Mafia 42: Assassin in the Palace (The Play)

Madcrawdad said:
Vote count thru post #67

Mal (2) - Z(49), Noodles(67)
BKW (1) - Dawg(50)
Dawg(1) - BKW(51)

No votes from: Ice, Jbradt, LG, Mal, Ogre

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch...
Click to expand...


That doesn't make sense. If 3 players have votes why would it take 5? A majority is a majority as long as all have voted. If we have 3 players with votes then 4 would be the majority. It would only take 5 if 2 people had votes or 5 of us decide to vote for 1 person. A better way to say it would be 5 votes causes a lynch or the majority rules once all votes are made or time is up.

I think knowing what I know and putting myself into Mads shoes I vote to lynch BKW. I would have made him the assassin also.
 
ice i think mad is just reminding us it's 5 votes.

Orge-Why would i post the list of don'ts? Wouldn't the assassin just ignore em then? The list is there to help me find ppl who are fishing. Which i believe is the best tactic of the assassin. Their best move would be to gain information. Giving information out via list is a "Don't" IMO

If everyone made a list of 3 ppl then the some of the list will overlap, using the over lapping players the assassin could create a list of not kings. Cause more then likly the person appearing the most is prob not the king. The person appearing the least or not at all is a possible king. So if everyone made a list of 3 ppl it's possible for the assassin to narrow their picks down.

Do you see why it's a bad idea to create a list? We give the assassin to much information.

I retract my vote for dawg and

I vote to lynch Mal

I rather a no show is lynched.

As Z pointed out now that the votes are so high on some one they need to go. So i suggest that no new ppl are voted for and everyone pick between me or Mal
 
Not targeting anyone specifically yet, because I havnt finished reading but I wanted to put it out there before I forgot- Discussing stategies on how to find the assassin may actually be the assassin trying to find out what he needs to avoid doing to avoid being found. Make sense? Probably not...
 
bkw1982 said:
ice i think mad is just reminding us it's 5 votes.

Orge-Why would i post the list of don'ts? Wouldn't the assassin just ignore em then? The list is there to help me find ppl who are fishing. Which i believe is the best tactic of the assassin. Their best move would be to gain information. Giving information out via list is a "Don't" IMO

If everyone made a list of 3 ppl then the some of the list will overlap, using the over lapping players the assassin could create a list of not kings. Cause more then likly the person appearing the most is prob not the king. The person appearing the least or not at all is a possible king. So if everyone made a list of 3 ppl it's possible for the assassin to narrow their picks down.

Do you see why it's a bad idea to create a list? We give the assassin to much information.

I retract my vote for dawg and

I vote to lynch Mal

I rather a no show is lynched.

As Z pointed out now that the votes are so high on some one they need to go. So i suggest that no new ppl are voted for and everyone pick between me or Mal
Click to expand...
I'm not a no-show, buttface:silly:
 
bkw1982 said:
Yes, you're right, because so many good ideas have come from ppl thinking of was of outing the assassin(sarcasim)

Either you skimmed my post or picked to skip over the part where i said...."

In a game where the only way to communicate is out in the open, there is no way to come up with a valid plan to trap anyone. Why you ask? cause as soon as you start the plan someone will think you're acting guilty, which has already been pointed out with the voting the king idea. If you did share it you just wasted it cause the assassin would read it.

So why bother coming up with an idea that won't be helpful, focus on other helpful things.

I vote to lynch Dirty Dawg

Due to him just picking only to bold part of my post and ignoring the part that completly shatters his reason for voting for me.

I also have my eye on noodles. The two votes on 4 ppl thing is a bad idea. if the last person to vote is a guard then they wont vote for the king, knowing that the assassin just gained some vaulable information (Im basing this on the voting period ends if someone not only gets 5 votes, but if they just get the majority at that the time. Example: 4-3-2 split between 3 ppl. Clarification please MAD). Tisk Tisk Egg Noodles, this may not be a good idea at all.

IMO the Assassin will be one of the last ppl to vote
Click to expand...

I clearly didn't skim because I posted your whole quote. How can anyone play a game where you need to take out the assassin and not try to come up with ways to out the assassin. :screwy:

You didn't say that you had ideas about taking out the assassin but felt it was better to keep it to yourself for now. You said you didn't bother trying to come up with ideas. Sorry that saving the King by outing the assassin is such a bother to you.

The OMGUS seals the deal for me. I know i am voting for the right person here. If not oh well, in your own words, you won't be outing the assassin anyway so we don't really need you.
 
bkw1982 said:
ice i think mad is just reminding us it's 5 votes.

Orge-Why would i post the list of don'ts? Wouldn't the assassin just ignore em then? The list is there to help me find ppl who are fishing. Which i believe is the best tactic of the assassin. Their best move would be to gain information. Giving information out via list is a "Don't" IMO

If everyone made a list of 3 ppl then the some of the list will overlap, using the over lapping players the assassin could create a list of not kings. Cause more then likly the person appearing the most is prob not the king. The person appearing the least or not at all is a possible king. So if everyone made a list of 3 ppl it's possible for the assassin to narrow their picks down.

Do you see why it's a bad idea to create a list? We give the assassin to much information.

I retract my vote for dawg and

I vote to lynch Mal

I rather a no show is lynched.

As Z pointed out now that the votes are so high on some one they need to go. So i suggest that no new ppl are voted for and everyone pick between me or Mal
Click to expand...

Wow!! Well it's no longer an OMGUS...it is a vote to break the tie already. I thought you might wait it out a little longer.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom