Mafia #26: Roadside Picnic the Game

[judgemax]

Swayde, any thoughts on judgemax?

I am also curious of what has you suspicious of me? Please make your case. If I am a stalker, then I have completely hosed my team. I guess I could be a renagade stalker and just not playing as a team.

If you find time to look back you will see day one, I first voted for Coler (and it was not just a lone vote), then went to Ogre (after his 4 stalker comment), I then went to Grace (after the message from ZS saying 6 stalkers). My votes were early and not after the train has formed. I think I was the second vote on grace after you as a matter of fact.

Day two, I voted for Jensons. I did not change it because I was traveling. The information you gave was not out at that time. I think many others thought that Jensons might be a stalker, she has a power role instead. That is a common mistake.

Day three, I am voting for Lady G. This vote stays.

If Lady G comes back a stalker, then I will most likely vote for judgemax. If Lady G is not a stalker, I will join everyone else in voting for you. I highly doubt that in this game with two of the stalkers dying by UD and losing one the first night that a stalker would lynch another stalker. With that said, I will most likely trust you and follow you more than the others.just out of curiosity, why if LG comes back as stalker, would you vote me?..I am not getting the connection..when i clearly have no problem voting her, and had no problem last night as well?..

I guess I am suspicious for following you, that is all that makes any sense.

 

[johnlarson66]

No hit, but they'll be busy....

Guessing that they'll get an investigation? I really hope they don't investigate me.

This post bothered me when I first saw it, but I let it slide. I thought you were implying you were the doctor.

I seem to be the one that forces the issue at times and did not think it would be good for the town to bring out the doctor at that time. Now I know that you are not the doctor. I also know that others could have thought of your post the same way. This is almost asking to get hit, but the stalkers hit Jensons, who was the doctor. Odd that you were not investigated or hit.

So why did you hope they don't investigate you? We only have one doctor. I think now is a good time to explain.

 

[johnlarson66]

Judgemax, don't be confused, even though you seem to be playing the confused call often this game.

Your lone vote for Hooked Newbie on day one is what first started me to be suspicous of you. There are multple other reasons, mostly your lack of sharing your information. I still did not really see where Jensons let it be known she was the doctor, I was waiting for a multi quoted post to explain it, maybe what you had posted was an attempt to explain it. I didn't see it.

At this point, even though you have been going after HN and HN has been going after you. The two of you are my top suspects and the two I suspect the most and trust the least. As far as others, I always have trouble trusting Ice, his split the vote idea was odd. Ogre is another, he was almost tossed into the zone and was saved by the Mod, if that post was not made, Ogre was going to the zone. I also have not seen a whole lot form BKW, but that is his style.

I will be curious of who the stalkers hit and what strange new twist will come into play.

 

[judgemax]

Judgemax, don't be confused, even though you seem to be playing the confused call often this game.

Your lone vote for Hooked Newbie on day one is what first started me to be suspicous of you. There are multple other reasons, mostly your lack of sharing your information. I still did not really see where Jensons let it be known she was the doctor, I was waiting for a multi quoted post to explain it, maybe what you had posted was an attempt to explain it. I didn't see it.

At this point, even though you have been going after HN and HN has been going after you. The two of you are my top suspects and the two I suspect the most and trust the least. As far as others, I always have trouble trusting Ice, his split the vote idea was odd. Ogre is another, he was almost tossed into the zone and was saved by the Mod, if that post was not made, Ogre was going to the zone. I also have not seen a whole lot form BKW, but that is his style.

I will be curious of who the stalkers hit and what strange new twist will come into play.

Well, in my defense, i voted for HN. because, it was a first day crap shoot. and, i was to busy to come back, and update my vote, ..and it was more out of jest, then anything, ..After that, i really haven't been "after" him,. all that much, ..

I did bring a post forth, ..if that doesn't atleast show you some of my thinking, i am sorry, I tried, ..

wasn't being confused, i asked a question inside your quote, so i just put that smile there because he had question marks.

 

[Swayde]

Judgemax, don't be confused, even though you seem to be playing the confused call often this game.

Your lone vote for Hooked Newbie on day one is what first started me to be suspicous of you. There are multple other reasons, mostly your lack of sharing your information. I still did not really see where Jensons let it be known she was the doctor, I was waiting for a multi quoted post to explain it, maybe what you had posted was an attempt to explain it. I didn't see it.

At this point, even though you have been going after HN and HN has been going after you. The two of you are my top suspects and the two I suspect the most and trust the least. As far as others, I always have trouble trusting Ice, his split the vote idea was odd. Ogre is another, he was almost tossed into the zone and was saved by the Mod, if that post was not made, Ogre was going to the zone. I also have not seen a whole lot form BKW, but that is his style.

I will be curious of who the stalkers hit and what strange new twist will come into play.

What do you think of Ice, JL?

Why has nobody mentioned Jpappy and where is Jpappy?

In JM's explanation post about Jensons tipping her role, it really did seem like it to me and it looked like Ice jumped on it as well. I agree with JM's point of view on that one and find it odd you don't see it and are making a big deal of it. I also find it odd that Ice spoke up that he'd noticed something, Jensons replied, and the next thing you know, Jensons is dead.

JL you seem very defensive. I have a feeling about you and Ice, that I don't have with anyone else. It was the same feeling I had for Grace, and LG, and Coler (although I never needed to really express that much). Granted it was the same feeling I had for Jensons, but fortunately that was cleared before it was too late.

