Mafia 31: Bounty Hunter Edition

[ZSandmann]

Why do people keep thinking there are possibly 5 mafia at this point when Ice had said there are less than 5? I can't think of many reasons other than mafia wanting us to debate the details instead of looking at the obvious.

By everyone I assume you mean me, as I mentioned it before I went to bed last night. It is semantics really, Ice gave us a range of 1-5, I personally do not believe there are five but I will not exclude the possibility when we just don't know to be honest. I would rather overestimate so that I stay on the offensive looking for them. Why are you so hot and bothered by people mentioning there could be "up to" five?

 

[ZSandmann]

Scoop I am glad to see you acting sane again, I am not sure what your motive for the brewhaha last night was but it has my attention now. You never answered my question though, you added me to your Mafia list just before night and today I am not on it again. Why do you think I am Mafia? Do you no longer think so?

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

By everyone I assume you mean me, as I mentioned it before I went to bed last night. It is semantics really, Ice gave us a range of 1-5, I personally do not believe there are five but I will not exclude the possibility when we just don't know to be honest. I would rather overestimate so that I stay on the offensive looking for them. Why are you so hot and bothered by people mentioning there could be "up to" five?

Because they are being dense and the town doesn't need dense people. Ice did not say there was a range of 1-5 people. He said more than one and less than 5...LESS THAN FIVE so that would mean 1-4. Mafia loves to misquote and lead the town in different directions to create chaos. Which one are you dude? Are you being dense or are you mafia?

 

[ZSandmann]

Because they are being dense and the town doesn't need dense people. Ice did not say there was a range of 1-5 people. He said more than one and less than 5...LESS THAN FIVE so that would mean 1-4. Mafia loves to misquote and lead the town in different directions to create chaos. Which one are you dude? Are you being dense or are you mafia?

Neither, I'm telling you MY interpretation of what Ice said, and by YOUR own definition it should be 2-4 Mafia shouldn't it? I told you I don't think there are five so I'm going to drop it now because this conversation is going nowhere. Let's focus on people we believe are Mafia. I've given my suspects who are yours?

 

[Lady G]

Well, thank you for answering at least part of my questions....

I voted Dangerdoll because I believed her to be more likely to be mafia than Driver, so why let it go to a toss. I made a decision and it was wrong. Of course I wish Dangerdoll was not dead now that I know she was innocent. You can say I nailed her coffin I say yah boo that's the game, I have nothing to be ashamed of except with the benefit of hindsight

Of course ultimately I was not the only player who made a decision on Dangerdoll as the Bounty Hunter was taking Dangerdoll anyway it seems. Lady G you spent a good bit of time making a case against Dangerdoll. Are you taking any credit for this ?

And I was wrong on Judgemax. That was more of a hunch based on saying her alias apparently not working where she seemed to imply that she was the fourteenth player etc. and then did not bother to answer any questions.

I am still going on Lady G, then Gunslinger as being mafia. Could I be wrong. Yes. Are they my best suspects, yes. With Lady G shading Gunslinger slightly.

Hooked Newbie is my next consideration. I know he's voting for me which doesn't really concern me at this point. I threw a vote for Hooked who had none at the time, got a bit of a reaction, and then pulled it pronto. This was by no means a scummy move as far as I'm concerned anyway. I think Hooked is over reacting to this and has no real fair case against me.

Yes, I take responsibility for DD, I obviously agree DD looked more mafia then Driver. I do not think you should be ashamed at all, but if you do not think your actions last night warrent a couple questions I don't know what to tell you. You were posting very odd, and yes it made me raise my brow a bit.

Though since DD did come up innocent, really it makes me lean you more innocent....because the only reason I could see mafia acting that way at night fall was to try and pull votes off their Don.

Why so long ? Bladda Bladda Bladda why would you care if I didn't post for 179 posts a)this is a red herring thrown out by you. b) are you saying its scummy to post first post late ? c)Do you really want to know why I 'waited' so long, why would you care ?

