hold that against me so be it. BUT recall this happened to LG last game and she was innocent.

DC, usually much more active, with a much stronger, more well thought out opinion, somewhat concerns me.

Wes, I agree, its a gut feeling, but its a strong one.

Fo bow, just in case I can not make it back before nightfall, I am Voting to lynch Blue as always this vote is subject to change.

As ussual my comments are in purple.

I am voting to lynch Blue

Notice how she points out that this happened to LadyG last game and she was innocent. The problem here as that we have a good voting record of yours to stand on as of this point.
End of this Day

Nothing on Sunday

Today

Sorry all, I'm reading to catch up, Have spent a portion of the weekend at the med-stop my 2yr old has strep throat, he was running a 102.9 fever saturday night

/// Game Off
I'm sorry you child is sick.. Mine is also home with the flu.. Hope they are better soon
/// Game On
I hope to hear some of your ideas because as of this point you have been severely lacking and I'm calling you mafia.

Again folks you decide.

 

[brains2]

I do not see plant as guilty.




My comments are in purple feel free to ask me question I will answer to the best of my ability.

I vote to Lynch Beth

While I appreciate the effort IMO its to little to late.. My vote is staying where it was placed.. I am very confident that you are mafia. It is only now that your neck is on the line that you have taken the time to come out of the closet, so to speak, and post anything of substance.

 

[Lady G]

Well if you don't get him how can you get any of the rest of the low posters or get a feel for if they are innocent or not? He is no different than any of the other low posters..

And realistically beth has only gotten really quiet since I sniffed her out that is what is leading me more and more to believe that she is mafia than some others on the list. Her posting hasn't been helpful it has been just enough to make people think she has but the guts of isn't.

I gave you a break in the beginning because your reasoning had merit. You may not have liked my tactics you can call me harsh or a jerk or whatever else you want but it did several things. It gave me a read on the prominent players in the game. You by no means have come off of my list but I'm thinking that you are doing more to help the town than most so I'm giving you a break..

LadyG's vote confuses me however.. While I understand the need to beat the bushes and kick the weasles earlier she listed three top candidates that she was waffling on but then voted DC. I consider that a safe vote right now and am going to continue to watch her carefully.. She also seems to be helping the town but with her again I just have this feeling.

I am even more assured of my vote right now with Andi my only problem right now is that she very well might UD. But then if I change my vote and she shows back up in the thread.. hmmmmm.. Out of everyone on my list she is the top along with beth.

I sat and watch the thread last night and saw Malbri in the thread for quite some time and she only had the one post. From the time she posted she was here with only two activity updates one at 8:00 and one at 8:29 but all we got was one post.

Beth, may of actually posted...but she hasn't posted anything that was of her own thoughts, IMO she has just been pretty much following what others have said.
As far as my vote, I don't see how it's confusing, or a "safe" vote. He is not adding to the game in any way, and sometimes it takes seeing your name in bold to draw ppl out.
I will have no problem switching to Beth or Andi to be honest, but it wasn't close enough to night fall for any vote to be a "safe" vote, I can and will change my vote, if I feel it will be wasted, and have plenty of time to do so.

 

[brains2]

Swade - while I'm not getting a large vibe from this person they are also one of the low posters so I'm scrutinizing her as well. Although I must admit Swade's posts at least have some substance to them.. But I do get a feeling of skating under the radar somewhat.. Maybe its just because she hasn't posted that much.. I'm not certain.

1st Day banter again.. Nothing to worry abut in my opinion.

Hi everyone! So good to be back here in Acville huntin down the evil mafia scum =) I can only pop in for a few minutes right now. I am waiting on hubby to finish getting ready to take me out for my birthday dinner. I am 29 again today

I feel like a newbie all over again. There are quite a few new players that I've never played with before and with the game 50/50 I think it's going to be rough for us to figure out who's actually the bad guys in the mix. I did read the thread up to this point and there's just too many people I need more time to get a feel for so going to hold off on voting. I will do my best to stay caught up but I do have a few things planned for this week since it's not only my birthday, but my baby brother turns 21 on the 10th also =) I will do my absolute best to help the town snuff out scum in my free time though as I get back into my groove!

End of Day 1 posts

Start of Day 2 posts.

JL, you seem to be playing a bit weird, I don't know if it's because you are on a business trip, or actually home for a change or what, I can't figure that out, but...you say you THINK it's for 3 different people, after RB had posted a listing of the current votes and who they are all for, which makes it seem to me as if you are skimming and missed it being spelled out for you. I also figured you for more of a player who would pay closer attention to details, such as vote counts.


DC, thanks for the warm welcome back I somehow am not surprised that you'd choose to give me a hard time right from the get-go, but seriously dude, are you going to keep the old grudge vote forever and not contribute anything to the town at all? So anti-town.


DD, wow, what was that all about on Niko? It seemed pretty obvious it was a joke, and I still don't understand how anyone saw it as any kind of a slip. IF JM did in fact catch ya on one of your famous slips, you are so going down. I am not 100% sure at this point though because, in my experience, your only very aggressive when you are a townie and are prone to slips and typos and mistakes as either alignment. So I'm not willing to make a judgement on you yet.

