Mafia 46: In the Dark

[dirtydawg10]

Well as far as I can see I could just as easy start calling out people for not putting out votes and for posting up useless no content posts and even for saying that my vote makes DD look innocent. For a start there are two mafia tonight and I don't know how many players so statistically you just think about it.

Why are you so reluctant to give any sort of reasoning for your vote? The reason people are not just throwing out votes on people is because there is only 1 retraction in this game. You wouldn't be getting a hard time if you would let us in on why you voted the way you did.

 

[luckydud13]

just trying to read your post correctly, who is "they" and "we"?

They is Maelstrom, did not know gender, and did not want to be grammatically incorrect. We is we players that are wondering why he/she voted for dangerdoll

 

[jbradt]

Well as far as I can see I could just as easy start calling out people for not putting out votes and for posting up useless no content posts and even for saying that my vote makes DD look innocent. For a start there are two mafia tonight and I don't know how many players so statistically you just think about it.

Right, there are 2 mafia tonight. Statistically, voting at random we have a good chance to lynch an innocent. And, there's no such thing as a useless post in this game. Every post gives a little more info about a player. Just because we can't make sense of it now is no reason to call it useless.

I still haven't seen a reason you voted DD. Admittedly, I've been in and out quickly today... maybe I missed it.

 

[Jarred Darque]

jeezus people stop posting so much! I dont like coming back to 6 pages of reading with no real information....

 

[jbradt]

Nope, went back and checked. Didn't miss it. :dance:

 

[rich311k]

jeezus people stop posting so much! I dont like coming back to 6 pages of reading with no real information....

If we didn't post we would not find out anything about anyone. Have you got a theory?

 

[luckydud13]

jeezus people stop posting so much! I dont like coming back to 6 pages of reading with no real information....

What were doing is better than sitting back and not doing anything while innocents get lynched. At least were getting somewhere. If ou don't like reading so much, ou shouldn't have joined a mafia game cause thats what their all about my friend.

 

[IceH2O]

jeezus people stop posting so much! I dont like coming back to 6 pages of reading with no real information....

If you go user control panel>edit options>Thread Display Options you can have each page hold 40 posts, used to be 100, makes it seem like less reading .

 

[[AC] C-note]

I think that by voting without stating reasons is scummy...yes. Because the idea of the game is to get ideas out there so we can help the town figure out who the evils are. It seems to me like someone starting a train.

Saying that something smells like someone starting a train shows that you've got fairly strong feelings about maelstrom possibly being mafia...heck, you even lean DD innocent. For some reason, though, you don't really ever mention your thoughts on maelstrom.

Interesting vote but I'm not sure what you see with DD because you never mentioned it. I usually tend to think DD is evil for some reason...mostly because she is hard to read but this vote with no explanation has her leaning more innocent to me now. I guess only time will tell.

In this post, you kind of express mild agreement with maelstrom that DD always seems guilty, but go onto say that maelstrom's vote kind of inspires you to move DD up a notch toward innocent. You never come right out and call maelstrom's move scummy, though, but apparently you really think it is.

In this game, the main idea is to lynch your best suspects so it seems odd that you'd take the time to lean DD innocent in your post, but not try to go after maelstrom at all. This looks like a possible attempt to blend; cuddling up to DD while not really pointing that strong of a finger at maelstrom...leaving it for others to lead that charge.

It is never too early to vote. Voting early does tend to get people talking at least. Hopefully something good can come from it.

Now here's a follow-up post explaining how early votes are good for getting people talking, and hoping something good comes from maelstrom's early vote. You still don't look to be taking much of a stand on maelstrom here. Odd since you find mael's actions scummy enough to move DD up on the innocent scale.

Makes me move you down a little toward mafia, Dawg.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

It is never too early to vote. Voting early does tend to get people talking at least. Hopefully something good can come from it.

This is a good point dirtydawg.

That was interesting, I am curious about the logic for that as well. I have started sorting some idea of who may be mafia scum, need to keep studying the posts.

I don't think its that interesting.

I would also like to see Maelstrom's reason for voting to lynch DD...seems pretty random.

Yes I would like some clarification of that vote, we still have another day to see if anything happens. Seems a little early to be voting on the little bit we have to go on. Seems like something someone would do to distract everyone from something, but i dont see anything that he/she would what to distract everyone from.

Interesting vote but I'm not sure what you see with DD because you never mentioned it. I usually tend to think DD is evil for some reason...mostly because she is hard to read but this vote with no explanation has her leaning more innocent to me now. I guess only time will tell.

You have still not answered the direct question below.

Dawg, you mention that maelstrom's vote for DD, without a reason, makes DD seem more innocent to you. I'm assuming then that you think maelstrom's move was pretty scummy. Is that assumption correct?

That is this question.

That was.......uncalled for, what exactly might he be covering up for? And more importantly who is he covering up for. Dangerdoll to me has really not made any headway whether she is mafia or innocent, unless they know something we don't.

Nobody knows anything except two mafia each know the other is mafia and two innocents know about each other.

Why are you so reluctant to give any sort of reasoning for your vote? The reason people are not just throwing out votes on people is because there is only 1 retraction in this game. You wouldn't be getting a hard time if you would let us in on why you voted the way you did.

I'm really not getting a hard time dirtydawg at all dirtydawg. You should answer your question you were asked though as it was asked directly of you and you have posted since.