Completely agree that his initial idea was flawed, I just don't see it as a sign of ill intent.
Mafia 40 "Life behind bars" The Play
- Thread starter Hooked Newbie
- Start date
You realize too, despite what everyone says, it's still true that if you talk more, you get lynched, even if it's just conjecture and trying to sound out ideas. And people who talk less, don't. So that's my cue.
Welcome to the club lol.
As for the other things you bolded.
If we do it by lineup and only find 1 when we could just invest who we think and find more is a better option.
As for the snitches not getting invests I'd need clarification from HN on that one. Usually the terminology covers the population and snitches are also part of the population. It only says the Underground doesn't get invests, it doesn't say the snitches don't.
But either way going down the list doesn't work as well as randomized invests would.
If HN says snitched don't get invests I might retract. If you are a snitch it might not out the PRs but you could have looked at the list seen this protected some of you and why you decided to run with it.
NJ every other game you say you don't want to chance lynching an innocent person on day 1, so why shank G right out of the gate. This is very inconsistent with your normal play. The more I think about this the more inclined I am to vote for you.
Snitches: You were planted by the corrupt Warden to keep an eye out and to inform him each night of who should be beaten to death by the Guards. Before night, the snitches must email or PM me their top 2 choices for a beating. I will randomly choose which is selected. You have the power to investigate once per night to find someone’s true identity. Before night, the snitches must email or PM me their top 2 choices for investigation. Members of the Underground will appear innocent on night 1.
If the plan is flawed and endangers power roles why is arguing against it bad? I'm not arguing against cooperation I have consistently said we should all use our investigations on day 2 to get maximum benefit, and we should out any snitches. I'm saying we should be careful that we don't hurt the town by tipping our hand too soon or leaving our PR's out to dry. That you find a problem with that makes me wonder about you.
Yeah that's true - but I already explained that I assumed Sunday night would be lynch, and I still had ONE vote change I could use if I had to, whereas if I didn't vote at all, and I missed the vote, I might UD, if I couldn't get back before Sunday night. Pretty self explanatory if you ask me. If you check out my Avatar/title, you'll see I have a real bad history of waiting too long to vote :/. Didn't want that to happen this game, because if I can't put a vote out at least once per day, even on the weekends, I shouldn't really be playing. Better for me to look into something, and put the vote out, and come back and change it if need be.
But I'm happy with my vote, actually, which is why I didn't recant it or change it, even once I learned that two days from Friday was NOT Sunday night, in fact, but Monday night.
But I'm happy with my vote, actually, which is why I didn't recant it or change it, even once I learned that two days from Friday was NOT Sunday night, in fact, but Monday night.
Everytime i try to get away....They keep pulling me back in!!
The reason for the lineup, as stated, would so we could find increase chances. If everyone picks there own then the more popular players will prob get doubles on them. It doesnt have to be the line up, if its dice or whatever.
The reason i picked the list was
A. because it's established by someone not in the game
b. it removes bias to pick popular players, and spreads the votes out.
c. Keeps snitches from saying they investigated this person.
There isnt any other real way to do it random and trust everyone.
i took it as "true" innocents. HN can we get a ruling
The other part of the list would be this. The snitches prob woulda hit the person that woulda revealed them.
To spell it out: The mafia would've(past tense) tried to silence the person below them, as not to be found out. So more then likly night 2 beatdown woulda prob been someone who woulda found them out. That's just more info that coulda been used.
Once again im not pushing the idea im explaining it.:crazy:
