Mafia #44 Christmas At ACville

[Hooked Newbie]

Maybe I missed her "case". Maybe you can explain it better to me. I was laughing too much.

I have responded. HN, if you really think plant and I are inter-changeable, then by all means, vote for me. The third evil is still in hiding.

I actually wanted to see your response first John and I must say that the flippant attitude seems quite a bit out of the norm for you. You usually have the ability to actually make logical arguments and now all you can do is laugh and ask for me to vote for you? I may yet.

game off///

I have to leave to catch my flight. I realy should be already at the airport. I might post from Houston, I will be home before nightfall.

game on////

Got the flight number handy? :lipssealedsmilie:

 

[piggy67]

I'm going to go ahead and get this out. I will be on again later, but I'm not sure how much time I'll have to review in detail. (Last day of finals for Sev so we WILL be partying).

I vote to lynch piggy.

I'd be willing to change to either of my other top 3 based on new posts and how / if the town comes together. I am also looking forward to seeing JL's response to Plant's post. They may be inter-changeable for me on my list after seeing her case.

is this a "hunch" thing,i see no evidence to support that,just because you haven't been in the game much,and don't know who is evil or not,you just pick me at random.that's ok...my innocense will come out soon enough.you one of those in the chat with plant,plotting to lynch yet another innocent?

 

[catfish69hunter]

Hey all is ask is after this turn of events and the scrambling the mafia is doing I would like to know if oyu guys could post the evil chat thread after the game for me?

 

[Madcrawdad]

Ok, I have some time this evening while she is studying for finals.

I'd like to propose something and am totally open for feedback. The best chance we have to turn this around and score a town victory is to play as a team and by consensus. With Cat's claims confirmed, we need to follow his lead. I am willing to vote for whomever on his list he is most sure of as evil (even if that's me). If his list is good, it should work out easily in our favor and based on what I've seen I think it's a pretty good list.

Would everyone else be willing to follow that plan? Why or why not? Feedback? Better ideas?

Hooked if you still around my opinion on you is as follows. I believe just following my list right off the bat is wrong. Now we have one less to worry about in me I want to hear everyones reasons for who they think are their top suspects. I feel that this will bring to light a lot of peoples ideas and It will bring out the liars.

SO everyone who is your top 3 and why?

I know it's been mentioned, but blindly following Cat is a bad idea. While Cat is a known innocent, and the motives behind his input are honest, just following blindly presents two problems, as I see it:

1. Cat could be wrong... by blindly following Cat, everyone stops looking on their own.

2. With the whole town following, there'll be no differentiation in votes to examine, after the fact. If all scum hop on after Cat does, we learn nothing new.

As his motives are in the town's best interests, I think it's wise that people weigh his input more heavily than others, but continue to think for themselves.

----------

As far as my list of top 3 at this point:

1. Dawg - the late kill vote on DD was REALLY scummy. And the vote for himself along with the 'I had a 50/50 chance,' only make it worse.

He also started pushing for DD early on Day 2, based on the fact that Eddie got hit.

Well...here's my thoughts on Eddie being hit. It seems to me it would be for one of two reasons. Since DD seems to have had the most interaction with him as of late it was to either set her up or to take her off the radar. If she is evil I can easily see her hitting Eddie so the excuse can be "Do you think I would be that dumb to hit Eddie when I was the one arguing with him". On the other hand if she is innocent it may be a good way to get more heat on DD. Since Eddie already had the heat on him for day two I'm leaning more with DD being evil but I'll just have to wait and see what happens.

Oh yeah...Noods is running a close second for me.

2. Piggy - early on DD, and cast the 1st vote for her with not a very strong reason. Seems odd, seeing that he was all over JL on Day 1. To seemingly jump on DD out of thin air looks suspicious

DD you seem to act like your very distressed by this very bad turn of events.i think maybe too much.i'm keeping my eye on you from now on.

DD,you was all over 3l,and for that matter Eddie as well,now i can see your evil plan,i knew it was just a matter of time,two innocents killed and your tring to be soo broken up about it!hmmmmm.maybe i was wrong about JL,time will tell;but for now I retract my vote to lynch Jl and vote to lynch DD

3. No firm 3rd here:

- Sploke, he really seems to have given a few qualifications for his vote on DD. 1st he qualifies that he doesn't want to align himself with Piggy, yet he does and 2nd he makes it sound like he doesn't really want to lynch DD....just wants to make the voting closer and see what happens. Yet, he rides the vote to nightfall.

