Mafia 34-Time Crisis(the Play)

[IceH2O]

I didn't say I thought anybody was innocent, Ice. I said you guys were just being normal.

OKay I'll accept that I guess.

I just know I've read my name coupled with innocent and get really worried when players start pulling that crap out of a Day 1.

I still need to see who said that.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

But HN you are voting WITH NJ now. I also think NJ looks scummy which is why I won't vote BH. Sure nothing they have said has been helpful, in fact quite the opposite, but her vote alone is enough to make me dodge that train.

HN where did I press Chill? I saw his mistake and thought it a slip. I didn't ask anyone to vote Chill. I explained why I thought it was a slip and he commented on how it couldn't be.I then explained how it could be. The only reason it was dragged out as long as it did was because he had no reasoning to why he chose 17. A good excuse probably would have lifted my vote off him.

Chill made what I thought was a slip and had no explanation for it.ANYONE that says they didn't see that there was a really good chance he was mafia is mafia themselves IMO.

Players have been lynched on Day 1 for much less then his misconstrued slip.

I get it, but you'd have heightened awareness of anyone that caught a "slip" from a lynch innocent right? Why shouldn't I?

 

[nickel652]

ok well i have to go (drs appointment for the baby) so i wont be back until later this evening....and i am still at a loss....i will go with Badhaggis...havent heard much...and when i went back and read through what was there was kinda strange....and i dont get the "evil" feeling from NJ...maybe different posting style but nothing that pops out and says shes evil....prolly doesnt make sence...but thats ok....so yeah

I vote to lynch BadHaggis

 

[Madcrawdad]

He was, but I was by no means convinced enough to vote him and after the fuss I'd made there was no way I was coming off of Lady.

No, I said that Ice & DD would look suspicious. They were the first to really press Chill.

Not opportunistic, I was being a bit defensive though. You don't find it curious that they didn't suspect anyone on Chill was a terrorist? Do YOU think that ALL the terrorists were on other players?

Actually I just re-read the whole Chill episode, and the first ones on were Ice, me, and then you. DD never really hopped on (any more than JL or Ogre, among others who also commented on Chill's goof.)


With regard to others not finding players on Chill suspicious, historically the games have gone badly for the town on Day 1, and players are rarely held accountable on Day 2 for their Day 1 votes. When things start clicking into place for the town (hopefully by Day 3 or 4) some Day 1 votes may be more telling.

As far as ALL the terrorists being on other players, I can't say. With all of the single votes out there, there may have been safer places to hide, though.

 

[nickel652]

My vote on Cap and suspicion of Nickels isn't about them living together. Its about how they come out and say I'm just looking to lynch someone and how I rub them the wrong way but then they vote exactly the same as me and for the same exact reason. Also bothers me that they seem to share the same thoughts like they are talking among themselves.




I'm okay with being suspected of being a terrorist. Its the fact that you say I rubbed you the wrong way then vote the same as I did for the same exact reason.


Since ties mean no death in this game I retract my lone vote on Cap and vote to lynch NJ.

She has to many posts that have slid by the way side. As Z pointed out posts like hers would get one of us lynched.

im not attacking you or bad mouthing you by this...just wanted to state my piece about what was said....(in bold)

you know and i know that i can tell you all day that we dont talk about the game but you wouldnt believe me...so why try...but i will say if i were going to talk to him about things then wouldnt i try to make what i say different then his????? why would i want to make it look like we talk? that just would be dumb...

so basically i cant change what you think and you will think it regardless of what i say...

 

[Lady G]

I "looked scummy" too when told you all you shouldn't vote me - and oops, the entire town killed the doctor. I "look scummy" - that doesn't mean I am. Plenty of people have "seemed scummy" or "that's what someone does when they're being scummy" etc. People are pretty much pointing at whoever walks by. I don't feel the need to defend myself against peoples "feelings" at this point.

But I am not at all surprised that I'm being lynched - I was shocked coming into this game that I wasn't put up for vote night one. I stick out, even before I post. But I don't suppose the fact that I didn't use an Alias, when it might have helped me avoid barbs like HN's about my past game, and made me less conspicuous count for not being "scummy".


All of the stuff brought up until are total point of view (the whole post-posting thing) and the fact that unlike the rest of most of you, I didn't vote to take out someone when I didn't agree with it. (I guess in the next case I'll just go along with the MOB. Oh wait... I suppose it's too late for that.)

Again - I'd rather still do the right thing. In the end, that's what counts, and I'll stand by my game. (With the exception of letting Lady G get to me about that stupid question that neither of us still understand, and has no bearing on anything, and offending someone.)

Well, I have to say, had you posted under a Alias unless you posted completely different, I still would of thought you to be terrorist. I've never played with you before, so who you are had nothing to do with my thoughts on you and your posts.

