Mafia #20 - Pirates of the Carribean the Play

well tell me this Jpap, who do you think is the captain? As I said to LG the captain is the ONLY pirate that Cooke can't protect. It isn't only wise for us to find the captain and end the game...but if we pick some pirate ruse like I believe Blue is we end up not lynching ANY pirates this round.
 
Grins said:
Maybe they both are, but at this point the obvious money is on Mad. Especially after JP just protected him.
Click to expand...

What is so obvious??? You have said this but I do not see where it is sll obvious. He may very well be pirate, but at this point I'm on the fence to say the least with him...where is the obviousness??
 
Grins said:
Which now has me thinking you're both pirates. You have to answer my direct challenge asking the town to decide between you both but you of course don't want to say you're a pirate....but can't out Mad because he is the captain.

Thanks for helping me feel more sure that Mad is the captain now.
Click to expand...

No offense grins but just because you are a known innocent does not mean that the town has to choose between YOUR choices of captain. Obviously I am not going to choose myself. But honestly, how can we for sure tell the difference between blackbeard and a regular pirate? You have a list of your thoughts on pirates but how come I end up as a bb suspect?

*Not trying to grill you as I believe that you are innocent 100% but I am just trying to figure out what you are thinking...
 
Grins said:
I'm not buying it...but, you won't mind if I go back and look up your past posts will ya?
Click to expand...

Not at all. Just keep in mind that I was wrong about Beth, and went hard at her.

jpappy789 said:
I never said mad was an innocent grins...thats the thing though, mad always plays middle of the road, never trying to get stuck in the middle of things and trying to stay off the radar. I am having trouble even deciding if he is a pirate to tell the truth. Looking at the voting though does it make sense to vote for a fellow pirate when the voting was so close at the time? That is what I have been trying to figure out...
Click to expand...

His middle of the road play is what makes him the perfect Captain. Think about it if you're innocent Jpap, if you aren't you have no need to.

Lady G said:
See, things are just not adding up for me that Mad is the pirate. Why would he be the 4th vote on JM, I'm pretty sure Blue is Pirate, Meems well now you are making me think about her AGAIN.


Pap, honestly I think maybe you are innocent, sorry I just got going on the fact Ice, Rb, Lupin were all innocents and just missed JL I guess, I don't know. It had been awhile since I went that far back in depth and when I came across the post I was like WOW!
Click to expand...

Again, you are the one defending him the most. You've made multiple mistakes and I think you're flustered. The pirates should shut you up and send someone else to Mad's defense. Who will it be? Blue, DD?
 
Grins said:
well tell me this Jpap, who do you think is the captain? As I said to LG the captain is the ONLY pirate that Cooke can't protect. It isn't only wise for us to find the captain and end the game...but if we pick some pirate ruse like I believe Blue is we end up not lynching ANY pirates this round.
Click to expand...
see my previous post referencing how the hell are we supposed to pick a blackbeard out of all the suspected pirates in town...

I am not trying to not be helpful but I am just saying that you expect me to come out with a name of someone that I honestly have absolutely no idea who could be bb...
 
Hooked Newbie said:
Not at all. Just keep in mind that I was wrong about Beth, and went hard at her.



His middle of the road play is what makes him the perfect Captain. Think about it if you're innocent Jpap, if you aren't you have no need to.



Again, you are the one defending him the most. You've made multiple mistakes and I think you're flustered. The pirates should shut you up and send someone else to Mad's defense. Who will it be? Blue, DD?
Click to expand...

I agree that he WOULD be a perfect choice as capt. if he was a pirate, the only thing stopping me from thinking that atm is his vote for jm last night.
 
Lady G said:
Well, Beth if I was trying to decide between you and someone else, I very well may do that...but I'm not. I'm trying to see of HN and Mad, who would be pirate. I thought I said that at the beginning of the post, but maybe I didn't.
Click to expand...

Hooked Newbie said:
Holy Slip! Beth?
Click to expand...

Lady G said:
Holy slip my ***, we were talking about Beth:wall:
Click to expand...

Hooked Newbie said:
Yes, but you addressed the post to her! :wall:
Click to expand...


Just so it's clear...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom