Mafia #21 Cabin Fever- The Play

rbishop said:
So, the two of you can really participate when you want too, is what you are saying.....
Click to expand...

hey I have all the time in the world for a week and a half now...but my imput doesnt matter now...
 
LesbianChap said:
Well, this is closest to the truth. Yes, I want to be one of those people no one can ever figure out in future games...I'm looking at the future.

But the main reason I'm doing it is cause I'm a reaction *****...erm, that's prolly gonna be censored so change ***** to addict...and the reactions I'm getting amuse me :)

And I wear it on my sleeve...it throws people off, and causes even a better reaction for me to enjoy.
Click to expand...

Well from the looks of it you need to have read more of the previous games as this has been tried (maybe not quite to the extent you have, but none the less its been tried) and people who do normally become an easy target. Much like Beth has the last several games for her style of play. I'm not saying that I plan on voting for you but you have made yourself an easy choice for quite a few people and I'm seeing people with votes on you now.

rbishop said:
Seems to be just a numbers game to me.

The Detective can not reveal their investigations per the rules, the Doc can only protect on Murders, the accomplice is always investigated as Innocent, the Don is investigated as Innocent until night 4, if the Detective reveals the Don, the Madman wins.

So the Madman just sits back and kills nightly, while the Innocents ban nightly. Unless they get lucky and can convince enough folks to pick the same person. No growing evil team, so the Madman/Accomplice can easily blend in. In fact, I see no reason why the accomplice would even do an investigation.

Just seems like a big crap shoot.

Though I suppose, there isn't anything stopping the Doctor from revealing who the Madman is, once the Detective has found both the Doc and the Madman. It would just be how believable they present it.
Click to expand...

I agree with this observation of the game dynamics.. While in a lot of games night 1 is a crap shoot, this game is even more so to a certain extent. I'm not saying there is anything wrong with the format, in fact I applaud Jpap for having something that is completely different than what we normally play. This in itself will make the game more difficult for the townies but challenging.

rbishop said:
Well, we can't let that happen, Lchap.....let me be accused of train starting and defending you.


Lchap is Innocent!!!!!!


I vote to banish Malbri....

(teenagers bug me...)
Click to expand...

While I don't question the vote RB I do question the conviction of your statement about LChap. I don't believe we can be certain about anyones role as of this point.

jpappy789 said:
ok all...I see how this game can be a crapshoot so if it is ok with you I would like to put in place a group or two of communicating innocents AFTER night 1...its a possibility as I dont want this game to die
Click to expand...

My vote is that you do what you see is fit.. Its your scenario. I personally am making changes to the game format of the Pirates game but am doing so with the knowledge of how that scenario worked for the game as a whole. I think if you make it so the Innocent PR roles can communicate it would even things out a bit. I must admit though I find this format quite challenging and will endeavor to try and play to the best of my ability. Unfortunately this format is also going to have us picking for any small little inconsistency to find out who is the madman..

As of this point I don't like the train that is forming on Lchap, but I really don't have any other suspects as well.. So I'm going to place a vote on who I think Jpap would most likely pick to be the madman or the person he thinks could get away with such a role..

I vote to Banish Ogre
 
rbishop said:
Doesn't sound good and I would expect it from an infrequent poster, such as yourself.

:grinyes:
Click to expand...

jpappy789 said:
sad thing is rb, me and jl are top posters this game
Click to expand...

I didn't think you would like the idea.

:devil:

I don't think I would either. Wouldn't be the same.

Role Play posts shouldn't count. I am also sure when there is real work for me to do, I will not be able to post as much. Most everyone is on break until the first of the year.

Any game where I am a top poster is highly suspicous. Besides role playing and waiting to see who gets killed, I am not sure what else to do.

I am glad most everyone has a sense of humor.
 
clown-lover said:
Well from the looks of it you need to have read more of the previous games as this has been tried (maybe not quite to the extent you have, but none the less its been tried) and people who do normally become an easy target. Much like Beth has the last several games for her style of play. I'm not saying that I plan on voting for you but you have made yourself an easy choice for quite a few people and I'm seeing people with votes on you now.



I agree with this observation of the game dynamics.. While in a lot of games night 1 is a crap shoot, this game is even more so to a certain extent. I'm not saying there is anything wrong with the format, in fact I applaud Jpap for having something that is completely different than what we normally play. This in itself will make the game more difficult for the townies but challenging.



While I don't question the vote RB I do question the conviction of your statement about LChap. I don't believe we can be certain about anyones role as of this point.



My vote is that you do what you see is fit.. Its your scenario. I personally am making changes to the game format of the Pirates game but am doing so with the knowledge of how that scenario worked for the game as a whole. I think if you make it so the Innocent PR roles can communicate it would even things out a bit. I must admit though I find this format quite challenging and will endeavor to try and play to the best of my ability. Unfortunately this format is also going to have us picking for any small little inconsistency to find out who is the madman..

As of this point I don't like the train that is forming on Lchap, but I really don't have any other suspects as well.. So I'm going to place a vote on who I think Jpap would most likely pick to be the madman or the person he thinks could get away with such a role..

I vote to Banish Ogre
Click to expand...

thanks for the suggestions clown :)
 
rbishop said:
So, the two of you can really participate when you want too, is what you are saying.....
Click to expand...

I can post is spurts. Today is a spurt day.

Happy Spurt Day!

Spurt! Spurt! Spurt!
 
I am very bored right now.
 
I have been only drinking Coke with Lime.
 
johnlarson66 said:
I am very bored right now.
Click to expand...

yeah, and There really isn't much we can do in the thread here...I may actually have to resort to * gasp* watching TV!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom