Mafia 42: Assassin in the Palace (The Play)

[dirtydawg10]

It takes 5 votes according to Mad for the lynch. To oust Z it would take Mal and 2 others to go to him to make 5. To oust Ogre 4 of us would need to move there. Or we can stay as is till Mad gets tired of waiting.

Actually the logic I couldn't follow is why you think anyone who doesn't vote the way you voted is suspect.

Anyone that moves to anyone other then Mal or off Mal at this point is suspect.

 

[IceH2O]

Actually the logic I couldn't follow is why you think anyone who doesn't vote the way you voted is suspect.

Its not the way I voted its the majority at the time.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Its not the way I voted its the majority at the time.

Still don't follow you. Here's a hypothetical...

There are 6 players. 3 votes are on player A, 1 vote is on player B and 1 vote is on player C. By your logic the person who hasn't voted yet has to vote for player A or they are suspect. What if player A is the king and one of the votes on player A is from the assassin. What do you think of your logic?

 

[IceH2O]

Still don't follow you. Here's a hypothetical...

There are 6 players. 3 votes are on player A, 1 vote is on player B and 1 vote is on player C. By your logic the person who hasn't voted yet has to vote for player A or they are suspect. What if player A is the king and one of the votes on player A is from the assassin. What do you think of your logic?

The only reason to not vote Mal is if you think she is King. If you think she is King then you are the assassin and will get voted out next.

Your hypo doesn't work in this case as the only non voter is in the lead. She isn't going to vote for herself. So for anyone to be lynched a number of people need to switch.

 

[OgreMkV]

Sorry, Ice, about the confusion. I disagree with Dawg. I think we should say as little as possible and just vote people out until we get the assassin. The only thing discussion can do is give the assassin hints.

Oh, and I am NOT keeping track of all the votes and I can't keep a page or so of votes in my head. SO if that's your reason to vote me, OK.

hmmm.... thinking. BRB

 

[dirtydawg10]

The only reason to not vote Mal is if you think she is King. If you think she is King then you are the assassin and will get voted out next.

Your hypo doesn't work in this case as the only non voter is in the lead. She isn't going to vote for herself. So for anyone to be lynched a number of people need to switch.

I retract my vote to lynch Ogre and I vote to lynch Ice

 

[jbradt]

Okay, I've got a break for 1/2 hour or so... any chance of getting a quick vote count mad?

 

[IceH2O]

Sorry, Ice, about the confusion. I disagree with Dawg. I think we should say as little as possible and just vote people out until we get the assassin. The only thing discussion can do is give the assassin hints.

Oh, and I am NOT keeping track of all the votes and I can't keep a page or so of votes in my head. SO if that's your reason to vote me, OK.

hmmm.... thinking. BRB

The votes were posted 2 posts above yours an hour before you posted, shouldn't have been that hard lol.

But don't worry I think Dawg is more likely to get the next vote. He isn't making any sense with his vote for me when its obvious Mal is either guard or assassin.

 

[IceH2O]

Okay, I've got a break for 1/2 hour or so... any chance of getting a quick vote count mad?

Mal 4
Z 2
Ice 1

no vote mal

5 needed to lynch

 

[jbradt]

Thanks Ice... I still believe in my vote for Z; something not right there. But the stalemate has to end at some point. If we wait as it is, Mal is out anyway when Mad gets tired of waiting. I'm considering switching my vote to Mal, but will take the rest of my break to think it over. I don't like the switch, but feel as though we need to move on.