nice try, but I have no idea; but with 19 players, 6 out on the first nite, all innocents; that leaves a lot of bad blood out there........I can't believe I actually made a spreadsheet for this! My husband is right - I am obsessed! LMAO :screwy:
Mafia 40 "Life behind bars" The Play
- Thread starter Hooked Newbie
- Start date
nice try, but I have no idea; but with 19 players, 6 out on the first nite, all innocents; that leaves a lot of bad blood out there........I can't believe I actually made a spreadsheet for this! My husband is right - I am obsessed! LMAO :screwy:
Ok, like I said I'm not sure I really read anything into it...but thank you for the answer.
The more I am thinking about things the more I really feel NJ is snitch. Sorry, can't "show" evidence at the moment, that will come as I look back more...but I think her post about Dawg and myself...well it still doesn't sit easy with me, especially now that it is known Dawg was innocent. I can't help but feel, she made her vote to me thinking "it's G..others will follow" and at the same time she had "doubt" lain toward Dawg, another ppl like to go after.
I know I said earlier that the end made RB possibley move down the list on me, but now that I have had time to obsorbe the nightfall more, I'm not sure....I am wondering if his posts talking about the tie and how we would learn nothing from it was to try and get Noodles to move her vote, in the end makeing her look to be the nail in the coffin of a known innocent..as a newb maybe he thought he could "toy" with her. GAH, I JUST DON"T KNOW!!!!!
For reference here is the final vote tally
Day 1
LG-1- NJ
RB-1- Jb
NJ-3-LG TH RB Noodles
Scoop-1- Z
Bkw-1-Ice,Dawg
Dawg-5-jm12, DD,Bkw,Ice RB
Ogre-1- Jpap
Chill-1- Doom
Doom-1- Chill
no votes: pixl8r, [AC] Scoop411, OgreMkV, Judgemax
Lots of single votes out there.
Day 1
LG-1- NJ
RB-1- Jb
NJ-3-LG TH RB Noodles
Scoop-1- Z
Bkw-1-Ice,Dawg
Dawg-5-jm12, DD,Bkw,Ice RB
Ogre-1- Jpap
Chill-1- Doom
Doom-1- Chill
no votes: pixl8r, [AC] Scoop411, OgreMkV, Judgemax
Lots of single votes out there.
This is crazy! My husband is in the other room watchin crappy tv, whining- "you dont love me" .....while I spend my time here. ARG!!!! :crazy:
I love it - LOL
**** button..
We can exclude the Chill for Doom vote and the Dawg for Bkw votes.
Jpap voted for a UD
Z voted for the medic
NJ voted for Lg
Jb voted for Rb
Doom voted for Chill
We can exclude the Chill for Doom vote and the Dawg for Bkw votes.
Jpap voted for a UD
Z voted for the medic
NJ voted for Lg
Jb voted for Rb
Doom voted for Chill
Horrible, horrible night....:shakehead:
There were some interesting votes placed before night. I believe Rb to Dawg and noodles to NJ...Rb is a screwy player so its hard to say whether his vote was just him being Rb or a snitchy vote. I'm leaning towards the former. As for noodles the tough part is that she is new so the first vote is going to be iffy.
I'm still very interested in Jbradt and Z. From the looks of it Jb is still in the game. As for Z I still am not too sure about the way he presented his view of Bkw. Though the early comment today on Jmax also makes me think he is more innocent because a snitch would know her role and not post the opposite accidentally. Unless it was planned, but I doubt it. He's still on my short list.
Another person I am going to look at more is NJ. I have no specific reasons at the moment just a gut feeling.
There were some interesting votes placed before night. I believe Rb to Dawg and noodles to NJ...Rb is a screwy player so its hard to say whether his vote was just him being Rb or a snitchy vote. I'm leaning towards the former. As for noodles the tough part is that she is new so the first vote is going to be iffy.
I'm still very interested in Jbradt and Z. From the looks of it Jb is still in the game. As for Z I still am not too sure about the way he presented his view of Bkw. Though the early comment today on Jmax also makes me think he is more innocent because a snitch would know her role and not post the opposite accidentally. Unless it was planned, but I doubt it. He's still on my short list.
Another person I am going to look at more is NJ. I have no specific reasons at the moment just a gut feeling.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
OMG!!! tonight was a mafia nightmare and yes, one to write in the books.... man.. with Dawg out, and chill out as both innocents, I am pretty thrown back... I thought for sure their tussles in the beginning were slip ups. That leaves NJ on my list... NJ, have you seen my last post? Just because in was just before or during night, doesn't mean you still can't follow my posts.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
I have to agree, I still do like jbradt *(actually I think Chill wasn't on my list but jbradt was) as a bit guilty and his last post stating he would sit out because he iffended rb, I think was a clever ploy... and screams being coached.
A little time to read through your wall of text would be nice, DD. I'm sure you put a lot of thought into it, but yes, you vanquished. Please, rather than me have to go through that work line by line - please just vote me out. I'd rather commit suicide than attempt to read it again, and answer half of it. How many games total? I don't know, count them, I said Doctor in 3, MAfia in 4, Innocent turned Mafia in 33, Swat Team innocent in 34, Innocent in I forgot what the number was, one before last I think. How many is that? Not that many, remember, I took a whole year off and have only been back since June, so not a whole lot.
My play style has changed a bit - already explained. I'm tired of missing the vote because I'm on Pacific Time and it's wrapping up when I'm in traffic. I have to get the vote in early, and change later (if I feel it's necessary), than wait until it's too late an UD.
But really, I suggest all of you today either shank me, or investigate me. I'm not repeating myself one more time. I'm not going to say why I chose Lady G over Dawg (who again, innocent as I said, too dumb a mistake to be touched by someone guilty), I'm not going to repeat how many games I've been in (read for yourself), I'm not going to explain the time zone or my need to vote early, or misunderstanding that 48 hours from Friday night was not Sunday night and voting even earlier, or anything else.
I'll make this easy for you, RB, Mad/Tree, Lady G, Chill, Z, and Noodles - all of you shank me tonight. REally - I don't even care. WHen you add one more innocent to the death pool, the rest of you can go back and rexamine these parties. Good night.
My play style has changed a bit - already explained. I'm tired of missing the vote because I'm on Pacific Time and it's wrapping up when I'm in traffic. I have to get the vote in early, and change later (if I feel it's necessary), than wait until it's too late an UD.
But really, I suggest all of you today either shank me, or investigate me. I'm not repeating myself one more time. I'm not going to say why I chose Lady G over Dawg (who again, innocent as I said, too dumb a mistake to be touched by someone guilty), I'm not going to repeat how many games I've been in (read for yourself), I'm not going to explain the time zone or my need to vote early, or misunderstanding that 48 hours from Friday night was not Sunday night and voting even earlier, or anything else.
I'll make this easy for you, RB, Mad/Tree, Lady G, Chill, Z, and Noodles - all of you shank me tonight. REally - I don't even care. WHen you add one more innocent to the death pool, the rest of you can go back and rexamine these parties. Good night.