Okay so at this point JL looks most like mafia to me. I vote to lynch Johnlarson.

My hubby goes back to work tomorrow after taking some vacation time to spend with me for my birthday (and to use it up before the end of the year!). I am going to lunch with my mom tomorrow though, but should have much more free time to do more posting. Sorry for the lack of posting so far, I know it's unlike me and can't blame people for finding it odd, just hope ya'll understand.

Ok so I can deal with this.. Seems to have what her thoughts are layed out in a somewhat cohesive fashion. While I've played with John recently I'm not seeing what she is seeing as of this point in the game.. But ok.

We'll see eventually if she's mafia or not. I just am not sure it's really a tell tale sign that she's a baddie. She makes mistakes so often, it's just not a very reliable way to get her IMO, but I don't think you are bad for pointing it out either and if she is bad then you deserve kudos for noticing it. Even if she's innocent, at least you are paying attention to details. If you are mafia and just trying to get rid of a potential threat, then hope you don't mind a noose around your neck while your feet dangle under Bala

Why is it that you will miss them? Can't just follow their leads?

End of Day 2

Start of Day 3

After reading the posts from today I have to say that JM's posts seem a lot more convincing. It sounds like DD is trying to throw her team a hail mary pass with her innocent investigation knowing she is busted. DD should definitely know better than to post a "you'll be sorry" post to prove her innocence, seems more like she's trying to be obvious enough as a sign for her unknown mafia buddies.

I was willing to give you the benefit of the doubt on your typo post, but I can't let the "you'll be sorry" thing slide as easily or how you could think it was a good thing for the town to give up an innocent's name.

I retract my vote for Johnlarson and I vote to lynch Dangerdoll.

Again I don't see a problem with this.. DD was mafia and swade caught onto the evidence.

No not even close to her 1st game Swade. Its like her third or 4th.

Andi's vote seems very odd. Is this her first game?

Sorry to hear you will miss night fall LG, but hey, the extra money surely must be helpful =)

Not trying to answer for anyone else here, but DD in my opinion, it's not that JM looks innocent, it's more like she's just seeming more reliable in this case because of just how guilty you seem to be acting.

End of Day 3

Start Day 4

That information is hidden from regular members if the person they check on is in invisible mode. Only mods can see activity information for people who are in invisible mode.

Again nothing wrong here as well.. Point out to Niko that not all of us have God powers
End of Day 4

Start Day 5

Great job Jmax =)

Andi, I was hoping yesterday to read that it was in fact your first game and that maybe you just didn't get the game, but it's not your first game and your behaviour, internet problems or not, is really scummy so far.

I am also still very, very suspicious of JL. If there was a power role, I'd be a little more inclined to think maybe that was the reason, but your gameplay so far has come across as very anti-town. I still think you are playing very strangely and I think you are a scumbag.

I vote to lynch Andi for now, this is subject to change since it's still pretty early for a vote on day 2.

Also keeping an eye on DC, he seems to be relying very heavily on his busy schedule to keep himself off radars, but I am not sure if that's because he's innocent and doesn't want us to waste a lynch on him because he's truly just that busy, or if he's using it as cover to hide his mafia nature.

End of Day 5

Start Day 6

I tired to log in last night, but kept getting a database error. I am relieved to be able to log in today at least. I'm hoping that the lack of activity last night is a sign that I wasn't the only one who could not log in. Unfortunately, I don't have much to contribute today. I am keeping my vote on Andi unless she can somehow convince me she's not mafia. It's gonna have to happen quick though because I will be playin WoW with my hubby most of the day today and tomorrow I'll be at my moms house most of the day for a bday party for myself and my baby brother.

End if Day 6

Start Day 7

Checking in to let ya'll know I am still here, still playing, just not nearly as well as I'd like. I thought I would have more time to play, but RL has been very hectic and demanding lately. I am stunned to see us down 3 townies after last night and the mafia are only down 1 from night 1 = ( Hopefully our hit nails a mafia, as well as our lynch so we can even things up a bit, it's getting too close to the point where mafia will win if they out number us. And no more UDs!!!!

I have not had a chance to read all of the posts. I just woke up =( I am going to go back through and reread the posts so I can make an informed decision (but don't expect it until late tonight or early tomorrow because I am not even going to be home today). I did look to see if Andi had posted anything worthwhile to make me think she might be a townie, but at first glance, I didn't see it. I am going to put a vote on her just in case I can't log in again before nightfall, but it is subject to change once I get caught up.

I vote to lynch Andi.

This is what caught my eye.. While I do feel that Andi is mafia you didn't remember that you had already voted Andi??

Overall I'm not getting any kind of a mafia vibe from Swade simply put she seems to have some insights that I can agree to but this last double vote thing does seem a little strange. Still going to leave her as only leaning mafia maybe neutral.

 

[brains2]

Hope everything is ok with the young one mate..

He's miserable but its to be expected.. Just trying to keep liquids in him right now.. But its going around his school like mad.. The only wierd thing is that he seemed fine this morning.. But he got to school and lost his breakfast on his desk.. He's running a temp now (not to high thank God) and I've called the ask a nurse line and am going by their recommendations for the time being.