At the risk of aligning myself with piggy, I vote to lynch DD. Mostly just to bring her into the race a little right now to see what happens.

- JL, his vote switch on Day 1 to save himself, falls way outside of what he's done in the past.

---------------

With that said, I vote to lynch Dawg


Just to give folks a heads up, I've been home with 2 sick kids for the past 2 days, and am sick myself....get your flu shots, people. I'm still a little behind on reading/digesting posts from late last night and today, but will hopefully be able to weigh in before nightfall.

 

[johnlarson66]

I actually wanted to see your response first John and I must say that the flippant attitude seems quite a bit out of the norm for you. You usually have the ability to actually make logical arguments and now all you can do is laugh and ask for me to vote for you? I may yet.



Got the flight number handy? :lipssealedsmilie:

I am flying out of Atlanta and my flight is delayed. CO 5973 It was supposed to depart at noon, now it is delayed.

I think one can say that my game play the last two games has been out of the norm for me. This has been established. I also voted 3L to save my own neck.

I can usually have the ability to make logical arguments, when the person I am argueing with has some sort of logic themselves. All I really can do is laugh. I didn't see one valid point in her "case". There are way better cases to be made against me than the junk plant came up with. She is squirming and there is only my vote on her.

 

[johnlarson66]

Mad, what do you think of plant?

 

[johnlarson66]

So the team is me, dawg and pig?

Is that the plan?

 

[plantling]

That is some funny stuff.

What a way to start my day off with a smile. Pig, I look forward to you playing more in the future.

Plant, the best you have on me is some day one posts? You can do better than that! Why do you refuse to vote for pig?

I think you should atleast vote for each other.

Plant, your attempt to put me and pig as teamates is about one of the most drastic attempts to date. I think your team has done well and I think that finding the third evil will be hard.

I have not said I refuse to vote for Pig. I said since you had your vote on them that I was not inclined to vote the same way as you as you are one of my top suspects.

plant, i don't know why you keep saying "see, i helped to make sure cat is a confirmed innocent now." you had nothing to do with it - RB posted that the present was delivered to you, which confirmed what cat said.

If Cat had not stated in the thread that he sent it to me, and I did bug him to name the person he sent it to, then anyone could say they sent the present to me. As far as I could tell Cat wasn't going to name me until shortly before nightfall. That would have been after RB's announcement. Also Rudolph needed to send in his protection b4 nightfall. Understand?

soo plant have you seen me in the chat room?if sooo you are imagining things-you and your buddies

Haven't seen you or anyone in any chat room. But I think with all this "open the present" I'm getting from some of you, you sure would like me to join u.




Speaking of joining evils, I have a choice to make and hopefully it will be for the best...

I am Blitzen.

I have a tough choice to make tonight. I think I have a good hold on who some innocents are. I will let the town know which person I picked shortly b4 nightfall. I hope the person I pick is the same person they decide to hit and so we only lose one innocent, that's why I don't want to say who now, though I have a good idea who they would want gone. If nobody dies from being coaled then you will know I have been turned. Feel free to lynch me tomorrow and obviously the person I picked would be evil as well. Though I am an innocent I do not have investigative abilities. I don't want pple to just follow my lead. I want you to read the thread and come up with your own conclusions. They may choose to hit me now but better that than any of our power roles.

That said, I vote to lynch Dawg.

 

[plantling]

So the team is me, dawg and pig?

Is that the plan?

What are your thoughts on Dawg?

 

[johnlarson66]

What are your thoughts on Dawg?

I think dawg could be evil. He was one of the first to point out the DD and eddie conection makeing DD look evil.

I wonder if someone else will claim to be Blitzen.

Blitzen, an Innocent, is still really upset over that night where Rudolph got to lead the sleigh. He was over looked for the task, pushed aside for a pretty face. He has a lump of coal. His lump of coal, when delivered, will kill an Innocent Townie. If delivered to the Grinch, or an Evil Elf, Blitzen will join the Evil Elves. This lump of coal must be delivered on game night 2 or 3. If Blitzen doesn't tell me who gets it, I will randomly PM a person on line and let them decide who gets it.

Maybe one of my evil teamates will.