I am suspicious of Ogre and BKW, but don't really have a case for them. I am not a good case builder...I go with my feelings more often than not. I know it's not the most helpful for the town, but that's just the way it is.

 

[judgemax]

What do you think of Ice, JL?

Why has nobody mentioned Jpappy and where is Jpappy?

In JM's explanation post about Jensons tipping her role, it really did seem like it to me and it looked like Ice jumped on it as well. I agree with JM's point of view on that one and find it odd you don't see it and are making a big deal of it. I also find it odd that Ice spoke up that he'd noticed something, Jensons replied, and the next thing you know, Jensons is dead.

JL you seem very defensive. I have a feeling about you and Ice, that I don't have with anyone else. It was the same feeling I had for Grace, and LG, and Coler (although I never needed to really express that much). Granted it was the same feeling I had for Jensons, but fortunately that was cleared before it was too late.


Ice, i feel is the next best candidate for stalker IMHO, ..because of what i stated prior.


I am suspicious of Ogre and BKW, but don't really have a case for them. I am not a good case builder...I go with my feelings more often than not. I know it's not the most helpful for the town, but that's just the way it is.

Ice, i feel is the next best candidate for stalker IMHO, ..because of what i stated prior.

I am leaning innocent on JL at the moment, he seems to be suspecting alot of the same people i do, ..his questions and concerns seem valid .

OGRE now, this whole situations seem to have me fizzled, i dont understand why he was saved. it just seems odd, ..thats all i can really say about that, .i just dont get it?..

 

[IceH2O]

Also, please post where Jensons "made it obvious that she was the dr". I did not see it. Please put a quote or something. It appeared to me that Jensons looked like a stalker and until Swayde told of the investigation, most others did also. I think the main thing that would have cleared her is Lady G's vote for her, after we find out if Lady G is a stalker.

I would like to know more about how you thought Jensons was the Doctor. I do not think anyone else did. It is easy to think someone is evil when in fact they have a power role. I just did not have any indication she might be the Doctor.

These are the 2 posts that I saw that made me think she was either the Dr or trying to trick us into thinking she was.

Yeah us!!!!


Praise Bala, I will survive to help heal AC of this horrible Alien threat to our safety.

~xoxo~

Doctor, help me!!!!!!!!

When she asked for the Drs help I knew she couldn't be saved by a lynch so thats when I started thinking she might in fact be the Dr and trying to let us know.

However, Ice is usually smart enough to not say anything, which is what makes me a little more concerned about it now?..he brought it up, usually he just says he thinks he knows who ( whatever power role ) is, and lets it go, ..if he says anything, its usually generic, ..so, i am a little concerned, that the
fact that jensons didn't make it through the night, had a little more to do with Ice than we would want to believe, ..esp, since he so suddenly stopped pushing her, and knew she was the dr, .IMHO, i don't get how it all worked out, again, i don't understand the story line, however, I do know, that he knew who she was, and she didn't survive, ..and no one else really noticed, ..so, it seems to me, Ice stopped picking on her, ..and had no worries, ..because he knew she would be gone, ..

does that make any sense to anyone else but me?..

Why would I continue to push Jensons after I thought she was the Dr? I wasn't sure of the fact and why I thought to throw out the keep it close vote.I figured the evils would rather sit on Jensons then LG if Jensons was telling the truth.

This post bothered me when I first saw it, but I let it slide. I thought you were implying you were the doctor.

I seem to be the one that forces the issue at times and did not think it would be good for the town to bring out the doctor at that time. Now I know that you are not the doctor. I also know that others could have thought of your post the same way. This is almost asking to get hit, but the stalkers hit Jensons, who was the doctor. Odd that you were not investigated or hit.

So why did you hope they don't investigate you? We only have one doctor. I think now is a good time to explain.

I was wondering the same thing when he 1st posted it but didn't want to bring it up. I would want to be investigated just so I could be cleared.



By my calculations we are still up 7 innocents 3 Mos 3 Stalkers so its 10-3. Everyone vote me, I'll be a sacrifice just to not have the focus taken away from the real Stalkers.

 

[Rbishop]

Please attack as needed over this post, I am sure some will....

From Zs' rules...

You are a Stalker. You embrace the new technology and the dangers associated with it that have been left behind by the alien visitors. You have access to a limited assortment of Alien Technology that will be used at random intervals. Since the Stalkers are a very closely connected group they may communicate privately. Your group may choose to kill one person per Night after Day 1.

From post #8 by Z....

Nightly order of Events:
[FONT=Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]
Tech
Lynch
Doctor's Protection
Stalker Strike[/FONT]

From Zs' night post...#492...

The Golden Sphere!


So a Tech device comes into play and overrides the night's lynch, putting it on the #2 vote getter...?

It kills the Doc, so if they are dead, their protection if submitted doesn't work that night...and in his post #8, Z doesn't say if the Doc can protect themselves or not, just...

there is a Doctor that can cure the effects of some of the alien artifacts

So why wasn't there a Stalker strike last night?

 

[Rbishop]

And why, with all the experienced game players, hasn't anybody mentioned this?

 

[judgemax]

And why, with all the experienced game players, hasn't anybody mentioned this?

Because everyone is skimming this game