Mafia #26: Roadside Picnic the Game

[Swayde]

Just because I saw something I thought suspicious doesn't mean it is fact. I explained why I thought differently. I never said it cleared her, I only said it lowered her.

She'll be watched closely, where her votes fall, how they jump, when they are placed etc to see any scumtell but right now it just looks to be confused newbie.

I have a hard time believing she's just a confused newbie. Her posts seem very well thought out, intelligent, and she seems to have a pretty solid grasp on how to play this game, and her role playing looks like she's had some experience at it. Not willing to let what I think to be a slip slide, because it's screwed me up too many times before.

I don't see RB as evil. He's a little bold for that this game. Usually what I've noticed is he tries to be more objective when he's bad and I'm seeing a lot of opinions from him. I could be wrong. This is just my thoughts currently.

Ice, who knows? He goes after people no matter which side he's on. Since he hasn't come after anyone for saying they can't post much and then don't, I have to give him the benefit of doubt and lean him towards a townie trying real hard to kick in some doors. Yeah Ice, I ain't letting that one go and you probably don't remember, but you got me lynched while I was innocent and you were bad and since you're not taking advantage of any of the low posters I gotta at least think just maybe you are innocent.

LG, Jensons, Ogre, BKW, JL, Plant...Can't tell either way, seem very normal to me, but those guys can be quite tricky.

Coler, if your innocent...please act more like a team player. I'm getting a bad vibe from you.

No opinion either way on anyone else either because I'm not familiar with their gameplay, or they haven't posted enough to really form an opinion.

As of now, I don't see a better candidate so my vote shall remain on Grace until I am convinced she's innocent, or until someone more obviously evil jumps out at me.

 

[IceH2O]

I have a hard time believing she's just a confused newbie. Her posts seem very well thought out, intelligent, and she seems to have a pretty solid grasp on how to play this game, and her role playing looks like she's had some experience at it. Not willing to let what I think to be a slip slide, because it's screwed me up too many times before.

I'm not discounting that she might have slipped but you can't base confused newbie on smartness and RP ability. The fact that she can make well written posts and RP well doesn't necessarily mean she had the roles correct.We still have almost 48 hours to see what transpires.

 

[bkw1982]

Your one contribution to the thread/game so far hardly defines a case. In fact, your own post talks about interactions between me ice and grace and I really have ignored her until the latest post by me. I definitely did not need your post to go after Ice...I have been picking at him all day.

You will need more activity here to deduce I am scum from one sleazy moment of posting, bkw and not even to be able to complete an accurate train of thought that is contradictory to your own statements.

Oh, in addition bkw, Ice voted for me close to 80 posts ago....I am really "paniced" now...(if that is a real word...??)

I dont see what my post count has to do with me reading the thread and coming to a conclusion.

The atks on my spelling just tells me you're fustrated

My response to the red: I dont see what ice voting for you has to do with anything, unless you're telling me you're going after ice cause he voted for you.

In fact, Ice, you were the first one to call her out on it....

you been picking on ice all day. but the above statment tells me you're just pointing fingures

IMO RB you're packing on the scum

 

[Rbishop]

I dont see what my post count has to do with me reading the thread and coming to a conclusion.

The atks on my spelling just tells me you're fustrated

My response to the red: I dont see what ice voting for you has to do with anything, unless you're telling me you're going after ice cause he voted for you.




you been picking on ice all day. but the above statment tells me you're just pointing fingures

IMO RB you're packing on the scum

Wow...keep it up,,,you will hit 3, matbe 4 posts before night fall. Nope, not going after Ice, just farting with him as normal. You stated I was after ice, an obvious improper conclusion...something that I would expect from a part time player...kind of an Emo thing.

 

[Lady G]

I've a bottle of that in my freezer. I'm fairly certain that it is free of radioactivity. Anybody care for a shot? :headbang2:

LOL, Jensons..the last time I had a shot of Jager with you, you were the madman(woman)...not sure I'll be drinking that with YOU again anytime soon:silly:

Wow...keep it up,,,you will hit 3, matbe 4 posts before night fall. Nope, not going after Ice, just farting with him as normal. You stated I was after ice, an obvious improper conclusion...something that I would expect from a part time player...kind of an Emo thing.

Ummm, Ok I know I'm not suppose to say this...but I'm a little confused here, how are you NOT going after Ice????

From the posts I have read by you, you sure seem to be going after him pretty hard....or are you trying to get others to feel he is scum and vote him based on your posts...in turn having the innocents do your dirty work?

 

[Lady G]

Well DUH.

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh: ICE said... "WELL DUH" :rofl::rofl::rofl: OMG, that cracked me up for some reason!!!!erv:

 

[Rbishop]

Still nothing from rws or jpap....

 

[OgreMkV]

Coler voting Cory makes that the 2nd vote on someone on a less then stellar case. Ogres vote was weak enough but the 2nd one looks even scummier.

I agree totally. I really didn't have a case and someone following me at this point is just nuts.

The interactions between ice, grace, and Rb is what stands out to me first.
of the 3 newbs she is getting alot of attention from these two, granted of the 3 newbs she is the only one to post over 1 post.

IMO

1) They either are trying to get to her to slip up and reveal herself if she is a baddy.

2) they're tryin to create a slip up so that she can say something incriminating and then jump on it and have every one vote an innocent but giv a reason why they voted. This happend last game with EMO, the bad guys jumped at the chance to to sway voting based on emos bad grammer.

Im leaning toward #2 which would lead me to belive that either ice or rb is scummy. Both have nit picked at graces post, tryin to turn certain words or phrases into confessions or "slip ups"

It's funny really, some people jump on the newbs, I generally give them the benefit of the doubt if only to let them have more than one or two days of play time.

LOL, Jensons..the last time I had a shot of Jager with you, you were the madman(woman)...not sure I'll be drinking that with YOU again anytime soon:silly:

Ummm, Ok I know I'm not suppose to say this...but I'm a little confused here, how are you NOT going after Ice????

From the posts I have read by you, you sure seem to be going after him pretty hard....or are you trying to get others to feel he is scum and vote him based on your posts...in turn having the innocents do your dirty work?

I pretty much see rb going after Ice and Ice going after just about anyone with a post.

However, this does not mean that they are evil. Especially lately, the trend is for evil to stay well out of the first couple of days. Make a few nothing posts and then jump on a train late each day (but not so late as to be the deciding vote).

This makes everyone else look scummy and casts a lot of doubt on the aggressive (i.e. dangerous players). This was used very successfully in our last game.

At this point, I'm very suspicious of those with low (role play NOT included) or no posts. Ice, rb, hooked may be evil or whatever, but they are probably not. Remember that we only have 4 evils out of all of us this game.

 

[Rbishop]

Ogre...I will probably get accused of skimming if I have missed this....but has Z actually stated in this thread, the Innocent/Stalker ratio? I know he tossed some numbers out in the sign up, but darn if I can find it stated in the game play thread.

 

[OgreMkV]

That's true Rb... I guess I could be accused of skimming too then. I'm basing it on what he said in the signup thread.

How 'bout it Z?