Mafia #47 "Ghost Hunters"

[IceH2O]

Might as make it simple.

Now this could be twisted as a way to make it look like I am protecting the murderer, but if I have led everyone wrong, then the town can do what they will.

Here is my idea:

If you believe me, then vote for Ice.

If you don't believe me, then vote for me.

There is NO good reason to vote for anyone else.

If I have lied, you can all take Lucky's soul the next day. I will even vote Lucky since I can't vote for myself. If I lose to Ice, then you can get Ice the next day.

So please vote for either Ice or me.

Yes there is, if the murderer is killed you don't get any turns. You can't improve your numbers.

So many holes in this story.

 

[Opicana]

Yes there is, if the murderer is killed you don't get any turns. You can't improve your numbers.

So many holes in this story.

That's a very good point. If JL is evil, but not the murderer, this would be the perfect way to take one for the team and take all pressure off the murderer for another nightfall.

Hmmm....

 

[johnlarson66]

That's a very good point. If JL is evil, but not the murderer, this would be the perfect way to take one for the team and take all pressure off the murderer for another nightfall.

Hmmm....

For just one nightfall. If I have lied I will follow your vote.

 

[luckydud13]

At this point in time, we have to believe someone. The question is who is going to be our guinea pig.

 

[johnlarson66]

I can't believe anyone is believing this.

If this was true wouldn't it be a better plan, if coming out anyway, to ask the Dr to use his 2nd vial on me and switch me back to innocent so we have 3 GHs again?

Is this enough evidence that Ice has turned????

There is a better plan. Instead of voting for Ice, the Doctor can turn Ice.

I would be willing to vote for someone else, even Lucky because I know he is not the Doctor. I don't want to risk voting for the Doctor.

Now this plan is no good if the Doctor has been turned.

Then I am toast.

 

[johnlarson66]

There is a better plan. Instead of voting for Ice, the Doctor can turn Ice.

I would be willing to vote for someone else, even Lucky because I know he is not the Doctor. I don't want to risk voting for the Doctor.

Now this plan is no good if the Doctor has been turned.

Then I am toast.

This plan has too much downside. Let's just lynch me or Ice and get on with it. If the Doc is turned I will die at nightfall anyway. We can't trust for 100% the Doc has not been turned.

 

[johnlarson66]

I don't think they turned the Doctor, but I am not 100% sure. Hard to say who they would have turned. Turning two Ghost Hunters is pretty mind numbing.

I have thrown out some ideas. I am okay with some suggestions.

For those that are certain that Lucky is the murderer, then vote Lucky.

For those that are certain I am lying, vote Lucky.

For those that think I am telling the truth, vote Ice. It is not worth the risk that the Doc has been turned to expect Ice to be turned back with the vial. I am taking a big chance that I won't be protected.

 

[IceH2O]

Don't listen to him DR.

If you use the vial tonight use it on JL. I am not a GH, was never a GH and am not evil.

JL is evil and needs to be turned.


The lynch of Lucky and turning of JL will leave the evils with 1 player and no way to turn us. At that point it won't matter if the real GH come out.

 

[johnlarson66]

Don't listen to him DR.

If you use the vial tonight use it on JL. I am not a GH, was never a GH and am not evil.

JL is evil and needs to be turned.


The lynch of Lucky and turning of JL will leave the evils with 1 player and no way to turn us. At that point it won't matter if the real GH come out.

Nice try Ice.

Yep, lets just make it Lucky vs Ice.

The Doctor can use his vial the next day. Maybe our investigation will come up with an evil.

 

[IceH2O]

Nice try Ice.

Yep, lets just make it Lucky vs Ice.

The Doctor can use his vial the next day. Maybe our investigation will come up with an evil.

Thought you had an evil, me. Why do you need to find an evil for the Dr to turn?


This is getting comical.