What you believe is wrong. Yes your right I am trying to set you up, to expose you for what you really are. A mafia.
Mafia 46: In the Dark
- Thread starter IceH2O
- Start date
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
So if I understand correctly, if one team recruits someone from the other team then a teamate from the choosing team dies.
So in finding out that Lady G is mafia, the communicating innocents lost one of their own.
I am fairly sure noods and lucky have spoken outside of the thread so this makes 100% sense.
I find it disturbing that a communicating innocent would vote for the same player so early in the same game and I hope the other communicating innocent has some sense.
I wish you would not have hinted or gotten around the rules.
So in finding out that Lady G is mafia, the communicating innocents lost one of their own.
I am fairly sure noods and lucky have spoken outside of the thread so this makes 100% sense.
I find it disturbing that a communicating innocent would vote for the same player so early in the same game and I hope the other communicating innocent has some sense.
I wish you would not have hinted or gotten around the rules.
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
You still have not explained to anyone really why you are so sure LG is 100% in your mind mafia....You are very defensive in your last several posts and the change just after night still bothers me.
I VOTE TO LYNCH LUCKY
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Or lucky could be saying this to save his rear...
Why would the communicating innocents want to recruit Lady G anyway, she has barely been playing.
Why would the communicating innocents want to recruit Lady G anyway, she has barely been playing.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
![[AC] C-note](/forums/data/avatars/s/83/83156.jpg?1431345517){kind=avatar}
Some thoughts regarding noodles' likely death...
Here are the 3 possibilities:
1. Noodles was a communicating innocent and the communicating innocents targeted a mafia member for recruitment last night. As a member of the CHOOSING team, she was randomly killed. In this scenario the remaining CIs now know that they targeted a mafia member last night.
2. Noodles was mafia and the mafia targeted a communicating innocent for recruitment last night. As a member of the CHOOSING team, she was randomly killed. In this scenario the CIs know that noodles was mafia, and they can examine her posts for clues.
3. Noodles was a non-communicating innocent and targeted for recruitment by both the communicating innocents AND mafia last night. In this scenario the CIs will only know that noodles was a non-communicating innocent.
I just want to get this out there, because the possibilities have been incorrectly described in several recent posts. I would encourage people to re-read the rules section regarding the death penalty for recruiting a communicating member from the opposite team. The CHOOSING team randomly loses the member, NOT the team that had the member chosen.
Here are the 3 possibilities:
1. Noodles was a communicating innocent and the communicating innocents targeted a mafia member for recruitment last night. As a member of the CHOOSING team, she was randomly killed. In this scenario the remaining CIs now know that they targeted a mafia member last night.
2. Noodles was mafia and the mafia targeted a communicating innocent for recruitment last night. As a member of the CHOOSING team, she was randomly killed. In this scenario the CIs know that noodles was mafia, and they can examine her posts for clues.
3. Noodles was a non-communicating innocent and targeted for recruitment by both the communicating innocents AND mafia last night. In this scenario the CIs will only know that noodles was a non-communicating innocent.
I just want to get this out there, because the possibilities have been incorrectly described in several recent posts. I would encourage people to re-read the rules section regarding the death penalty for recruiting a communicating member from the opposite team. The CHOOSING team randomly loses the member, NOT the team that had the member chosen.
**********
With regards to a suspect, I really like Rich for the reasons I questioned him about earlier.
I plan on taking a harder look at LG tomorrow.
I plan on taking a harder look at LG tomorrow.
For rule violations Lucky has been removed from the game
Lucky was
you'll find out at games end...
All votes for Lucky will not count and Ogre can have his retraction back.
Lucky was
you'll find out at games end...
All votes for Lucky will not count and Ogre can have his retraction back.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
I need to change my vote, Ice will this count as a retraction or will I get to change my mind.
Also, I feel a moral dilimea. I am fairly certain (and his death kinda confirms it) that Lucky was indeed a communicating innocent. I am also fairly certain that lucky was a communicating innocent. I unsure if that leaves one or two left.
Here is my problem, I just don't feel right about voting for Lady G, but I am fairly certain that she is mafia and was the recruit of Lucky noods and company. I did not have Lady G as a suspect and the only reason I would be voting for her is based on the posts from Lucky that were in violation of the rules. I feel like lynching Lady G would be cheating.
I want to see how and why Orge came up with this Lady G and Rich connection and how they were his top suspects. I most likely will vote for Rich and then the next night vote for Lady G. I have a short list of people I half-way trust and too be honest forgot who they were. I think Orge and Mael is on that list, I will find my post. This recruitment twist makes it hard to trust someone for more than a day, they could have been turned. I doubt a team would have recruited Orge, he was on the chopping block. If Orge is mafia, then I will take back forever my statement that Orge is bad at being bad.
Also, I feel a moral dilimea. I am fairly certain (and his death kinda confirms it) that Lucky was indeed a communicating innocent. I am also fairly certain that lucky was a communicating innocent. I unsure if that leaves one or two left.
Here is my problem, I just don't feel right about voting for Lady G, but I am fairly certain that she is mafia and was the recruit of Lucky noods and company. I did not have Lady G as a suspect and the only reason I would be voting for her is based on the posts from Lucky that were in violation of the rules. I feel like lynching Lady G would be cheating.
I want to see how and why Orge came up with this Lady G and Rich connection and how they were his top suspects. I most likely will vote for Rich and then the next night vote for Lady G. I have a short list of people I half-way trust and too be honest forgot who they were. I think Orge and Mael is on that list, I will find my post. This recruitment twist makes it hard to trust someone for more than a day, they could have been turned. I doubt a team would have recruited Orge, he was on the chopping block. If Orge is mafia, then I will take back forever my statement that Orge is bad at being bad.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
