Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

Madcrawdad said:
Seems a little strange. You've been riding LG hard, and then go with the vote for Judge. Based on her recent list, though, I agree that Judge could be scum. Late in day 2 is getting a little late to say that someone is mafia because they just seem 'off' or something just doesn't seem right.

Right now, I'm kind of liking you and Judge. You're both calling each other scum, but neither have much of a reason...both kind of claiming more gut feel than anything.

Problem is, I don't ever believe the sacrificial lamb theories....it's never happened. I think that this may be a case of distancing gone bad.
Click to expand...

Lady G said:
I pulled this cause I agree with MM on this one.


Here, HN say's why he voted her. It was her reactions.


This I just pulled up because I thought maybe we should look at it.


And here are the guy's that didn't vote her...Ice-innocent, RB-innocent, Lupie-innocent. Maybe Jpap is too?? Maybe that is what the clue really was..NONE of the guy's that didn't vote her were Pirate??

Here is the post I was originally looking for, NOW he say's WAY later he thought she may be innocent.


Here, Mad make a good point about HN. Sorry but it is.

Now looking through this of the two, again...I see Mad as more innocent. Although I am rethinking my thought that they BOTH would not be pirate..I'm kinda wondering now if they both may be.
Click to expand...

I hope you still believe that I am innocent but jl didnt vote beth and he was a pirate Lg...
 
LG- I answered the post from Mad. There are several he has not answered, nor has he apparently had time to review as he stated he would. Apparently he's content with letting you try to change the course. Hopefully the town doesn't buy it.
 
Lady G said:
Well, Beth if I was trying to decide between you and someone else, I very well may do that...but I'm not. I'm trying to see of HN and Mad, who would be pirate. I thought I said that at the beginning of the post, but maybe I didn't.
Click to expand...

Holy Slip! Beth?
 
Hooked Newbie said:
LG- I answered the post from Mad. There are several he has not answered, nor has he apparently had time to review as he stated he would. Apparently he's content with letting you try to change the course. Hopefully the town doesn't buy it.
Click to expand...

I'm not buying it...but, you won't mind if I go back and look up your past posts will ya?
 
I never said mad was an innocent grins...thats the thing though, mad always plays middle of the road, never trying to get stuck in the middle of things and trying to stay off the radar. I am having trouble even deciding if he is a pirate to tell the truth. Looking at the voting though does it make sense to vote for a fellow pirate when the voting was so close at the time? That is what I have been trying to figure out...
 
jpappy789 said:
Went back to see if anything from mad stuck out to me and this is all I could find (directed to jl btw)

Pushing hard for a beth vote and slightly implicating jl...not sure what to make of this post. However nothing else except he questioned rb a lot but voted jm instead but...

problem is last night he voted Jm when rb had 5 and jm had only 3 (his vote making 4)...too risky imo. The pirates would have no control over the lynch if people decided to hop on jm instead, although rb was a better choice at the time (at least imo)...unless of the three remaining people (blueiz, myself, and meemee) there was one or two pirates left to vote...blueiz voted rb on reasons that she had earlier in the day and meemee stated her reason was because rb went after beth and wanted mg gone...stuff from day one which has me wondering why she never took any of rbs more recent posts as suspicious...

Another thing is that she says that she would vote for me or jl, a logical vote seeing as that who she was focused on for the entire game basically, but that it would be wasted...even though she was the last to vote and rb was already in the lead by one vote, she decided to land hers there.

I am going to have to rethink my stance on meemee now
Click to expand...
See, things are just not adding up for me that Mad is the pirate. Why would he be the 4th vote on JM, I'm pretty sure Blue is Pirate, Meems well now you are making me think about her AGAIN.

jpappy789 said:
I hope you still believe that I am innocent but jl didnt vote beth and he was a pirate Lg...
Click to expand...
Pap, honestly I think maybe you are innocent, sorry I just got going on the fact Ice, Rb, Lupin were all innocents and just missed JL I guess, I don't know. It had been awhile since I went that far back in depth and when I came across the post I was like WOW!
 
Im invisible for more reasons than this game. If you would like to know how often I view this thread, if Im on AC, Im looking at the game. However I do find it really nice of you to give out a personal invitation for everyone to change there status to visible..

It makes no difference what I say, or what my thoughts are. You will find a way to twist them to fit the ideas you have in your mind. It looks as tho you re finding a way to back down off your train on me, why? Be the leader grins, shovel the coal. Then you can have another innocent lynching under your belt.

I vote to make LC walk the plank, he was next on my list. This is subject to change at any time.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom