Mafia 31: Bounty Hunter Edition

[Rbishop]

UhOh, what happened to your thoughts on Old3Toes? He/she was your vote last night but you have not mentioned them yet today I dont think

The above...follow the conversation...

 

[[AC] UhOhChongo]

Personally, I can see it simply because the actions at nightfall...did make it look like DD was the Don, I for one thought we really did have the Don. Up until, Scoop voted DD it looked as though it was going to be a toss up and IMO, the Bounty Hunter felt that DD was the Don also and didn't want to take the chance of missing her.

Yeah, that is the only reason I could account for doing it. Personally I'd still not have done it. I know DD seemed suspicious to some but from a day one point of view there wasn't anything that was so out of character that it didn't seem circumstantial to me. If you're mafia, sure you want DD out early. But if you're innocent and don't know (and who knows on a day one?) you don't take the hit. I wouldn't.

I do not like UhOh response to the whole "how many mafia" discussion. They are missing the point and now want to call people dense. What my issue is that HI IQ posted that "with only 5 possible mafia and the doc and BH able to stop lynches the odds are in the towns favor." I wanted an explaination. I don't think I ever got it, instead I got a bunch of BS from UhOh about 5 mafia. Thinking that the "odds are in the towns favor" is plain old fashion mis-information. The fact that UhOh wants to jump in this bothers me.

My top two are HI IQ and UhOh.

I vote to lynch HI IQ.

I would also like for UhOh to their thoughts on HI IQ. I think they were diverting attention from HI IQ.

I get the point of the debate over what HiIQ said, but the logic that there could be five people is flawed. Don't believe it ask Ice. I brought it up for the same reason anyone brings anything up..it looks suspicious and what looks suspicious to me is that people keep throwing out false numbers and facts with no support. That is a scumtell. I've made my point on it and if people want to ignore the obvious and think someone is scum for telling them they are acting dense so be it. If you want to know what I think about Hi IQ, I think he isn't using much logic either and looks as scummy as anyone else lacking it.

So I am mafia and bossy. I may be too puhy for some but only trying to get a goo read on people instead of standing on the sidelines like some people...

Some could stand to be a little less aggressive with bush shaking. If they don't have their facts straight and go off on a rant that others follow on we end up doing things like night one...screwing ourselves by lynching the innocent.

I am looking for the Don, they have the power to add another Mafia on Night 3 so we need them gone before then.

This has been discussed to death but here in UhOhs first post they claim that Old3Toes is Bob when Bob was the first to post and clearly said he would not use an alias. This is the first of several instances of scimming I have seen from them, but with only 8 posts it is hard to follow.

I've already made comments about this post but a few additions. Ice said in the start up that these names were drawn at random and they were made for last round so trying to tie Bob to a particular name is a waste. Also, most of UhOhs posts are about the number of Mafia. Yes, it would be nice to know but we can speculate on it till the cows come home, the best way to find out is to lynch some.



The use of "dude" aside UhOh is focused on O3T and the number of Mafia.

Ice had clearly stated 14 players, I agree that Scoop called out JM and still wish we had gotten more info from her. Plus a vote for O3T here for "scummy twisting of facts" which is talking about the number of players.

So here UhOhs list has become: O3T, Gunslinger, and HN. Name calling but no help.

**Yawn**

Scimming the rules of what the BH can do.


This was directed at me when I tried to rationalize our stats. But in fact UhOh can't even keep their own facts straight. If you follow Ices words literally there would be 2-4 Mafia. Regardless I think I have 1 of them.

I vote to lynch UhOh (Spaghetti O's)

Nothing but arguing and semantics, misdirection, and posts that are made to look helpful but do nothing to help us find Mafia. Also, one of the lowest post counts, I believe Scoop may be another Mafia but after the sideshow before Night fall I do not think they are the Don. If Scoop is Mafia and was trying to draw votes off someone it would have to be Driver but I do not really think Driver is evil, so either Scoop is Innocent and is just a little overexcited or is trying to screw with us.

Not going to argue with you as I think you're mafia and anything I say will fall on your guilty deaf ears but could you do me a favor dude and learn to spell "skimming"?

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

well before you yelled at me for not understanding what you meant when you went to an earlier discussion so I can never really tell what posts you are referecing...

and anyways, it could be a mafia tactic but UhOh might have found other suspects and doesnt consider 3toes to be a strong one, but its odd that there was no mention of him...problem is I dont think going at it day one and voting for each other is a great mafia tactic to begin with but still a possibility...I am watching UhOh and 3toes seems more innocent to me...

