Mafia 34-Time Crisis(the Play)

Status
Not open for further replies.
ok, I tried reading quickly to get my vote in and I have read some during breaks at work today. I will point on things that caught my attention....

Lady G said:
Just to remind you.....here is your post and now the 3rd time I've asked what post you were talking about we "crossed posts" on....you've danced around the answer twice now, can you answer this time, they do say the 3rd times a charm.
Click to expand...
this is kinda at the beginning of the whole G/NJ saga, kinda reminded me of DD/G sagas of Mafia games past :D There was also a post earlier in this game that NJ goes on to talk about all her past games and how she is this way when she plays or that way... what I was thinking during that post was... wasn't it just 1 game NJ that you were in, 2 max?

NeonJulie said:
This is too crazy even for me, so I'll present a few things which lead me to my vote:

I vote to lynch BadHaggis.

With any luck tomorrow, I'll barely be around, like some other people manage to be doing just fine (RB, etc.)
Click to expand...
with the battle of the ladies today, I would have totally thought your vote would have been on G today and makes me wonder why it isn't.... even if an OMGUS vote... it seems it was the most heated from you and I would think the things you were going back at G with, that they were more reason than any other to place your vote to her... yet you vote Haggis. :confused:

Madcrawdad said:
A couple of things I noticed yesterday, said by Hooked Newbie, that seemed a little inconsistent...

Here HN tosses out the idea of trying to figure out who the aliases are. Says that it doesn't really matter, sounds like maybe just a fun way to pass the time early on.

Ice questions why it matters who the aliases are.

HN replies that it doesn't matter, but goes onto explain that the fact that players chose an alias does. Kind of sounds like he's taking the stance that aliases do actually matter. This seems a little inconsistent with his original statement that it really didn't matter. Not a major inconsistency, but of interest, as it looks like he's changing positions slightly, when confronted.

-----------------------------------------------------------
The next inconsitency is with regard to Chill.


Here HN throws out a list of suspects that includes Chill.


HN actually goes on to vote for Chill... he later retracts and goes back to vote LG.

After returning to vote for LG, he still points out that he finds Chill scummy.

Here, later in the day, he's naming possible suspects. The biggest point of interest is that he says 'CatHaggis looks suspicious as will Ice and DD if Chill is innocent.'

What's this? HN voted for Chill at one point, and even after returning to LG says that he would still support a Chill lynch. Now if Chill ends up innocent he'd be suspicious of Ice and DD. Why?

These inconsistencies, coupled with his very extreme position on the suicide pact he was pushing with LG has me watching HN EXTREMELY closely.
Click to expand...
Why would I look "any" way if Chill was innocent?

[AC] BadHaggis;1471808 said:
when i started writing the post it had not been difinitively stated by bkw. I forgot to go back and remove the impression part.

yep as soon as I read the interaction with chill, I made my decision, and stuck with it. it happened that i missed the begining.

I do not have rickets!!!!! unlike some i don't post bios for each player. i only post my thoughts on who i thinks guilty.
do i detect pent up hostility? :devil: i post my feelings. i was just stating that Z's posting style seemed to me to have more subtle clus. nothing to indicate good or evil, yet.

i think itd be a good way to throw us off the sent, if i were the mod. it would be very risky, and i doubt it, but i wantd to put it out there for others to think about.

thankya thankya verre much.

lol, its funny how we each read evil. ive peen sharing my ideas even the dumb ones. with the events of the last day, i am putting my vote on dd. mostly ice got me thinking, with his post about dd and you.

i vote to lynch dangerdoll. right now i think her likely to be a terrorist.
Click to expand...
why have you quoted on everything jpappy, yet you place a vote on me with little to no reason?

Hooked Newbie said:
He was, but I was by no means convinced enough to vote him and after the fuss I'd made there was no way I was coming off of Lady.

No, I said that Ice & DD would look suspicious. They were the first to really press Chill.

Not opportunistic, I was being a bit defensive though. You don't find it curious that they didn't suspect anyone on Chill was a terrorist? Do YOU think that ALL the terrorists were on other players?
Click to expand...
Um... I didn't press on Chill at all.... why does everyone keep saying that? All I did was note on Ice's remarks on the numbers chill messed up... not sure why this makes me so "terrorist-ish"

but at any rate, G made a whole lot of sense while NJ didn't seem to be closing in on her gaps. It has brought me to the decision to vote NJ today in fact. So, I vote to lynch NeonJulie
 
I meant to keep Cap and Nickels on that list too



NJ
Jpap
Fire
LG
HN
Cap
Nickels
 
BH(6)-John(575) jpap(614) NJ(642) FireD(658) HN(711) Nickels(723) dawg(727)
NJ(7)-Z(589) LG(643) Mad(650) Cap(661) Rick(690) ice(717) DD(731)

HN(1)-ogre(600) dawg(630)
DD(1)-Haggis (653)
RB(1)-jmax(678)

cap(0)-Ice(665)
Dawg(0)-hn(627)

Lil more then a hour til night. PMs needed


never try to make a vote count and talk on the phone.....u mess up alot :)
 
Last edited:
Lady G said:
No, Ice it wasn't a "built in" excuse....do you disagree that he did? I do not think I would of voted Chill though, because the whole "Ogre" thing stood out in my head to much and I just wasn't sure, even though YES his post did make me wonder, if I hadn't been on Hooked, I most likely would of voted NJ really...there were several times I was going to come off HN, but I knew if I had he would of jumped all over that, and I'm sure others would of followed him. That is why I stuck with Hooked, I felt I couldn't take my vote off him nothing "built in".
Click to expand...

Yes I disagree. He moved off you without consequence then went back to you. You could have moved at anytime.
 
bkw1982 said:
BH(6)-John(575) jpap(614) Haggis(642) FireD(658) HN(711) Nickels(723) dawg(727)
NJ(7)-Z(589) LG(643) Mad(650) Cap(661) Rick(690) ice(717) DD(731)

HN(1)-ogre(600) dawg(630)
DD(1)-Haggis (653)
RB(1)-jmax(678)

cap(0)-Ice(665)
Dawg(0)-hn(627)

Lil more then a hour til night. PMs needed
Click to expand...

RB, you going to vote?


I see after I put NJ ahead 6-5 Nickels and Dawg came in and put BH ahead 7-6 then DD came in and tied it up 7-7.
 
Sorry, haven't finished skimming, been busy with Pms to various members....
 
Madcrawdad said:
BKW has since edited the post count, and it looks like NJ is in the lead by a nose... (7-6)
Click to expand...


Darn Mods....keep your tallies straight lol

Ok so then its I made it 6-4 then Nickels and Dawg tied it at 6 and DD put it to 7-6.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom