Mafia 30: Witness Protection - The Play

[[AC] C-note]

I think once the game is over, there should be a chance to guess who was who. Everyone that wants to, gets to submit a list and posts it before Mad tells us.

 

[[AC] Tree_Hugger]

IDK But, I do see both of your points about what you are trying to say but one of you seem too be mafia to me. But then again the way games seem to get played it seems that the innocents are always the first ones to cut their own throats. All the while the evils just interject little comments and make themselves look innocent. They let the others run themselves ragged and tear themselves to shreads picking themselves off. Well with the way this day one is going it seems that this one will be no different.

You see both points, yet you quote 3 people. But I do agree with you, it generally is innocents who go at each other on the first couple of days, which is why I am looking more to the people who are non-committal, and try to slip under the radar as much as possible.

 

[[AC] C-note]

going to be a tough game.

we cant trust anyone now!

That is no different from any other game, unless you happen to be on a team....

Got any other statements to make?

I was going to post about this and still will. If anything, I feel that I can judge a player by how they are playing and not from anything in the past or past games. Not that I can trust anyone more, because everyone is guilty until proven innocent, but I can make choices based on this game and not about the past. I think wing nut should be watched.

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

Rickets, I would like to share a something I found on the internet about the mafia and apple pie.



They are talking about John Gotti. Are you telling us you are the Don?

WELL, i guess you caught me!!! Yea, you caught the don quan of apple pie. :lipssealedsmilie:

OOOOOH, BTW i think only mafia would go look for something of that nature on the internet to try and incriminate someone who is just trying to make an innocent joke. THANKS!!!:silly::silly:

 

[[AC] RICKETS]

Rickets, I would like to share a something I found on the internet about the mafia and apple pie.



They are talking about John Gotti. Are you telling us you are the Don?

You see both points, yet you quote 3 people. But I do agree with you, it generally is innocents who go at each other on the first couple of days, which is why I am looking more to the people who are non-committal, and try to slip under the radar as much as possible.

Sorry, I dont know how that other one got there????

 

[Madcrawdad]

I think once the game is over, there should be a chance to guess who was who. Everyone that wants to, gets to submit a list and posts it before Mad tells us.

At game's-end folks are welcome to guess away. I won't post the list of who-is-who until players are ready.



On a separate note, I'd like to try something different this game regarding UDs....

Hopefully nobody will need to leave the game. But if someone does, I'd appreciate if they would give me as much notice as possible. My plan is to line up a few replacements, one of which could step in, and take over the role/ID (as opposed to just UDing the role).

Obviously if you don't vote, you're done. If you give me enough notice, however, it might be possible to get you replaced.

 

[[AC] BadHaggis]

you are misquoting me which i was just advised is a mafia play. o think your chances of being mafia are higher than the 23.5% of everybody else. you post nothing, i question it, you comeback and call me stupid, i respond, you put words in my mouth. why?

No, I'm not.

Your choice of words is interesting. 'You were just advised'

Presumably you are referring to this

So do you need specific advice that deliberately misquoting someone (which would be impossible in a game like this anyway, there is after all a record, perhaps you meant misinterpreting) is evidence of someone being mafia ?

Is your post supposed to show everyone that you are just a poor simple newb who doesn't know anything except what other people tell them ?

Is someone telling you what to say ?

These by the way are rhetorical questions that I'm asking out loud. I don't expect that you will answer them in any unpredictable way.



No, I didn't.

you "interpreted" what i said and placed it into quotes = misquoting. no?

no one is telling me anything, nor am i talking to anyone besides you.

so IQ, would you then say that Nemesis is "advising you"? this whole thing gets a bit misconstrued and I just want to understand exactly what is trying to be said here.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

I would have to say the ones jumping most out to me right now would have to be...
Hammerhead
Hi-IQ
Treehugger
Really not real huge vibes from anyone at this point and there are others that have raised suspicion in my mind, but these three have raised my brow a little more then others at this point.


For one, yes it would make since especially if YOU are Lady G, really doesn't matter to me if you are or not honestly...as this would not really mean you are mafia just because of that. I really have know idea if Mafia can tell each other their names or not, but being they are team mates I don't know that it would matter if they did know. Quick to think that they can't though aren't ya?



Now, but didn't you just say it was pointless to try and figure who is who at this point...but now it is making you wonder so much that you went back to the sign up thread to check it out?


Since when are 2 votes a "train", just think it is funny you pointing this out that there is a "train" starting....makes me wonder if you NO that UhOh is innocent and you want to be able to come back and say, you pointed out the train and can through suspicion on the two that supposabley started the train? I find it very hard to believe Mafia would vote the same on day one...so which of the 2 "train starters" do you think are the Mafia player?

IF I were G, then your original post about me hinting at her alt id might make a little sense but why would I wanna hint who I really am. Isn't it against the rules? And if I were Mafia with her why would I wanna even draw more attention to her goof up? I don't know if the Mafia are telling each other their alt id's but I've been thinking that if they are using the same old sign on's in chat, I'm sure they will be able to figure each other out and who but they are to know if they tell each other? I'm wondering if you know all this already as you seem to be in the know. And I have wondered if YOU aren't Lady G even before this last post. The posting style is very similar and spelling as well. It wouldn't matter if you were other than the fact that you are trying to say that I am G. Hmmm, why would you wanna do that if you were G? The only reason I can think is because you are Mafia.

I said it was pointless to belabor who Lady G is at the moment. Like some have pointed out, posting on the wrong id doesn't make one automatically Mafia. However I would like to know who all I'm playing with, especially if I've played w/them b4. It helps me to sort things out better in my mind.

I never said I thought the 2 pple on UhOh were Mafia, but UhOh is the leading vote getter and for scoop411 to have come out and thrown more suspicion his way, yet not vote, it made me slightly suspicious of scoop. I have decided that UhOh maybe new to the game and not Lady G as I once thought.

 

[[AC] Hammerhead 991]

At game's-end folks are welcome to guess away. I won't post the list of who-is-who until players are ready.



On a separate note, I'd like to try something different this game regarding UDs....

Hopefully nobody will need to leave the game. But if someone does, I'd appreciate if they would give me as much notice as possible. My plan is to line up a few replacements, one of which could step in, and take over the role/ID (as opposed to just UDing the role).

Obviously if you don't vote, you're done. If you give me enough notice, however, it might be possible to get you replaced.

Sounds like a good idea Mad. It would make the games more fun if we could stop losing players due to UD's.

Gotta run off to a late lunch and catch up later.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

IDK But I see allot of people trying to make sense of who is who, and not playing the game, Identities don't matter. Sure its fun to try and surmise it,( even I am doing that) but its irrelevant in the long run. Maybe Instead of worrying about who is what screen name, we should be focusing on who is really contributing, and who is diverting.