I'm not picking on DD here but in all fairness pointing to voting Ogre yesterday means diddly squat. I think there is more information to be gained in the earlier votes.
Mafia #32 LMAO
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
I'm not picking on DD here but in all fairness pointing to voting Ogre yesterday means diddly squat. I think there is more information to be gained in the earlier votes.
Last thoughts as regards ZS lynching. In circumstances where we know Catfish and Jensons to be innocent, you have to look at the fish and DD votes, which edge ZS ahead each time, as being indicative of innocence. Its a tight vote with no guarantees, and they could not have counted on Catfish and Jensons voting as they did.
You also have to look on Mseckmans vote as being very suspicious but I already said that. Wing Nuts comments awaited; this looks to me as being far more suspicious than some superficial vote hopping by me in posts appearing directly after each other and ultimately landing on the scumbag.
It has helped no doubt to keep me in the game so far though
You also have to look on Mseckmans vote as being very suspicious but I already said that. Wing Nuts comments awaited; this looks to me as being far more suspicious than some superficial vote hopping by me in posts appearing directly after each other and ultimately landing on the scumbag.
It has helped no doubt to keep me in the game so far though
OK I am saying that Mseckman is my best subject today based in large part on the ZS lynching. What I havn't managed to do is think through is the impact of the fact that the two mafia teams were unknown to each other at this time. Effectively my question becomes is it realistic that ZS and Mseckman were on the same team at that point.
Also awaiting Wing Nuts thoughts.
Also awaiting Wing Nuts thoughts.
Sure would help to know what team Ogre and Charlie were on. It seems likely that Ogre and ZS were team mates.
But driver the prob with the ZS lynch is that there were still 2 seperate teams. so that dont make any differance in proving innocence
I know and said that. That's why the question is to what extent is an Mseckman team with ZS likely. This is the importance of the ZS lynch.
I think teams were as follows
team one
ogre
ZS
charlie
team 2
DD
Judge
Mseck
then when ZS was lynched and charlie quit they had to move ogre to the girls team. so with the removal of ogre we have just eliminated only one team. now we need to get the other one.
team one
ogre
ZS
charlie
team 2
DD
Judge
Mseck
then when ZS was lynched and charlie quit they had to move ogre to the girls team. so with the removal of ogre we have just eliminated only one team. now we need to get the other one.
Darn I said it seems likely that Ogre and ZS were team mates - I meant to say ZS and Charlie what with Charlie dropping out and all.
Yeah it would be nice if it was that simple.
I guess the DD vote for instance, putting it on ZS, is less indicative of innocence because she would not (if the above teams are correct) have known that ZS was mafia.
[QUOTE='[AC]
Msek said some strange things and her voting record is a bit erratic.On Z night 1, would have been the kill vote on Pix if C-Note didn't switch on night 2 but first on Ogre night 3.Her vote for Bkw could have been a joke as she said but it would be dangerous to think that way and not assume she skimmed.Especially with the hit being on Bkw that night.
I retract my vote for Fish and vote to lynch Driver his actions look more suspicious to me.[/QUOTE]
Well in fairness you have identified the points that I made. If its your subjective opinion that my voting patterns (unknown D1 (you by the way), Mafia D2, Mafia D3, Mafia D4 (who cares - Ogre)) are suspicious then I think you are at best reading them badly.
Msek said some strange things and her voting record is a bit erratic.On Z night 1, would have been the kill vote on Pix if C-Note didn't switch on night 2 but first on Ogre night 3.Her vote for Bkw could have been a joke as she said but it would be dangerous to think that way and not assume she skimmed.Especially with the hit being on Bkw that night.
I retract my vote for Fish and vote to lynch Driver his actions look more suspicious to me.[/QUOTE]
Well in fairness you have identified the points that I made. If its your subjective opinion that my voting patterns (unknown D1 (you by the way), Mafia D2, Mafia D3, Mafia D4 (who cares - Ogre)) are suspicious then I think you are at best reading them badly.
