Mafia #29 Biological Badlands #2

Don't we go after JM every game on day 1 for how laid back she is? This last minute charge to have her head has me more than a little baffled. I can't say I have any feeling that she is Evil or Innocent, but I do know that there are better suspects.
 
ZSandmann said:
Don't we go after JM every game on day 1 for how laid back she is? This last minute charge to have her head has me more than a little baffled. I can't say I have any feeling that she is Evil or Innocent, but I do know that there are better suspects.
Click to expand...

Tell us who you think is better.
 
jpappy789 said:
I dont exactly know why but a few of Zsands posts have seemed "faulty" to me...the whole argument with catfish then the switch to Zig that made me look back at his posts...



Basic post by a person who starts posting mid-way through a game.



First goes after Zig (not hard though) for repeating what has been said. But how is that really any different than ZSand's first post?



IMO, mafia like to nitpick but on the otherhand so do innocents so really that doesnt go anywhere. But I also will be keeping in mind that something like this can be blown way out of proportion and so I will wait to see if anything else like this occurs later...



I have not seen Zsand's attitude towards newbs like this in a while. The last time I remeber was the werewolf game when he went after malefic...he was evil that game...just something to take into account

After those thoughts of mine I cant really do anything put just move Zsand up a little further than the majority of the players.



Yes, but it seems like each game you have some new "plan" to get the evils. You could not have possibly predicted some of the reactions to the morse code so I am not buying this. I think it was just something for you and possibly another evil friend of yours to hide behind (who that is I am not sure of)...I would have been just fine if you said it was all in good fun but you saying that you had this whole thing in mind from the beginning is BS IMHO.

Other comments: Grins is not making a whole lot of sense and others are finding the wholes in her logic. Either she is trying to get back into the game or she is evil

So far I have:

Jmax
Ice
Grins
Zsand

on my short list...
Click to expand...


You don't think that it was a good chance that some people would blow up at the morse code? If anyone bothered reading it they'd know there was some type of communicating going on.Was it between all innocents, that I'm not sure of right now. But it did let me know I could write 1 person off as innocent IMO. From what I gathered from the morse code and how people felt about it in either direction will help me with my choices later in the game. The reactions plus votes is a lot better to me in deciding who is what then just votes.
 
jpappy789 said:
I think my thoughts on Zig should be questioned in case he is gone tonight...

Honestly, I do not see him as evil at this point. Too many times I have seen people, especially new players, get angry and start babbling or getting confused while others (usually evils) pick at their mistakes until a big train gets started on them. Now this situation is a little different as there is no big train but I see a lot of people at least highly considering switching, which at this point in the day, is almost a commitment. But also when I look at where it started, I see how this could very well be the lynching of an innocent. If he turns up guilty tonight, fine, but I am not at all convinced that he is evil...even for a night 1.
Click to expand...

I agree and will not vote for Zig at this time, unless he does something real silly in the next 30 mins. Which he might, I saw him viewing.
 
IceH2O said:
You don't think that it was a good chance that some people would blow up at the morse code? If anyone bothered reading it they'd know there was some type of communicating going on.Was it between all innocents, that I'm not sure of right now. But it did let me know I could write 1 person off as innocent IMO. From what I gathered from the morse code and how people felt about it in either direction will help me with my choices later in the game. The reactions plus votes is a lot better to me in deciding who is what then just votes.
Click to expand...

Gonna tell us who that one person is?
 
ZSandmann said:
pappy, why of all the people with votes was I the one you decided to build a case against? And I have been going at Grins, Cat, and Zig all day so why is Grins on your short list with me. I just find the timing and the direction of that post strange.
Click to expand...

I explained that your argument with catfish/Zig made me look back at your posts. Mainly to get my thoughts out there warranting Zig and possibly later catfish's roles. You were the one who started the whole thing, were you not?

And to answer the second part...why should I turn the blind eye because you are after each other?
 
jpappy789 said:
I think my thoughts on Zig should be questioned in case he is gone tonight...

Honestly, I do not see him as evil at this point. Too many times I have seen people, especially new players, get angry and start babbling or getting confused while others (usually evils) pick at their mistakes until a big train gets started on them. Now this situation is a little different as there is no big train but I see a lot of people at least highly considering switching, which at this point in the day, is almost a commitment. But also when I look at where it started, I see how this could very well be the lynching of an innocent. If he turns up guilty tonight, fine, but I am not at all convinced that he is evil...even for a night 1.
Click to expand...

I had honestly forgotten you were playing Pappy. This post seems to make me twitch. You're already qualifying things for TOMORROW when I (and others, I think) are spinning in circles today.
 
OgreMkV said:
Bull cookies. You say that based on one response, this person, whom you won't name is innocent. Then you claim my reactions make me guilty. This is exactly what I was writing about when I voted for you. you just make up some criteria and declare that someone is guilty and someone else is innocent based upon unknown criteria. Bull cookies. You're just making stuff up now.



Like this is never happened before?!?!?!?





Yes, I would have follwed her onto you, as you might recall I had picked you for scum much earlier. However, she moved onto JMax and I don't buy that for a heartbeat.

Comon, you guys know how JMax plays, if she was a bad guy, she'd be all up in this. Making mistakes maybe, but she'd be there. The only reason she wouldn't be in this is if one of her evil teammates told her NOT to get involved. That doesn't give me enough to vote for her though.



see above



Again, you make something up using totally vague criteria, then declare someone innocent and someone guilty. I say again, bull cookies.
Click to expand...

It wasn't one reaction from the person it was an accumulated response. Don't go twisting what I mean to fit your mold.

As I stated above, I use what means I need to help me make decisions.

Do yourself and myself a favor and hit me tonight. I'm not going to argue my game play which hasn't changed in 20+ games just to keep you from getting me lynched.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom