Mafia #23 Revenge

Ok, heres my views on players so far...with numbers and text.

lady-3-I think you are innocent, not a 100% sure though. Nothing screams mafia in your posts, you seem like you are helping the town.

ogre-6-Nothing really to go, not posting that much. Could that mean he is mafia and doesn't want to say much incase he slips (again maybe)?

hook-5-Not sure about you.

ice-7-Yours posts have lately not sat well with me, I think you may have a hidden agenda...I'm leaning mafia currently.

blue-6-I don't think you are helping out the town much, but I don't know your playing style. Never played with you before.

clown-5-Like I said previous, your posts yesterday seemed a little mafia'ish', though today they don't. Not sure about you.

DD-5-Not sure.

emo-5-Two posts, can't really go on much.

lchp-7-Weird behavior, and the new the 'detective ploy' has started to make me lean to mafia with you.

beth-4-Leaning innocent.

bkw-6-I have a bad gut feeling about you, that only puts you up to a 6 on my list though.

cool-6-Not been that helpful, most posts are goofy or really have nothing substantial in them.

grins-9-I really think you are mafia. You seem to be defending yourself alot of the time, your posting style is off, and my gut says "mafia".

mad-5-I am really not sure about you now.

judge-7-Reasons stated previously.

king-5-No read yet.

ZS-5-No read yet.



Matt
 
Madcrawdad said:
Alright, based on that post, I'm assuming that you're claiming to be the former detective...

To the rest of the town questioning whether RB would or wouldn't have switched the role of detective, I can't say with certainty. But I think for the town, he might have.

Here's one of LChap's very early posts that had me a little concerned. It was his response to me and a couple other folks as to why he had been playing so oddly, apparently trying to get himself lynched.


If you'll notice the part that I bolded 'but lessons must be taught.' When I saw this, one of my first thoughts was, 'what if this guy's a PR and trying to get lynched just to prove a point.' It seems a little far-fetched, but I also play the game on another site and in my first game a townie played intentionally scummy 'to teach a lesson...'

So, if RB knew that LChap was detective and thought he might be intentionally trying to get himself lynched it wouldn't be that far out there IMO for him to consider moving the role. The only thing that I can't work out, though, is why he would have waited until after LChap had apparently begun to actually play the game to do so...

Not positive, but not out of the realm of possibility. A very unusual situation, as whether or not LChap is now innocent or mafia, his revelation serves no purpose other than to get himself killed?
Click to expand...

Mad, I could totally see LChap doing this as a lesson if it were not for the whole bit with having the detective role taken away from him. That part and the way he keeps changing the order things suposedly happened is what makes me still call BS.
 
so is supposed to be actual, And I have to say I know almost everyone myself included is voting for LC, but something is bothering me with the once again the attention is deflected. Anyone else feel this way or is it just me.
 
Ok, guys/gals...I am going to get my vote in, I have some stuff I need to get done and I have been on here trying to get caught up for what 2 hours now!! Anyway..I vote to lynch Grins

Sorry all this "deflection" stuff has to be toward her or Jmax, I know how out there Jmax has been and Lchap well, I think he has been sniffing to much of something. Not sure what to think of him besides he is just nuts this game. We can deal with all that another time, so many have jumped on him and Jmax though I just can't put my vote there, I just feel most strong about Grins at this time.

Everything is subject to change, and I will be back before long to look through and post more thoughts.
 
Day Two Ends: 7PM CST Thursday 1/10
(18 Players) No Vote: (3) emo, cooldude, Mad
4-Grins: Blueiz(992)Ogre(1016) HN(1161) Cory(1188) King(1265) Beth(1470) LChap(1505) LadyG(1517)
7-LChap: clown(1002) clown(1307) ZSandmann(1335) King(1347) Blue(1361) Grins(1429) DD(1480) Beth(1484) bkw(1495)
0-elmo: Zsandmann(1122)clown(1169)Lchap(1231)
3-JM: Ice(1154) clown(1285) Ogre(1323) clown(1324)
0-Blue: Lchap(1281)
1-Ice: JM(1503)
 
Sorry I have to go with my first choice: I promise I won't change again.
I retract my vote on LC
I vote to Lynch Grins
if she goes and is innocent I will accept full ownership
 
ZSandmann said:
Mad, I could totally see LChap doing this as a lesson if it were not for the whole bit with having the detective role taken away from him. That part and the way he keeps changing the order things suposedly happened is what makes me still call BS.
Click to expand...

unfortunately, the inconsistencies do make it difficult to sort through.



Also, to get it out there I vote to lynch Grins

Could change. I may talk myself into voting for Ice instead...

At this point, my top pics for mafia would be:

Ice
Grins
Clown

maybe DD? for the 2nd day in a row, she's kind of swooped in and voted for the candidate of the moment

I've already given reasons for Ice and Grins, Clown will follow in a later post.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom