MAFIA 22: Who is who?

Which makes me wonder...if Ice were to play with the "randomness" of power roles, would he also do the same with a random tiebreaking roll? Meaning what are the chances that he'd roll the dice for a mafia to be hit the same night he knew the mafia would hit one of their own? Could it be because both LC and CT are mafia and it didn't matter?

I have to say Grins this is a thought, I thought yesterday about switching to LC, glad I didn't though. But why vote Rb if you think LC could be mafia too?
 
Grins never mind I hadn't caught up yet. Totally disregaurd that question. Thats what I get for posting and reading at the same time.
 
Besides Lchap and Emo, Beth falls in that group also...she hasn't posted much this game and has made many references to past games where she was a newb, also mentioning how the "target" has been taken off her back..hmmm, to me this is a wee bit interesting.

So for now I am going to retract my vote on Lchap, mainly because there are others I think need to be looked at.

So honestly, I have to say Lchap, Emo, Beth, DD, RB and Jmax would be my biggest pics at this point as mafia, I do believe the boss may be one of the newer players though.

Sorry Lady G I had to shorten this a little,okay how does my having sympathy with someone one there first game make me look more mafia? And how is the Target thing a wee bit interesting? I only ask because the game where every one was gunning for me, and I got really upset, you Lady G did the very same with me. You posted quiet a few times about how you sympathized with me and understood what I was going through. I was being nice to someone who seemed upset. But take it as you will.
 
Talking about people just popping in...Jmax, what gives are you going to give any opinions this game, your quietness is very troublesome. My vote may be going her way if only to get her to post.

I am truly sorry, real life issues have me in somewhat of a bind, i am trying my best to atleast keep updated on the thread, which in itself, is proving troublesome, ..I am hoping that by sat night, things will have cleared up, and i will be able to participate more. Please forgive my absence, but do know, that when i pop in, and vote, i am doing so, after reading every single post.
 
*yawns* good morning. Let me do what I can here.

I see Ogre has already done my worst-case/best-case scenario thing...so I'll not repost that. Instead, let me go on my suspect list:

RB - Vote switches, in #450 he said he did it to save my *** and give me a 50/50, when he changed it from CT 6 - LC 4 to 5-5. Lying about his motives makes him seem more Mafia to me...if he didn't switch and encourage others to do so, (HN being the only one that did, and he would have made is LC 5 - CT 6) I wouldn't have needed a lucky save.

Clown - *****ing about the nightfall time being early so HN could switch his vote again...Erroring on his vote tally and making me look like scum because of it. Not much from his has stood out. I don't like how he "gave me a break" and then the next post has LG accusing us of being linked...chances are against it, but maybe they're talking and that's their master plan to get ya'll to go after someone that seems more innocent to them?

Other people I'm watching, but haven't gone back to make a case: LG, Emo, and Grins have my eye as well. Emo because his posts are looking more and more like a Mafia newb, Grins because she's barely adding anything to the town, just a post here or there that seems to add another person's momentum without new thought, and LG for the LG/Clown thing...but both of them have now retracted their votes against me and I'm trying to figure out if it's cause the train didn't take off, or because they truely are innocent and believe I'm on their team.

I still feel that RB is my best target, then Emo.
 
ok, I get it... so as of last night's end and day start today, we possibly have 2 innocents and 2 mafia's talking. My goodness, some people are so touchy LOL

I'mvery touchy when it comes to people confusing the issue out of either ignorance or malevolence. I thought the statement had been sufficiently discussed to rule out ignorance.

I lso note that in the past you have played similarly when we were a mafia team. I now count you as most likely to be mafia in my book. Since I'll be traveling today (finally)...

I vote to lynch/banish/chop up for fish food Dangerdoll

I think it is worthy to note, as you lightly did, and even though it would be somewhat against the odds, is if the Mayor found the innocent that is the policeman. That would make an interesting Game Day 2 with an increased chance for three deaths.

True, bu then the Mayor probably wouldn't be so silly as to blindly have the cop waste his two shots and maybe take out another innocent... I hope.

#461 you know Grins it feels nice like I really am part of the group now, not just a target. NOw lets get more mafia,

This sounds super mafiaish to me. I realize they are not part of a group... unless Grins is the boss and beth is the first contact... which on the face of it doesn't make sense with all the talk of Ice 'supposedly' making preferential choices.

I am truly sorry, real life issues have me in somewhat of a bind, i am trying my best to atleast keep updated on the thread, which in itself, is proving troublesome, ..I am hoping that by sat night, things will have cleared up, and i will be able to participate more. Please forgive my absence, but do know, that when i pop in, and vote, i am doing so, after reading every single post.

Good luck with all that JMax.

As just mentioned, I will be heading home after a week of nearly pure hell. So, we're getting ready and once we leave it'll be 5-7 hours until more contact... see ya.
 
AquariaCentral.com