Mafia 42: Assassin in the Palace (The Play)

[OgreMkV]

The case for Ice being the assassin...

I have no other way to do this but to try and get into Mads head. I'm voting each day for the person I think Mad would make the assassin.

I vote to lynch JB.

I'd rather not retract as I think it gives the assassin to much cover but will if needed on a person that seems to be screaming assassin.

6:30A this morning... he posts that he would rather not change unless a person screams assassin.

In a setup like this I myself wouldn't trust a random draw of players.I doubt Mad did either.

I don't see how JBs post shows Mal isn't King either. I think you are trying to out the King here Zsand. We could put 3 votes on the King easily. The 4th vote could be the assassin but there would still be a guard to vote the other player. Like Dawg said its all about tricking the assassin.

I retract my vote on JB and vote to lynch Zsand

Yes JB I am guessing, I did pretty much say that.Glad you're so observant.

I think we should keep the voting to 2 people per day. We need to mix it up and have the King,if we haven't already :evil_lol: in the loop of voting as to not give them away. With keeping to 2 players we never give out to much info and still have a chance at getting the assassin, never put more then 3 votes on 1 of the people. We could vote out 1 person then the next day use the person that was saved the previous day plus another player.

Like yesterday it was BKW and Mal....today Mal and Z...tomorrow Mal and Noodles then Mal/Noodles and JB etc....use whover in place of Noodles and JB just used them as an example,it could be whoever we decide at the time but you get the drift I hope.

his very next post at 4ish is a vote change...

Lets not find out....

I retract my vote on Zsand and vote to lynch Mal.

That should make it 4-2-1. She can't save herself.

More to follow in next post, want my vote in before Mals

his NEXT post is a vote change.

If nobody moves the majority rule says Mal dies.

I agreed with Zs comment but wanted to see who would speak against it so I spoke against it. Notice I never said anything about LG agreeing with Z.

I think we should all look at voting for Noodles,Ogre and/or JB next.

I still think JB is a good choice for Mads assassin if not Mal.

Ogres miscount of votes when it was only 2 posts above his I could see as blending in and taking down a somewhat known guard or a chance that she is actually the King and we let to many votes pile up on her making his job easier.

Noodles because of her flip flopping around looks like she is trying to blend in also.I agree with Dawg that if you don't feel right about someone you shouldn't vote with that someone.

Now it really looks like he's fishing. More on this in a minute.

Well I'm pretty sure my next vote is Ogre if Mal isn't the assassin.

Anyone that moves to anyone other then Mal or off Mal at this point is suspect.

More fishing and a classic Ice ultimatum.

Actually the logic I couldn't follow is why you think anyone who doesn't vote the way you voted is suspect.

He's always that way.

The only reason to not vote Mal is if you think she is King. If you think she is King then you are the assassin and will get voted out next.

Your hypo doesn't work in this case as the only non voter is in the lead. She isn't going to vote for herself. So for anyone to be lynched a number of people need to switch.

This is basically a threat to get people to vote the way he wants... i.e. to eliminate people that have previously been IDed as possibles by other players.

I retract my vote to lynch Ogre and I vote to lynch Ice

I'm with you. I retract my vote on Mal and vote to lynch IceH2O.


The more on this thing... it really looks like Ice is fishing to see who responds to his various threats. He's basically accused half of us at this point. I think he's hoping to get a reaction and can use that to hit the king.

I also HIGHLY suspect that Ice would be a great choice for assassin, knowing Mad as I do.

 

[OgreMkV]

The votes were posted 2 posts above yours an hour before you posted, shouldn't have been that hard lol.

But don't worry I think Dawg is more likely to get the next vote. He isn't making any sense with his vote for me when its obvious Mal is either guard or assassin.

Really, you've got a 7 in 8 chance of being right on that one. Good call.

 

[dirtydawg10]

In a setup like this I myself wouldn't trust a random draw of players.I doubt Mad did either.



