Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

IceH2O said:
Wouldn't it help the other voters to see what you're thinking? We can't look into your gut and see any evidence to help us decide to vote JM.

I am assuming. I'm assuming that you would vote for the person you have the best case against which seems to be LG and not JM.
Click to expand...

I actually do not have a case against Lady right now, I do like to argue with her though. If you get her riled enough she slips up and starts posting like a whacko...she goes and grabs 10 or 15 quotes and talks about them all at once keeping others confused and then she gets caught in her lies.

She is doin a pretty good job of it and I have her leaning more pirate than innocent. Did you notice the bull crap about when she normally posts....all you have to do is go back and check previous games and you you will find she is tap dancing...or doing a jig....

I am sure RL issues will be spit forth to explain the difference in posting times....
 
IceH2O said:
Rb would it make you feel better if we switched to JM?

Did you guys luck out and get 7 pirates and with all the innocent UDs its made it so you guys could sacrifice a pirate thats to busy to play?

Guess she isn't a power role huh, just a normal run of the mill deck laborer?

Then when she shows pirate you can look good?
Click to expand...

Nope. want you and others to vote for who you think is a pirate. I'll post my thoughts as I can and hopefully with good results. I currently see a lot of activity by two good players and a crap load of non-participants. Something you and hook have had issues with, along with me.

When you only have a few folks actively participating, you either team up on one of them or chose a middle of the road player to hassle. I know Judge can play well....she just isn't playing or is laying low....must be hard for her since I know you all but have to gag and chain her from posting.

We have some players coming in with their once every 20-36 posts and they still skim by without attention. Either the active folks know who they are and are letting them lay low without attention or they are on a mission to set up a lynch for the town.

I'll pull posts on folks as I can and if I see something special, my vote will change, but for now it is on judge and will stay there, like last night, until she convinces me she is a townie.


Oh, yeah, as clown suggested...I really recommend all go back and read the rules and think way outside the box....
 
that should read once every 20-36 hours of posting
 
I agree I hate the low posters. But its hard to vote to lynch someone based on that. Maybe if our numbers got to the point where we could chance it but we're down to many players for that right now.

We have no choice but to go with what has or hasn't been said when they do post.

As I said earlier I agree with JM as a vote. I just don't like the reason you are using.

Let me ask in a different way...

What are your thoughts on LC DD and Blue?
 
Well, like I said I need to get my vote out there tonight.

Bob- you still look Pirate to me and have a few votes already.
DD- There are definite inconsistencies in your posts.
JM- You are playing totally different and I think it may be the stress of a new evil PR.

I vote to make Judgemax walk the plank.

I don't want all the votes on a single person at this point, but I personally think they are both Pirate. I can't help but think that maybe Rb is willing to take the lynch to protect a stronger role. He's called her out somewhat, but that could be a tactic. I'll be on for a bit longer for any who want to attack. I may be able to "hit and run" at lunch tomorrow and should be back right around nightfall tomorrow.
 
Blue, needs to post more..though I know she isn't one to post just to post...but inactivity means you you are presenting minimal chance of a slip up and really isn't helpful to the town in the long run. It is bad when they have posted so little, you can't even lean them one way or another.

Lchap....leaning pirate...he seems to be very good as a newbie...at least as a newbie here....

DD....don't trust...no way...no how...could go either way, but slightly leaning innocent...it almost bothers me that some of the low, infrequent posters only come out to attack her.....
 
OK, here is my opinion on the players of this game, thus far...
these are in no special order, I tried to keep them in order of sign up thread.


Grins, she is appearing innocent to me, she has proven herself to be a good player, but she isn't "hiding" this time, which leads me to believe that she has nothing to hide.

Jl, I am still getting used to his more active approach, So I really don't know what to think, when I remember him being the most active, he really had me fooled, so, i have to say, i think him more pirate.

Myself, well, i know I am innocent..

Mad, ..I don't know, he is one, i can never read, ..

MG..Innocent

RB, there is something there, I am not sure what, but he is acting odd, ..

Jpap, he has been abnormally quiet, he has been the last couple games though, but I just think its odd, and I currently have him leaning more guilty

LG, you know, I could kick myself for saying this, But i have her leaning innocent, this is the most cohesive she has been though a game, lmao, maybe staying up late works for her.

lupin;Innocent, ( hope all is well lupin! )

LC: you know, i think, still, that something is very wrong here..I have him heavily as pirate

Mal, ..I agree, that she seems to have gained alot of insight, in a few short days, I find that some what disconcerting, I have her leaning pirate

mee-mee, I have her as (almost def) a pirate, she is just bad at it, lol

Ice: He is always helpful, I think people forget that, he is usually much more helpful, though, imho, when he is guilty, .i still find his vote changes odd, very unlike ICE

DD: you know, i also hate to say this, but I have her mid line, she could really go either way with me at this point, ..

blue: I find her lack of posting, very disheartening, her first game, she was extremely aggressive, .and this game, ..We are seeing almost nothing...

HN, well, what can I say, he is himself, through and through, ..although, he is helpful to the town, its similar to ice..he if guilty, will get more brash, as teh game wears on...

Beth, Innocent


so, my opinions only, and I am going to say sorry one more time, to those that think, i am not helping the town, i have been extremely busy, and am exhausted, I will try to do my best to keep up with the game, form here on out!
 
jeez, a girl steps out to think, and by the time she is done, she is standing on the plank, so this is what kiera felt like?.
 
I vote to lynch LC at the stake i still think, something is off there, and am not willing to back down.
 
judgemax said:
I vote to lynch LC at the stake i still think, something is off there, and am not willing to back down.
Click to expand...


rbishop whispers it is not a Witch game...it is pirates.....
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom