Mafia 46: In the Dark

[luckydud13]

So much to think about, just got caught up again. What bothers me is that everyone is bickering to prove their innocence and no one has the goal of finding the mafia in mind.

If you want to know who's scaring me the most, well its LadyG. I know how that might sound. But think about it, she's made what a couple posts? And doing that, she has almost solidified herself against being voted out. Because noone has enough information to prove her wrong or right. At least with the people that are here now we can decipher what their saying.

But with lady G, noone wants to draw attention to themselves by blatantly throwing out a vote for her. But what the heck. I am doing this so that all the people in the game remaining will be talkative, so we can trully figure out who is who. We dont do it know, she will be a thorn in our side for the rest of the game whether you realize it or not.

I vote to lynch Lady G

 

[rich311k]

Wow we have votes and accusations flying everywhere. Some pretty thin logic but we have not all that much to go on either.

I suspect or feel mafia leanings for ogre and c-note but that just may be they are the most active.

Ogre and Noodles are on each other but they have been since almost post one. Maybe this is ruse to make us not pay that much attention to them.

Lucky and dawg have been strong in their opinions. Again is this tactics or personalities.

I must think some more on this.

 

[mostlycichlids]

Nightfall is not until tomorrow - Thursday 9 pm EST

Woops i forgot, working swing shift at work two days two nights got me confused.

MC, you've gone from a late 'random' vote yesterday, to a vote for Ogre today, with no reasoning. Interested in hearing your thoughts.

I'm also interested in hearing responses to the several unanswered questions I've posed to you over the past couple of days. I'm starting to think you're avoiding me.

Well, noodles and Ogre have been pretty much bickering back an fourth...which to me is a sing of laying low...When Ogre does reply to another person it is very short and careful. As far as the other posts you say I have been avoiding not sure what I haven't replied too that you think is so important....I really would like to be participating more but unfortunately I haven't had much of a chance...I have the next few days.

I thought you weren't arguing with me anymore



I don't know. C-note, check me on this thinking. I don't know if you've ever played before (probably), but don't you think that a mafia player is (just by being a power role) is intrinsically more interested in the game and more likely not to skim?



I too am interested in this... although it is also about the above question.

This confirms my suspicion that noodles and Ogre are trying to draw attention away from themselves

I normally wouldn't expect Dawg to skim, but his question sure looks like it.

As far as mafia members not skimming, I disagree. Some do, some don't. They still need to post, even if they're not keeping up with the reading, so when they do skim it shows.

Pretty sure you've been busted when skimming as mafia, so I'm not sure why you're even asking the question. I'm wondering now if you're not last night's turn coming to Dawg's aid.

At this point I feel pretty strongly about Dawg, and am thinking that MC and possibly yourself are his partners.

Partners? You quote here that you disagree Mafia skim then acuse Dawg and what looks like myself of skimming. You also state in this quote some don't so if this is your thoughts than why do you suspect me of being mafia for possibly skimming? I feel like you are trying to protect yourself and you talking about skimmers being mafia make me think you might be mafia.

Noodles, if anyone knows not to quote, I would think you do... this is very odd IMO for you...

interesting that as chatty as you were yesterday, this is pretty much all you've said today... before you claim school... what is the difference in Monday and Tuesday than today?


I don't understand the trap... I have been accused in past games of not being the brightest bulb in the closet, II guess this is one of those times... can you explain it for me?

for the day though, I have to say that I have been trying to read this thread with the open mind of 2 communicating teams. One being mafia with a turned person (who I think might be dud at this point) and one being the communicating innocents... Out of everyone I have seen, I think dud's behavior has changed drastically from one day to the next.... I have major suspicions on Ogre but bigger suspicions on C-note... The problem I have with c-note is the hard drive he is taking at dawg... for all I know, Dawg could be mafia, but the more cnote pushes on the one instance and then the process of digging for information has me most concerned.

If I were to vote today, my vote would be on c-note... second would be on Ogre... but I think I will hold onto my vote until I am more sure...

I am beginning to think the same for a lot of the same reasons. The suspicion between the two is very high IMO.

This is it, still can't get over it and the whole "Dangerdoll is innocent as they come." line. There is no way someone can make such a statment about another player unless they know someone is innocent. Only mafia or communicating innocent will know this. I don't think MC is communicating innocent. At this point I have seen nothing in DD's posts that would warrent such a comment. I would always have DD high on suspect lists, she is very good at being bad and really enjoys it. Anyone that trust DD is either naive or dangerous (I had a whole list of other words to use, but settled on dangerous).

MC I think you are dangerous and are mafia. I want to see you hang.

I would get over it seriously, it was pretty random. I have only played a few games and DD has always been an innocent....And If I was mafia and knew DD was innocent why would I not be drilling her and voting to lynch her. In fact I agree with a lot of her statements of possible mafia. Not sure why everyone is all hung up over my acuasations.

 

[mostlycichlids]

I am hoping my evil teamates CJ and Orge jump on the train I have started.

What does this statement mean exactly..."evil teammates" communicating mafia? I was thinking about changing my vote but now I think I will stick to my original thinking.

