No, I was trying to get involved since this is the first real opportunity I've had to do so. If I were trying to blend in, it would be pretty stupid for me to ask a question to everyone knowing that some would try to use it against me. Like this. What are YOUR thoughts? I've already posted mine.
Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
No, I was trying to get involved since this is the first real opportunity I've had to do so. If I were trying to blend in, it would be pretty stupid for me to ask a question to everyone knowing that some would try to use it against me. Like this. What are YOUR thoughts? I've already posted mine.
Had to go get the kid i bed finally.
I think Dawg pushed a bit for DD's lynching. Right after night 1 he put the idea out that it would be just like DD to put a hit on Eddie to cover herself. But somehow he didn't vote her first. I need to look closer at him.
Something strange is going on w/JL. He's started out playing very aggressively and voted to save himself. He seemed to want to stir things up w/JP and Noodles and then again earlier w/Cat and myself about the present scenario. He seemed to be enjoying the confusion.
You and Sploke have been quiet up until this afternoon when the present scenario unfolded. I have you leaning more evil than him b/c you shoulld know better than to just wanna follow along. Just following along doesn't generate any useful info. Maybe you are pressed for time in RL, but then maybe you are hiding out as well.
I am still looking at the others including Piggy, but nothing strikes me about them yet. I have to look at DD's posts again but didn't find anything to indicate that she had investigated an evil.
I think Dawg pushed a bit for DD's lynching. Right after night 1 he put the idea out that it would be just like DD to put a hit on Eddie to cover herself. But somehow he didn't vote her first. I need to look closer at him.
Something strange is going on w/JL. He's started out playing very aggressively and voted to save himself. He seemed to want to stir things up w/JP and Noodles and then again earlier w/Cat and myself about the present scenario. He seemed to be enjoying the confusion.
You and Sploke have been quiet up until this afternoon when the present scenario unfolded. I have you leaning more evil than him b/c you shoulld know better than to just wanna follow along. Just following along doesn't generate any useful info. Maybe you are pressed for time in RL, but then maybe you are hiding out as well.
I am still looking at the others including Piggy, but nothing strikes me about them yet. I have to look at DD's posts again but didn't find anything to indicate that she had investigated an evil.
Here's my top 3...
1. Piggy - I think DD investigated them and then put a vote on them. The vote for Cat before the reveal by delivery of the present is another strike. The third strike is this quote which is out of left field somewhere...
^^ I take it he meant Dawg.
2. Plant - I think Plant has been trying to stop Cat from helping us win this game. Cat is the only confirmed innocent who has someone else on their side to communicate with. They have a big advantage over us because they can communicate without the evils seeing it in this thread.
3. JL - I'm really not sure though.
1. Piggy - I think DD investigated them and then put a vote on them. The vote for Cat before the reveal by delivery of the present is another strike. The third strike is this quote which is out of left field somewhere...
^^ I take it he meant Dawg.
2. Plant - I think Plant has been trying to stop Cat from helping us win this game. Cat is the only confirmed innocent who has someone else on their side to communicate with. They have a big advantage over us because they can communicate without the evils seeing it in this thread.
3. JL - I'm really not sure though.
This in bold really bothers me, Plant. Why would DD want to give any clue that she was Santa so early in the game? She is the only innocent that could investigate. If she said anything she would be hit by the mafia.
How am I stopping Cat from helping the town. I think I may have helped Cat establish his confirmed communicating innocent status. I played that role last year's game so knew he needed to name the person he sent the present to. I'm glad he worked it out w/RB. The present scenario is finished IMO. R U trying to stir something up again?
It is not uncommon for players to scour over other players posts once they are lynched or hit to see if they can find some leads to go on. Why are u so apposed to it? Are you afraid I will find something she wrote about you?
I'm not trying to stir anything up. Vote for me if you like. You were the one pressing Cat to reveal information when he wasn't comfortable doing so. The reveal worked because RB confirmed it. Your plan was for the person who received the gift to confirm it. I like the way things worked out. I also think you seem very opposed to Cat's list. It could be because you are #2 on his list. It seems you are #2 on several people's lists.
If DD knew something about me I'm sure she would have voted for me. You said you are going back to see where she implied she investigated Piggy. I don't think DD would imply that because she would know she would be the mafia's next hit. Look all you want Plant. I'm not hiding anything but I think you are.
Why are you not voting for Piggy? You may be better off in this game if you just take one of your own out in the lynch. Then you will be less suspicious. C'mon, Plant. Vote with DD (Santa) and lynch one of your own. Vote for Piggy.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
1. Piggy - I am fairly sure everyone has pig pretty high on their list, and those that didn't do now. For what ever reason, pig has been hard on me. I am a little nervous about the idea that once he is found to be evil that I will be blamed for some sort of distancing and be a suspect. I think pig was told by his teamates to go after me.
2. Plant - The more she types, the more the evil spills out. I think you should save yourself and open the present. Plant sure got active once cat said he was an innocent. Has placed the most doubt on the situation. She screams of mafia even more than noodles did.
3. Fire - the main reason is that plant just through her name out there. There are others that have not posted much, but she throws Fire's name out there. I am still kinda leary about that day one scaled list. Fire has not had much input. I think Fire's vote on Pig was distancing. I doubt if she would vote pig in a close vote. Fire has done well to lay low. Maybe the grinch? Maybe another power role...
2. Plant - The more she types, the more the evil spills out. I think you should save yourself and open the present. Plant sure got active once cat said he was an innocent. Has placed the most doubt on the situation. She screams of mafia even more than noodles did.
3. Fire - the main reason is that plant just through her name out there. There are others that have not posted much, but she throws Fire's name out there. I am still kinda leary about that day one scaled list. Fire has not had much input. I think Fire's vote on Pig was distancing. I doubt if she would vote pig in a close vote. Fire has done well to lay low. Maybe the grinch? Maybe another power role...
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Here is a thought,
Let's get it to a tie between pig and plant. With plant voting for pig.
She can open the gift and have a chance of her vote counting double or get turned.
Then we will know what gift was used.
I think plant should be more than willing at the town's request to open her gift. Cat sent it to her for a reason. I think it would be rude for her not to open it.
Let's get it to a tie between pig and plant. With plant voting for pig.
She can open the gift and have a chance of her vote counting double or get turned.
Then we will know what gift was used.
I think plant should be more than willing at the town's request to open her gift. Cat sent it to her for a reason. I think it would be rude for her not to open it.
Dawg Im going to say this about DD's second night vote it could have proven someone innocent as well as evil there is no straight answer off what she did only her and rb knows and Rb aint telling.