 

[[AC] Gunslinger]

Yeah, that is the only reason I could account for doing it. Personally I'd still not have done it. I know DD seemed suspicious to some but from a day one point of view there wasn't anything that was so out of character that it didn't seem circumstantial to me. If you're mafia, sure you want DD out early. But if you're innocent and don't know (and who knows on a day one?) you don't take the hit. I wouldn't.




I get the point of the debate over what HiIQ said, but the logic that there could be five people is flawed. Don't believe it ask Ice. I brought it up for the same reason anyone brings anything up..it looks suspicious and what looks suspicious to me is that people keep throwing out false numbers and facts with no support. That is a scumtell. I've made my point on it and if people want to ignore the obvious and think someone is scum for telling them they are acting dense so be it. If you want to know what I think about Hi IQ, I think he isn't using much logic either and looks as scummy as anyone else lacking it.



Some could stand to be a little less aggressive with bush shaking. If they don't have their facts straight and go off on a rant that others follow on we end up doing things like night one...screwing ourselves by lynching the innocent.



Not going to argue with you as I think you're mafia and anything I say will fall on your guilty deaf ears but could you do me a favor dude and learn to spell "skimming"?

Well I dont consider what I am doing as wreckless, but from my viewpoint I am doing what I can to get info from people as some seem reluctant to say what is on their mind...though I can tell you that I am a little surpised my self at how I am playing this game, maybe a little hint at who I really am...

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

Well, last night sucked.Maybe the bodyguard took a chance and wasn't around near nightfall to see how things were progressing...? Who has been absent for a considerable time prior to the nightfall....? and after....?

And Driver really disgusts me....at least if they were going to wimp out and play pouty, they could have pit their vote on no one.

I am leaning Uh Oh and Gunslinger as scum bags right now.

Driver hasn't even bothered to post since the 15th in the afternoon....maybe they knew things were well in hand.....

RB so i dont missinterupt what i see here, can you explain what you're trying to say. To me it looks like you're tryin to peg driver as the BH. You say the BH has to be someone who hasnt been on. you also make it seems like you have driver as a suspect.

I have scoop and driver both as mafia. How do you peg Driver?

 

[Hooked Newbie]

OK. I've been thinking about this all day and I'm going out on a bit of a limb, but my best suspect right now is Z. I read through his posts and he seems to be doing a great job at hiding amongst the weeds. He keeps agreeing with me and no one ever trusts me. That should have set off alarm bells earlier. I've also never seen him be much of a miss-speller. To spell skim with a c twice in one post is weird. I'll be on and off tonight, but will be gone until sometime Sunday afternoon. For now, I vote to lynch ZSandmann. He seems to be doing what I would as the Don.

 

[Rbishop]

Nope not trying to peg anyone as the BH. That would be a call each person in the game has to male, and I wouldn't want it revealed. I have made my share of mistakes in a similar role.

It is just a possibility that each of us should explore, I feel. I just don't see why if the BH was present during the whole nightfall, they would have left their hit on the lynch victim that they had already chosen to hit...!?!

 

[Rbishop]

^ make

 

[ZSandmann]

Yeah, that is the only reason I could account for doing it. Personally I'd still not have done it. I know DD seemed suspicious to some but from a day one point of view there wasn't anything that was so out of character that it didn't seem circumstantial to me. If you're mafia, sure you want DD out early. But if you're innocent and don't know (and who knows on a day one?) you don't take the hit. I wouldn't.

I get the point of the debate over what HiIQ said, but the logic that there could be five people is flawed. Don't believe it ask Ice. I brought it up for the same reason anyone brings anything up..it looks suspicious and what looks suspicious to me is that people keep throwing out false numbers and facts with no support. That is a scumtell. I've made my point on it and if people want to ignore the obvious and think someone is scum for telling them they are acting dense so be it. If you want to know what I think about Hi IQ, I think he isn't using much logic either and looks as scummy as anyone else lacking it.

Some could stand to be a little less aggressive with bush shaking. If they don't have their facts straight and go off on a rant that others follow on we end up doing things like night one...screwing ourselves by lynching the innocent.

Not going to argue with you as I think you're mafia and anything I say will fall on your guilty deaf ears but could you do me a favor dude and learn to spell "skimming"?

Wow I misspelled a word, horror of horrors. You got me I must be Mafia because I am looking for suspects. And now I'm scummy because I am voting for you.

 

[IceH2O]

Nightfall in 24 HRS

vote tally

Day 2

Scoop-1- HN(307)Gun(344)
HiIQ-2-Old3toes(333)LG(338)
UhOh-1-LG(337)Zsand(346)
Zsand-1-HN(366)


no votes : RB Ogre Driver Hi UhOh Scoop