I didn't get the hint until he claimed to be the Doc and said he left us a hint.
The rules don't say he can't protect himself. At least I didn't see it.
Mafia #41 The Play -- 50/50
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
I didn't get the hint until he claimed to be the Doc and said he left us a hint.
The rules don't say he can't protect himself. At least I didn't see it.
No, it doesn't I went back and looked too. We have played so many games where they couldn't protect themselves. I did NOT catch that at all.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
wow... what a turn of events... sorry, I missed nightfall and what a show. I never in a million years would have believed Ice was an innocent and the doctor to boot. Yes, his hit about not lynching him but letting him be hit was spot on but hind sight is 20/20. I don't know if I was here at nightfall if I would have believed him.
Great job, CI's! We are finally getting somewhere!!
Yep, as everyone who was in a heated debate before their spatter was outted, I was totally set up. I will give a list... because if I am taken out next round, I need you all to see what I see....
LG - not sure. When innocent, her head is easily spun by mafia. It really seems to be spinning this round. I can't tell at this point for sure, but the fact that she said that she thought plantling was mafia (don't remember the post number) makes me really think she's playing the game, as I can't see ANYONE thinking plantling was mafia. She also voted Ice, but I feel Ice pushed it.
Judge - not very helpful. I go back and forth on her, usually settling on scum.
Dawg - The fact that he voted for Driver over noodles made me think he was scum, but the fact that he and Ice have been going back and forth make me wonder.
Malbri - voted for noodles 2x (first both times) and never came off when the votes builded on noodles... I would tend to lean her innocent but something nudges me wrong on it... could she have been turned.
C-note - who knows? Not posting enough. Got a tight tongue but the longer the game goes on, the more suspicious I am...
Chill, one person who I've got no real feel on... I thought he was more active in these games but I have also been in a game with him being quiet and innocent. Of course, still a suspect.. like everyone else.
Who out of this would I be willing to vote, I would say Dawg because of how Ice gunned for him.... if not him, G is a good second place.
Great job, CI's! We are finally getting somewhere!!
Yep, as everyone who was in a heated debate before their spatter was outted, I was totally set up. I will give a list... because if I am taken out next round, I need you all to see what I see....
LG - not sure. When innocent, her head is easily spun by mafia. It really seems to be spinning this round. I can't tell at this point for sure, but the fact that she said that she thought plantling was mafia (don't remember the post number) makes me really think she's playing the game, as I can't see ANYONE thinking plantling was mafia. She also voted Ice, but I feel Ice pushed it.
Judge - not very helpful. I go back and forth on her, usually settling on scum.
Dawg - The fact that he voted for Driver over noodles made me think he was scum, but the fact that he and Ice have been going back and forth make me wonder.
Malbri - voted for noodles 2x (first both times) and never came off when the votes builded on noodles... I would tend to lean her innocent but something nudges me wrong on it... could she have been turned.
C-note - who knows? Not posting enough. Got a tight tongue but the longer the game goes on, the more suspicious I am...
Chill, one person who I've got no real feel on... I thought he was more active in these games but I have also been in a game with him being quiet and innocent. Of course, still a suspect.. like everyone else.
Who out of this would I be willing to vote, I would say Dawg because of how Ice gunned for him.... if not him, G is a good second place.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
well G... I guess here goes the infamous G vs. DD debate.... I absolutely was not defending Judge, you voted for her and gave absolutley NO reason for doing so, which can be a scumtell... I was merely asking for reasons, not saying that I thought you were right or wrong. What was the reason, anyway?
You didn't "defend" her...but you accuse me of "distancing" ohh, and I guess I was from Ice also according to you?
Ummmm...actually DD maybe you should go back and reread. It looks to me like Ice was gunning for you...
Well for DD skimming over day 3 (when she and Ice were going at it) and pointing the finger at me being Ice's target makes me more confident in the fact that DD is scum. I was going to flip a coin on DD and Mal but after this slip up by DD I vote to lynch DD.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
nice try Dawg,,,, but it was you who he was gunning for at a point. Ice coerced me into voting him and that was clear. I was not skimming at all, dawg.... and though this looks OMGUS, I vote to lynch Dawg... plain and simple... and though through the game, Ice had you in suspicion, he put me there because he pushed me to and I explained that when I got back after night... so who did you vote. What made you vote for Driver the other day instead of noodles, dawg?