I don't see how JBs post shows Mal isn't King either. I think you are trying to out the King here Zsand. We could put 3 votes on the King easily. The 4th vote could be the assassin but there would still be a guard to vote the other player. Like Dawg said its all about tricking the assassin.

I retract my vote on JB and vote to lynch Zsand


Yes JB I am guessing, I did pretty much say that.Glad you're so observant.



I think we should keep the voting to 2 people per day. We need to mix it up and have the King,if we haven't already :evil_lol: in the loop of voting as to not give them away. With keeping to 2 players we never give out to much info and still have a chance at getting the assassin, never put more then 3 votes on 1 of the people. We could vote out 1 person then the next day use the person that was saved the previous day plus another player.

Like yesterday it was BKW and Mal....today Mal and Z...tomorrow Mal and Noodles then Mal/Noodles and JB etc....use whover in place of Noodles and JB just used them as an example,it could be whoever we decide at the time but you get the drift I hope.

Again your logic is flawed. How do you put a max of 3 votes on one person and vote for only 2 people at a time when there are 8 playing? There are 4 votes on Mal and you were the 4th. You already broke your own rules. Now you are calling for a 5th. You are either the assassin or you are dumb. And for the record "I don't think you're dumb". That's my logic. If you don't like it you should all vote me the hell out of this game.

The votes were posted 2 posts above yours an hour before you posted, shouldn't have been that hard lol.

But don't worry I think Dawg is more likely to get the next vote. He isn't making any sense with his vote for me when its obvious Mal is either guard or assassin.

:lipssealedsmilie:

 

[IceH2O]

You guys are hilarious....

Do me a favor and get 2 more to vote me then I'll vote myself and get out of this hellhole we call mafia.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Vote count thru post #182

Mal(3) - Z(121), LG(128), Ice(156)
Z(2) - JB(113), Noodles(151)
Ice(2) - Dawg(176), Ogre(181)

No vote from: Mal

With 8 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch...

 

[jbradt]

Ok, so... five more minutes, then it's back to counseling addicts. For now though, who to kill. I didn't like switching my vote from Z to Mal, not much evidence to vote for mal other than low posting, and that just doesn't do it for me. Ogre makes a decent case (imo) against Ice... but I've been looking at Ogre since the beginning. Hmmm... the stalemate has to end though. I (reluctantly) retract my vote for Zsandmann, and vote to lynch Ice. Noodles, any chance of switching to either Mal or Ice?

Now I have to get back to work... can't wait to see what happens with this by the time I get back home. Maybe it'll be quiet and I can check back sooner!

 

[IceH2O]

Again your logic is flawed. How do you put a max of 3 votes on one person and vote for only 2 people at a time when there are 8 playing? There are 4 votes on Mal and you were the 4th. You already broke your own rules. Now you are calling for a 5th. You are either the assassin or you are dumb. And for the record "I don't think you're dumb". That's my logic. If you don't like it you should all vote me the hell out of this game.



:lipssealedsmilie:

How is that hard to understand? If 3 are on 1 then the other gets 5. Did you fail remedial math?

Not that it matters, if not by the time I go to bed I'm hoping by the time I wake up to have Mal and another player switch to me so I can vote myself and let you guys play the game I didn't really want to play anyway.

 

[noodles62]

It would take more than me switching to make it count. My first instinct was Mal and the case against Ice is pretty convincing...........:wall:
I just want this to move on!

 

[dirtydawg10]

How is that hard to understand? If 3 are on 1 then the other gets 5. Did you fail remedial math?

Not that it matters, if not by the time I go to bed I'm hoping by the time I wake up to have Mal and another player switch to me so I can vote myself and let you guys play the game I didn't really want to play anyway.

Actually maybe you did. You said "never put more then 3 votes on 1 of the people".

5>3

 

[IceH2O]

Good just need Mal now.

I retract my vote on Mal and vote to lynch Ice