No...the fact you didn't post under a alias does nothing to give you credit IMO, as I said...I've never played with you before, and many ppl playing have never played with you before...so how can you say you "stick out". I don't even think the ones you played with before (until recent posts) had really said much one way or another about you. Yes, ppl mentioned you as they do all players in the game...but none really came after you that I recall.

Yes, it is all points of view....kinda the only way you can play this game isn't it? You post your thoughts (point of view)?

As far as you didn't vote for Chill, that in itself really means nothing either...I'm sure there wasn't to many terrorist actually on his vote. They do not normally all vote the same person, so that means their votes were on someone else.

What I posted about had plenty of bearing, you may not think it did because you had to back peddle so much but it did:grinyes:

I am sorry though if I offended you, that wasn't my intentions....it's a game, and wasn't meant in anyway to be about you in RL.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I have been catching up since last night and I am seeing a few different things. I don't like what BH has been posting. Several of his comments (as others have pointed out) make me feel he is evil...especially his vote for DD out of the blue. Of the 2 up for lynch right now my gut feeling says I should be voting for BH over NJ. Although she is quite suspicious, just for the fact that she is defending herself on a topic that she has no clue what the argument is. I am suspecting LG for the same reasons although it is a little less than NJ.

Since the rest of the town doesn't seem to agree with me right now on HN, I feel my vote will be better cast on one of the 2 current candidates I feel to be more suspicious. Then I read the post below and realized HN had the same gut feelings that I did after getting caught up. He dropped a little on my suspect list at this point.

I'll go ahead and take care of that. I retract my vote to lynch Dawg and vote to lynch BadHaggis. Although the post below makes it hard not to vote for NJ.

Here's my list in order

BadHaggis
NeonJulie
Lady G
Hooked Newbie

I retract my vote for Hooked Newbie and I vote to lynch BadHaggis

 

[IceH2O]

deja vu...remember all when ogre (i think) got grilled because he posted numbers of evils but he was innocent?

I think this is something that will turn out in a wrong lynching...it always does. Unless chill trips up again I dont see a good reason to warrant a vote on him

So basically you are going on a hunch that chill accidentally slipped by revealing the number of his teammates because he misread a post and stated that there were less players than there are?

He said that he made a mistake and said 17 instead of the 20 that was in Rb's post....I call that misreading...

No I don't have anything better but it's only been like 24 hours and we have another full day, which is why I am not liking this "chill is a terrorist" thing based on your assumption.

This probably doesn't mean much to you but I am not defending chill just not agreeing with Ice's hunches...I agree with your thoughts on how day one works but IMO Ice's is a stretch. As I said earlier unless chill trips up later I am treating this as a mistake. Right now I am more interested in how DD will answer my and orge's questions

Jpap spent a lot of time protecting Chill on Day 1.

chill - Chill and the numbers thing doesn't scream out to me, but hey, numbers make my head go fuzzy.

Looks like FireDancer was too

My list right now:

Chill - he's on everyone's lists over the numbers thing. I can understand why, but people make mistypes all the time, etc. So I'm going to keep eyes...

As was NJ

Chill-Love the RP btw, his now famous 17 post has to make you go hmmm... but I know last game I flip flopped quite abit on him, so right now I really do not know.

LG says she isn't sure. But what got me thinking ,and I wish I saved the quote, LG says HN had her backed into a corner and couldn't come off HN if she wanted too.Could this be a built in excuse for not voting Chill?

HN was on Chill and thought him suspicious then went back to LG. Then after Chill shows innocent he is all over those who were man enough to live with their vote?

Updated list

NJ
Jpap
Fire
LG
HN

 

[IceH2O]

Sorry my statement on Firedancer ended up inside her quote.

 

[Lady G]

Jpap spent a lot of time protecting Chill on Day 1.
As was NJ

LG says she isn't sure. But what got me thinking ,and I wish I saved the quote, LG says HN had her backed into a corner and couldn't come off HN if she wanted too.Could this be a built in excuse for not voting Chill?

HN was on Chill and thought him suspicious then went back to LG. Then after Chill shows innocent he is all over those who were man enough to live with their vote?

Updated list

NJ
Jpap
Fire
LG
HN

No, Ice it wasn't a "built in" excuse....do you disagree that he did? I do not think I would of voted Chill though, because the whole "Ogre" thing stood out in my head to much and I just wasn't sure, even though YES his post did make me wonder, if I hadn't been on Hooked, I most likely would of voted NJ really...there were several times I was going to come off HN, but I knew if I had he would of jumped all over that, and I'm sure others would of followed him. That is why I stuck with Hooked, I felt I couldn't take my vote off him nothing "built in".