 

[Opicana]

Looks like Noods has found out about CJ and me. Even as a bonus she discovered who we recruited. I am impressed. No reason for me to talk to CJ outside the thread when we can talk in here. Might as well make all of our moves public. Ogre, don't worry about AIM, we can talk in the thread.

So since we recruited Orge, I certainly can't vote for him. Well I could, but that would be distancing. I really can't vote for noods, because she outed me. I also can't vote for CJ, becuase that would be distancing. Since I have already distanced myself from CJ and Orge I am in the clear, as long as no one listens to Noods.

Okay, this interests me. Yes, it is clear you are being sarcastic. But that would be a clever cover up....Admitting it, jokingly, would throw people off the trail that perhaps Noods picked up on...and it would be a smart way to deflect the accusation. Just a pondering....doesn't mean any of your are my top suspects.

 

[[AC] C-note]

MostlyCichlids, here are several questions I've posed to you which have gone unanswered over the past few days. If you could address them, I'd greatly appreciate it.

Sorry for the links and not actually posting the questions again, but the original posts contained some embedded quotes, and just quoting the old posts wouldn't show those quotes.

http://www.aquariacentral.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1813067&postcount=262

http://www.aquariacentral.com/forums/showpost.php?p=1814878&postcount=448

 

[noodles62]

Looks like Noods has found out about CJ and me. Even as a bonus she discovered who we recruited. I am impressed. No reason for me to talk to CJ outside the thread when we can talk in here. Might as well make all of our moves public. Ogre, don't worry about AIM, we can talk in the thread.

So since we recruited Orge, I certainly can't vote for him. Well I could, but that would be distancing. I really can't vote for noods, because she outed me. I also can't vote for CJ, becuase that would be distancing. Since I have already distanced myself from CJ and Orge I am in the clear, as long as no one listens to Noods.

I vote to lynch mostlycichlids.

Something just doesn't sit right, not sure what it is. There is a post that struck a nerve, I will quote it.

I wanted to get my vote out, I am traveling for the next week, but will be able to post at night.

:lol: Did I strike a nerve, John?

 

[[AC] C-note]

Rich, here are some of your thoughts on other players from yesterday. Please note and explain the MAJOR INCONSISTENCIES. Keep in mind, these are posts are all from the SAME day:


Here you say that you think Ogre is innocent.

I think Ogre is innocent, he just enjoys talking and analyzing probably why he is a fixture in these games. He makes some valid points. The only question I have about Ogre is was the gun thing a lets see what happens when I say this or a scheme by a veteran mafia player to remove some one they thought was dangerous.

A little later you imply that Ogre may be scum. Maybe your opinion has changed in a short time, but the interesting part is where you now say that he's been your number one suspect for a long time. Huh? You said he was innocent a little earlier in the day.

Ogre has gone out of his way to stay in the spotlight, had to tell us all that he was right and what the curerent situation is. He is firmly convinced that Noodles is the one that needs to go. How can you be that sure unless you know more than most of us can? He also does not like me because I voted for Guns. I had him number one long before he sprung his "Trap".

**********
​

Now here I seem innocent.

C-note seems innocent to me right now, we shall see.

Here I'm still innocent because I've been actively questioning other people.

C-note has been on everyone. Seems to be doing what an innocent towns person would do, try to get people to speak to see if he can pry lose that important fact that will help us come to a good decision. I would like to know what his list is currently.

Now a little later I'm possibly scum because I've been active, and Ogre is scum, too.

I suspect or feel mafia leanings for ogre and c-note but that just may be they are the most active.

Do you see the inconsistencies, Rich? And these are all from the same day (yesterday). Interesting to note that DD named myself and Ogre as suspects, and then you seem to do a complete 180 and do the same...

What gives?

 

[rich311k]

Rich, here are some of your thoughts on other players from yesterday. Please note and explain the MAJOR INCONSISTENCIES. Keep in mind, these are posts are all from the SAME day:


Here you say that you think Ogre is innocent.


A little later you imply that Ogre may be scum. Maybe your opinion has changed in a short time, but the interesting part is where you now say that he's been your number one suspect for a long time. Huh? You said he was innocent a little earlier in the day.

**********
​

Now here I seem innocent.


Here I'm still innocent because I've been actively questioning other people.


Now a little later I'm possibly scum because I've been active, and Ogre is scum, too.


Do you see the inconsistencies, Rich? And these are all from the same day (yesterday). Interesting to note that DD named myself and Ogre as suspects, and then you seem to do a complete 180 and do the same...

What gives?

The I had him number one before he sprung his trap, the him referred to Guns not Ogre. I should have stated that more clearly.

I was observing that you and Ogre were suspects or talked about a lot because you were both active and questioning.

I still think Noodles right now but that may change. Plenty of time left to make as good a guess as i can.

 

[Dangerdoll]

DD, you incorrectly lynched Gunslinger yesterday for going hard at maelstrom, and now I'm suspicious for going hard at Dawg? You'd think with your logic being so faulty with Gunslinger that you'd think twice about using a second time so quickly.

actually, I voted Guns for being a bully.... interesting trying to twist it though...