My vote on Dangerdoll already explained. I can say no more than that between Dangerdoll and Driver I felt more strongly that Dangerdoll was mafia than Driver. I have a vote, I used it. Unfortunately I was wrong.

Yes, actually I was wondering...no I didn't want a long list of "I was at work , taking the dog out, taking the garbage out..yadda, yadda" Was just looking for MAYBE a reason, maybe "I just wanted to see what others had to say first" or "It was my first chance" something.

No, I didn't say it was scummy...it was just a question that I was wondering, nothing more. If that makes you think I am scum so be it. I was just hoping for a reason that is all.

So you think I am scum, do you care to add why you think this?

 

[Lady G]

I don't see why they used it on night one when so many of the suspicions are about feelings and other pulled out of the air reasonings.

Personally, I can see it simply because the actions at nightfall...did make it look like DD was the Don, I for one thought we really did have the Don. Up until, Scoop voted DD it looked as though it was going to be a toss up and IMO, the Bounty Hunter felt that DD was the Don also and didn't want to take the chance of missing her.

 

[Lady G]

dd
RB
Ogre
Lady G
HN
Zs
JP
AC Driver
AC HI IQ
AC Toes
AC GS
AC Tib
AC Chung
AC Doom

the town should win this game. with only 5 possible mafia and the doc and BH able to stop lynches the odds are in the towns favor. just have to be careful of night 3

Ok, this statement made me uneasy in the beginning so IQ...tell me after last night do you still think it is in "favor" of the town? You see, they always know who is innocent, we never KNOW who is mafia...they start with a huge advantage no matter their numbers IMO. So I was just wondering if you still felt we were at an advantage.

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

Ok, this statement made me uneasy in the beginning so IQ...tell me after last night do you still think it is in "favor" of the town? You see, they always know who is innocent, we never KNOW who is mafia...they start with a huge advantage no matter their numbers IMO. So I was just wondering if you still felt we were at an advantage.

seeing as 3 townies are gone and the doc is gone....no i dont think we are at an advantage.

 

[[AC] scoop411]

Well, thank you for answering at least part of my questions....


Yes, I take responsibility for DD, I obviously agree DD looked more mafia then Driver. I do not think you should be ashamed at all, but if you do not think your actions last night warrent a couple questions I don't know what to tell you. You were posting very odd, and yes it made me raise my brow a bit.

Though since DD did come up innocent, really it makes me lean you more innocent....because the only reason I could see mafia acting that way at night fall was to try and pull votes off their Don.

Yes, actually I was wondering...no I didn't want a long list of "I was at work , taking the dog out, taking the garbage out..yadda, yadda" Was just looking for MAYBE a reason, maybe "I just wanted to see what others had to say first" or "It was my first chance" something.

No, I didn't say it was scummy...it was just a question that I was wondering, nothing more. If that makes you think I am scum so be it. I was just hoping for a reason that is all.

So you think I am scum, do you care to add why you think this?

I will not have you using my failure to answer this silly question as evidence of me being mafia just to get the retaliation in first.

Basically Lady G you appear 'concerned' about lots of stuff but you are low on the specifics. You ask silly questions, and you say silly things which don't really help.

I love that me not explaining to you why I didn't post until 179 is suspicious but you would have been satisfied if I said 'oh I was reading the thread' or 'I've been really busy'.

I don't think I posted odd at all. But of course you are concerned.

I don't love that you lean me more innocent now. This just means I'm to be nailed doesn't it.

 

[[AC] scoop411]

Scoop I am glad to see you acting sane again, I am not sure what your motive for the brewhaha last night was but it has my attention now. You never answered my question though, you added me to your Mafia list just before night and today I am not on it again. Why do you think I am Mafia? Do you no longer think so?

You kind of are Zsandmann, on my list that is. But I will be straight and say that its not more than a hunchy thing based on previous games I have played with you, so it is not all that strong.